I Wanted to Love Apple Reminders, But I Cant Trust It. @Carl_Pullein
I Wanted to Love Apple Reminders, But I Cant Trust It.  @Carl_Pullein
Uploaded December 2025 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
After two months of using Apple Reminders as my main digital task manager, I have to report that I can no longer use it. While I know many people love it, I hit a "red line" that forced me to stop the experiment.

In this video, I explain exactly why I lost trust in the app. The main issue stems from how Reminders handles rescheduling recurring tasks—often showing me tasks I’ve already pushed to the future. This quirk caused me to second-guess my daily plan, and once you lose trust in your task manager, it becomes useless.

I also discuss the clumsy UI for adding task details compared to other apps and why I’ve decided to return to Todoist.

Timestamps:

00:00 - The announcement: Why I'm stopping the experiment
00:33 - The #1 criteria for any task manager: 100% Trust
01:51 - The glitch: Rescheduling recurring tasks
02:40 - A real-world example (My CRM workflow)
04:05 - The mental cost of "Second Guessing" your list
05:46 - The UI problem: Why is adding details so complex?
07:54 - Where Reminders actually shines (Siri & Shortcuts)
08:35 - Why I'm moving back to Todoist
09:33 - Should you still use Apple Reminders?
10:05 - Update on the Apple Notes experiment

Links & Resources:

My Productivity System:
carl-pullein.thinkific.com/courses/time_based_productivity

Todoist Setup Guide:
youtu.be/p4U5pK_gsQU?si=6i_dj4pPpRdpNAaF

Subscribe for more productivity tips:
eepurl.com/cOAmvz


Note: This is purely my personal experience regarding my specific workflow. Apple Reminders is still a fantastic app for many users, specifically those just starting their productivity journey
I Wanted to Love Apple Reminders, But I Cant Trust It.How to Get Back On Track When the Wheels Come OffAre You Addicted to Checking Messages & Emails? (How to Fix It)How Swiping Between Apps Destroys Your Productivity (And How to Fix It)This Apple Reminders Feature Will Change How You Work ForeverDitch the Screen: 4 Analogue Habits for 2026This Productivity Shift Will Change How You Manage TimeHow To Change The Text Size in Apple Reminders (macOS 26)The Fastest Way to Capture Tasks: Todoist Ramble GuideWhat Will They Remember about You?Why I Stopped Organising My Notes (And What I Do Instead)Projects Are Messy. (And That’s a Good Thing)
Carl Pullein |

I Wanted to Love Apple Reminders, But I Can't Trust It.

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER