I Hired 15 Welders To Make The Same Thing. Heres What Happened. @FireballTool
I Hired 15 Welders To Make The Same Thing. Heres What Happened.  @FireballTool
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
JOIN OUR DISCUSSION ON THE FIREBALL FORUM
https://fireball.discourse.group/t/15-fabricators-one-project-15-different-ways-to-build-it-which-process-actually-wins/4519

WANT TO BE IN THE NEXT EXPERIMENT?
We're looking for volunteer fabricators for the next round of this test. Email fireballframes@gmail.com with your shop info, the tools and table you use, a few photos, and why you want to take part.

15 fabricators, one identical welding project, and 30 finished frames measured on a CMM. We tested fixture tables vs. plate steel to find out which fabrication process is the fastest, the most accurate, and the most profitable.

A few years ago, I built a square frame on my fixture table, and a lot of you told me you could build it just as fast with a flat steel table and a tape measure. So I started testing it, and after four different tests, nobody had built the part correctly. This time I sent 15 volunteers the same drawings, material, and instructions. Each built two matching angled square-tube frames in their own shop, on camera, with a clock running. Setups included plain plate steel, Fireball, Siegmund, BuildPro, Certiflat, and generic fixture tables. I judged every frame blind.

There were two catches. The drawings called out every length and angle but gave NO tolerance, so each fabricator had to decide what "good enough" meant. And every box had two parts cut wrong on purpose: correct length, wrong miter angle.

In this video you'll see:
- How 15 fabricators approached the same drawing, from "cowboy" welding on plate steel to a plasma-cut template for placing fixtures
- Who caught the miscut parts before welding, and who didn't
- Using a fixture map to build the part on the table before any material goes down
- MIG vs. TIG: how welding process choice affected build time
- Weld sequencing: why you weld the outside corner first to stop tube roll and twist (More on weld sequencing: youtube.com/shorts/yCsSC4tLoP8)
- Heat shrinking, and why you shouldn't check flatness while the part is still hot
- A blind customer inspection of all 30 frames, and why the "deluxe cheeseburger" isn't what the customer ordered
- Build times from 58 minutes to 4 hours 22 minutes (average: 2 hours 22 minutes)
- Grinding time: about 17 minutes on average, up to 47 minutes for some
- Results by process, and how much each fabricator effectively earned per hour

CHAPTERS
0:00 Intro
8:38 The Fabricators
13:08 The Experiment
53:08 Post-Experiment Questions
59:16 Measuring the Frames
1:18:04 The Data
1:29:06 Who Made the Most Money?
1:30:20 Join the Next Experiment

TOOLS FEATURED
Fixture tooling (tooth blocks, fence blocks, risers, clamps): fireballtool.com/products/table-fixture-start-kit-plus
Fireball fixture tables: fireballtool.com/collections/fixture-systems?_pos=1&_psq=fixture%20table&_ss=e&_v=1.0
Fireball Magic Square: fireballtool.com/products/magic-square
Maximus Clamps: fireballtool.com/products/maximus-clamp-kit-set-of-2

Need a fixture map for your own project on a Fireball table? Ask on the Fireball Tool Forum: https://fireball.discourse.group

Thank you to all 15 volunteers for putting their work on full display. Leave them a thank-you in the comments!

Safety: Wear proper eye, hand, and hearing protection when welding and grinding.

#Welding #Fabrication #FixtureTable #science
I Hired 15 Welders To Make The Same Thing. Heres What Happened.Cutting Glass For Our Starship Portal!Turning A Wood Floor Into A Spaceship Deck!We Cut Out Glass For The Starmap!Whats a shifter lifter? DIY go-kart belt grinder build!Every Sci-Fi Office Starts With The Basics!What is this table hiding?Have You Seen This New Square? Fireball Miter Square!This Tables Price Is Insane! New Fireball Standard Duty Table.Should you bolt your table to the floor?Are you shopping for a fixture welding table?Why Can’t You Just Cut the Corner Off a Speed Square?
Fireball Tool |

I Hired 15 Welders To Make The Same Thing. Here's What Happened.

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER