Uploaded November 2024 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
What’s the most unusual thing you’ve ever found at a garage sale? For Stuart McDaniel, it wasn’t just a knickknack or vintage appliance—it was an entire abandoned church.
Join us as we follow Stewart and Katie McDaniel, and find out whether or not they made an impulsive decision they would come to regret or follow through with plans that will preserve an important part of Tulsa history. We will show you The Second Presbyterian Church, from its vibrant beginnings in 1917 to its closure in 2004, this once-thriving church has seen it all: community growth, urban decline, and a surprising rebirth.
In this video, we uncover the stories behind this architectural gem, explore its unique challenges, and reveal Stuart’s bold vision to transform it into a living community center. Along the way, we’ll share rare historical insights, stunning visuals, and interviews with those passionate about saving this piece of Tulsa's history.
📜 Chapters:
00:00 - Garage Sale Surprise: Buying a Church
00:48 - Welcome to Second Presbyterian Church
02:51 - Early History: Founding and Growth
05:30 - Challenges: Decline and Urban Renewal
08:32 - Many Charitable Organizations started here
10:30 - Becoming Abandoned, What now?
11:38 - Preservation is Important / Future Projects
12:55 - LGBTQ Congregation that took over
Find the websites and socials of all 6 states here: AbandonedAtlas.com/links
Feature Documentary on a really cool abandoned hotel!
amazon.com/Forever-Majestic-Caitlen-Taylor/dp/B09VB6R4J7
Sponsor a future episode of Abandoned Atlas!
abandonedatlas.com/sponsor-aaf
Video Produced by: Prairie Nation Creative - prairie-creative.com
Historic Photos: Judy Barto Collection - Museum of Tulsa History
Want to support the Abandoned Atlas Foundation? Think about donating to our cause or buying a book as a different form of donating! Our shop is equipped to accept all major credit cards, Afterpay, Cash App, Venmo, and Paypal.
Shop Our Books - AbandonedAtlas.com/shop
Donate to our Cause!
Venmo - @AbandonedAtlas
Cash App - $AbandonedAtlas
Paypal - paypal.com/donate/?token=ovemMoyczre9Oailu8_IMrDXPf8rOergEEnJOhyoJfQ8PN_8aQUEQS0rsQc79EIBHKhzCGBhSXe0lIAS&locale.x=US
What’s the most unusual thing you’ve ever found at a garage sale? For Stuart McDaniel, it wasn’t just a knickknack or vintage appliance—it was an entire abandoned church.
Join us as we follow Stewart and Katie McDaniel, and find out whether or not they made an impulsive decision they would come to regret or follow through with plans that will preserve an important part of Tulsa history. We will show you The Second Presbyterian Church, from its vibrant beginnings in 1917 to its closure in 2004, this once-thriving church has seen it all: community growth, urban decline, and a surprising rebirth.
In this video, we uncover the stories behind this architectural gem, explore its unique challenges, and reveal Stuart’s bold vision to transform it into a living community center. Along the way, we’ll share rare historical insights, stunning visuals, and interviews with those passionate about saving this piece of Tulsa's history.
📜 Chapters:
00:00 - Garage Sale Surprise: Buying a Church
00:48 - Welcome to Second Presbyterian Church
02:51 - Early History: Founding and Growth
05:30 - Challenges: Decline and Urban Renewal
08:32 - Many Charitable Organizations started here
10:30 - Becoming Abandoned, What now?
11:38 - Preservation is Important / Future Projects
12:55 - LGBTQ Congregation that took over
Find the websites and socials of all 6 states here: AbandonedAtlas.com/links
Feature Documentary on a really cool abandoned hotel!
amazon.com/Forever-Majestic-Caitlen-Taylor/dp/B09VB6R4J7
Sponsor a future episode of Abandoned Atlas!
abandonedatlas.com/sponsor-aaf
Video Produced by: Prairie Nation Creative - prairie-creative.com
Historic Photos: Judy Barto Collection - Museum of Tulsa History
Want to support the Abandoned Atlas Foundation? Think about donating to our cause or buying a book as a different form of donating! Our shop is equipped to accept all major credit cards, Afterpay, Cash App, Venmo, and Paypal.
Shop Our Books - AbandonedAtlas.com/shop
Donate to our Cause!
Venmo - @AbandonedAtlas
Cash App - $AbandonedAtlas
Paypal - paypal.com/donate/?token=ovemMoyczre9Oailu8_IMrDXPf8rOergEEnJOhyoJfQ8PN_8aQUEQS0rsQc79EIBHKhzCGBhSXe0lIAS&locale.x=US










