Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Crime statistics are used by politicians, researchers and law enforcement to advocate for public policies, funding, resources and reforms to the justice system. Journalists are often tasked with contextualizing this data, but separating the truth from political bluster can be tricky.
In this webinar, hosted by The Marshall Project and The Journalist’s Resource, a panel of experts discuss how to identify flaws in crime data, interpret trends in the data and fact-check claims from officials about public safety. Much of what they cover is included in this toolkit for journalists and researchers on how to report on local crime data: themarshallproject.org/2026/10/16/crime-rates-violent-public-safety
If you’re interested in examining FBI crime data, The Marshall Project also has a toolkit for that: themarshallproject.org/2026/10/16/fbi-crime-statistics-nibrs-police
2:51 Narratives about public safety during the 2026 midterm elections
6:25 Why crime data is complicated
8:34 Pitfalls for journalists to avoid when reporting on crime data
13:21 Patterns in crime data
24:14 Exploring falling crime rates in recent years
32:23 How can reporters evaluate claims about crime made by local officials?
53:29 While U.S. crime is trending down, why do people still feel unsafe?
For additional information, check out our resource list, which captures all the resources shared during the event: docs.google.com/document/d/1Cs9aMGHLAL7iVfDaLqfFp0ImnXdoAGXLRygkNl6wrVc/edit?usp=sharing
Here’s more information about each of our speakers:
Jeff Asher is co-founder of AH Datalytics (ahdatalytics.com/about), a criminal justice data analytics firm, and he is a nationally recognized crime data analyst. He previously served as a crime analyst for the city of New Orleans and publishes a newsletter, Jeff-alytics, that explores the nuances of working with crime data: jasher.substack.com
Jeffrey A. Butts is the executive director of the John Jay Research and Evaluation Center (https://johnjayrec.nyc/) and a research professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice who studies the effectiveness of justice system policies and programs. He has consulted with journalists on the framing and methodology of crime data analysis.
Moderator Jill Castellano is a data reporter for The Marshall Project (themarshallproject.org/). Castellano reports on the uses and misuses of criminal justice data in American society. Her stories cover crime statistics, policing, the perception of crime and the broader criminal justice system. She is the author of two toolkits for journalists and researchers on how to examine and report on crime data. Prior to journalism, Castellano studied criminology and worked in a crime research lab.
Thaddeus Johnson is a senior fellow for the Council on Criminal Justice (counciloncj.org/). Johnson is also an associate professor of criminal justice and criminology at Georgia State University, a former law enforcement official in Tennessee, and an expert on policing, crime control and governance equity. His research focuses on police lethality and coercion, street violence, recidivism, algorithmic and predictive bias, and correctional control.
With Investigate This!, see everything you need to turn our criminal justice reporting into stories for your community: themarshallproject.org/investigate-this?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tmp-youtube-videos
The Marshall Project’s investigative journalism often sparks change by shining a light on injustice — with your support: themarshallproject.org/donate?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tmp-youtube-videos
More from us:
themarshallproject.org/newsletters
instagram.com/marshallproj
reddit.com/user/marshall_project
tiktok.com/@marshallproj
facebook.com/TheMarshallProject.org
threads.net/@marshallproj
Crime statistics are used by politicians, researchers and law enforcement to advocate for public policies, funding, resources and reforms to the justice system. Journalists are often tasked with contextualizing this data, but separating the truth from political bluster can be tricky.
In this webinar, hosted by The Marshall Project and The Journalist’s Resource, a panel of experts discuss how to identify flaws in crime data, interpret trends in the data and fact-check claims from officials about public safety. Much of what they cover is included in this toolkit for journalists and researchers on how to report on local crime data: themarshallproject.org/2026/10/16/crime-rates-violent-public-safety
If you’re interested in examining FBI crime data, The Marshall Project also has a toolkit for that: themarshallproject.org/2026/10/16/fbi-crime-statistics-nibrs-police
2:51 Narratives about public safety during the 2026 midterm elections
6:25 Why crime data is complicated
8:34 Pitfalls for journalists to avoid when reporting on crime data
13:21 Patterns in crime data
24:14 Exploring falling crime rates in recent years
32:23 How can reporters evaluate claims about crime made by local officials?
53:29 While U.S. crime is trending down, why do people still feel unsafe?
For additional information, check out our resource list, which captures all the resources shared during the event: docs.google.com/document/d/1Cs9aMGHLAL7iVfDaLqfFp0ImnXdoAGXLRygkNl6wrVc/edit?usp=sharing
Here’s more information about each of our speakers:
Jeff Asher is co-founder of AH Datalytics (ahdatalytics.com/about), a criminal justice data analytics firm, and he is a nationally recognized crime data analyst. He previously served as a crime analyst for the city of New Orleans and publishes a newsletter, Jeff-alytics, that explores the nuances of working with crime data: jasher.substack.com
Jeffrey A. Butts is the executive director of the John Jay Research and Evaluation Center (https://johnjayrec.nyc/) and a research professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice who studies the effectiveness of justice system policies and programs. He has consulted with journalists on the framing and methodology of crime data analysis.
Moderator Jill Castellano is a data reporter for The Marshall Project (themarshallproject.org/). Castellano reports on the uses and misuses of criminal justice data in American society. Her stories cover crime statistics, policing, the perception of crime and the broader criminal justice system. She is the author of two toolkits for journalists and researchers on how to examine and report on crime data. Prior to journalism, Castellano studied criminology and worked in a crime research lab.
Thaddeus Johnson is a senior fellow for the Council on Criminal Justice (counciloncj.org/). Johnson is also an associate professor of criminal justice and criminology at Georgia State University, a former law enforcement official in Tennessee, and an expert on policing, crime control and governance equity. His research focuses on police lethality and coercion, street violence, recidivism, algorithmic and predictive bias, and correctional control.
With Investigate This!, see everything you need to turn our criminal justice reporting into stories for your community: themarshallproject.org/investigate-this?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tmp-youtube-videos
The Marshall Project’s investigative journalism often sparks change by shining a light on injustice — with your support: themarshallproject.org/donate?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tmp-youtube-videos
More from us:
themarshallproject.org/newsletters
instagram.com/marshallproj
reddit.com/user/marshall_project
tiktok.com/@marshallproj
facebook.com/TheMarshallProject.org
threads.net/@marshallproj
![Behind the Walls (1974) - Western Union And Your Love [Prison Music]
This music was composed and recorded by incarcerated artists serving time in the Texas Department of Corrections and released in 1974. It is being shared by The Marshall Project as part of Redemption Songs, a limited-run newsletter that spotlights one song each week made in prison. Spanning almost a century, we’re telling the story of mass incarceration, one song at a time.
Sign up for Redemption Songs here: https://www.themarshallproject.org/newsletters/redemption-songs?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tmp-youtube-videos
From the jacket copy: “The lyrics have a special meaning to these musicians; they are lyrics lived by the composers. Some are sad songs, but some have the flicker of hope that reflects the inner thoughts of incarcerates who some day will again be free to use their God-given musical talents.”
Huntsville, TDC, J.D.Thomas, vocalist and composer
Someone in My Arms, Paul Bailey, vocalist and composer
Here Comes Warden Walker, J.D. Thomas, composer
I Can’t Be Myself Without You, Jack Collins, vocalist and composer
Comin’ Home, Jack Sims, Vocalist and Composer
Western Union and Your Love, Paul Bailey, vocalist and composer
Wait for Me, J.D. Thomas, Jack Sims, vocalists; J.D. Thomas, composer
I’ve Been a Loser, Jack Collins, vocalist and composer
Will I Be the One, Jack Sims, vocalist and composer
Bar Room Angel, J.D. Thomas, vocalist and composer
Fort Wayne, J.D. Thomas, vocalist and composer
Play That Song Again, Sam, J.D. Thomas, vocalist and composer
No One But You, Claude Reneau, vocalist; J.D. Thomas, composer
If I Had the Right, Paul Bailey, vocalist; Jack Sims, composer
Picking My Way Back to You, J.D.Thomas, vocalist and composer
Stuck Out, J.D. Thomas, composer
Personnel:
Paul Bailey, vocalist
Jimmy Cikalo, drums
Jack Collins, vocals
Billy Huckaby, bass
Claude Reneau, guitar & vocals
Jack Sims, bass & vocals
John D. Thomas, guitar & vocals
Engineers: Steve Gates, Tom Miller, Paul Comstock
The Marshall Projects investigative journalism often sparks change by shining a light on injustice — with your support: https://www.themarshallproject.org/donate?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tmp-youtube-videos
More from us:
https://www.instagram.com/marshallproj
https://www.reddit.com/user/marshall_project
https://www.tiktok.com/@marshallproj
https://www.facebook.com/TheMarshallProject.org/
https://www.themarshallproject.org/newsletters
https://www.bsky.app/profile/themarshallproject.org Behind the Walls (1974) - Western Union And Your Love [Prison Music]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/g3squNv-esI/mqdefault.jpg)



![Behind the Walls (1972) - Life Is A Promise [Prison Music]
This music was composed and recorded by incarcerated artists serving time in the Texas Department of Corrections and released in 1972. It is being shared by The Marshall Project as part of Redemption Songs, a limited-run newsletter that spotlights one song each week made in prison. Spanning almost a century, we’re telling the story of mass incarceration, one song at a time.
Sign up for Redemption Songs here: https://www.themarshallproject.org/newsletters/redemption-songs?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tmp-youtube-videos
Digitized in 2016 by Maurice Chammah
Claude Reneau- Lead Guitar
William McGill- Trumpet
Herbert McKinley- Lead Guitar & Banjo
Benny Medina- Drums
John Frederick- Valve Trombone
Morgan White- Vocals
Charles Neugent- Bass
Gwen Burgess- Tenor Saxophone
Red King- Electric Piano
Francis Owens- Trumpet
John Pruitt- Baritone Saxophone
Jack Sims- Alto Saxophone & Vocals
John Stanfield- Guiltar & Vocals
Harley Rex- Director
Behind the Walls, Composer: Claude Reneau
Sympathy, Vocals: John Stanfield, Composer: John Stanfield
Saved Myself Some Tears, Vocals: John Stanfield, Composer: John Stanfield
Happy Fool, Vocals: John Stanfield, Composer: John Stanfield & Sonny Henderson
Midnight Lace, Vocals: Dave Hendon, Composer: Dave Hendon
Give the Jukebox One More Dime, Vocals Dave Hendon, Composer: Dave Hendon
Visiting Room Rag, Composer: Claude Reneau
The Best Part of Me, Vocals Dave Hendon, Composer: Dave Hendon
Sand Song, Vocal: Morgan White, Composer: Charlotte Phelps, Arrangers: Dr. Harley Rex & John Frederick
Life is a Promise, Vocal: John Stanfield, Composer: Michael Jewell, Arrangers: Dr. Harley Rex & John Frederick
Yes, I’m Leaving You, Vocal: John Stanfield, Composer: Jack Sims
Sittin’, Thinkin’, & Wonderin’, Vocal: Jack Sims, Composer: Jack Sims
Bring This Thing Together, Vocal: John Stanfield. Composer: Bill Murdock, Arranger: Jack Sims
The Marshall Projects investigative journalism often sparks change by shining a light on injustice — with your support: https://www.themarshallproject.org/donate?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tmp-youtube-videos
More from us:
https://www.instagram.com/marshallproj
https://www.reddit.com/user/marshall_project
https://www.tiktok.com/@marshallproj
https://www.facebook.com/TheMarshallProject.org/
https://www.themarshallproject.org/newsletters
https://www.bsky.app/profile/themarshallproject.org Behind the Walls (1972) - Life Is A Promise [Prison Music]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/grP4_Z3NcoU/mqdefault.jpg)



![Morton-Shannon - Prison Rodeo Blues [Prison Music]
This music was composed and recorded by incarcerated artists serving time in the Texas Department of Corrections. It is being shared by The Marshall Project as part of Redemption Songs, a limited-run newsletter that spotlights one song each week made in prison. Spanning almost a century, we’re telling the story of mass incarceration, one song at a time.
Sign up for Redemption Songs here: https://www.themarshallproject.org/newsletters/redemption-songs?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tmp-youtube-videos
The Marshall Projects investigative journalism often sparks change by shining a light on injustice — with your support: https://www.themarshallproject.org/donate?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tmp-youtube-videos
More from us:
https://www.instagram.com/marshallproj
https://www.reddit.com/user/marshall_project
https://www.tiktok.com/@marshallproj
https://www.facebook.com/TheMarshallProject.org/
https://www.themarshallproject.org/newsletters
https://www.bsky.app/profile/themarshallproject.org Morton-Shannon - Prison Rodeo Blues [Prison Music]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/hP-qekvWveM/mqdefault.jpg)

