Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 20 hours ago
In 1897, a federal court in Indian Territory ruled that my great-great-grandmother, Evaline Goins Padilla, and her family were Choctaw by blood. Her Dawes enrollment card recorded her Choctaw blood but by 1904 that ruling was gone, and so was she, along with more than a hundred members of her extended family.
In this video I go through the actual case file, Robert Goins et al. v. The Choctaw Nation, using the attorneys' letters, the witness affidavits, and Evaline's enrollment card. Those papers show the lawyers for the Nations deciding my family were "Mexicans and negroes" before they had any testimony, and then going out to find witnesses who would say so. This is my family's story, and it's also how reclassification worked on thousands of Native families during the Dawes era.
00:00 – The Paper Trail of Reclassification
01:00 – Danielle’s Family Case & Legal Erasure
02:45 – What is Racial Reclassification?
03:45 – Land Allotment, Dawes Commission & the Curtis Act
05:08 – The Citizenship Court & The Residency Requirement
06:57 – Evaline’s Choctaw Roots & 1896 Testimony
08:47 – The 1897 Ruling Reversed
10:12 – The Financial Incentive to Exclude Claimants
10:45 – Subverting Bloodlines: "Proving" Families Were Black
12:00 – Genuine Evidence vs. Fraudulent Claims (The Caldwell Case)
14:08 – Reclassification Tools Across America (Plecker, Melungeon, Redbone)
15:56 – DNA Proof & Maternal Haplogroup C1c
17:04 – Free Genealogy Tools & Resources
17:36 – Reclaiming Forgotten History
SOURCES
Court records
Robert Goins et al. v. The Choctaw Nation, U.S. Court for the Southern District of Indian Territory, Case No. 127. Judgment entered December 21, 1897.
Choctaw and Chickasaw Citizenship Court, Case No. 31 (Goins). Motion to dismiss, May 1904, and final decree denying citizenship.
Brief for Appellees, U.S. Supreme Court, including No. 588 (Goins case).
Attorneys' case file, Melven Cornish Collection, University of Oklahoma Libraries (oku_31856), including:
Affidavits of Thomas Norris, S.J. Garvin, S.M. Moncrief, Jane Slayton, James Davis, Reuben Goins, J.W. Norton, J.D. Wilburn, José Manchaca, Paddy Thompson, Bill Jones, and J.J. Hayter
Reports of investigator D.A. Richardson, Nacogdoches, Texas
Correspondence of S.L. Williams, Purcell, and Mansfield, McMurray & Cornish, 1899 to 1903
Firm tally of Goins claimants denied
Mansfield, McMurray & Cornish letter book and Choctaw claimants roll, Melven Cornish Collection, University of Oklahoma Libraries.
Enrollment records
Dawes enrollment card, Choctaw by Blood Card No. 5151 (Evaline Paddieo). National Archives, M1186, via Fold3.
Applications for enrollment, Five Civilized Tribes. National Archives, M1301, via Fold3.
Evaline Goins Padier affidavit, August 1, 1896.
Memorandum, district Indian Agent, Pauls Valley, Oklahoma, November 20, 1908.
[1900 U.S. Census, Evaline Padier household: county, ED, sheet]
Books and articles
Angie Debo, The Rise and Fall of the Choctaw Republic (University of Oklahoma Press).
on Samuel Caldwell and the Choctaw and Chickasaw Citizenship Court. Summarized at Legal History Blog: legalhistoryblog.blogspot.com/2026/08/walker-on-choctaw-citizenship.html
Federal Judicial Center, "Choctaw and Chickasaw Citizenship Court, 1902-1904": fjc.gov/history/courts/choctaw-and-chickasaw-citizenship-court-1902-1904
Family research
Gowen Research Foundation, "Choctaw County, Mississippi," Gowen Manuscript 086: freepages.rootsweb.com/~gowenrf/genealogy/Gowenms086.htm
Reposted at Goyen Family Tree: goyengoinggowengoyneandgone.com/086-choctaw-co-mississippi
Access Genealogy, Choctaw citizenship records: accessgenealogy.com/native/page/237
FOLLOW ME 📸
► YouTube: / @NYTN
► Facebook: / facebook.com/findinglolafilm
► Website: nytonashville.com
► X: / twitter.com/ImFindingLola
*Amazon links are affiliate links. If buy something through these links, we may earn affiliate commission. Thank you for supporting this project!
In 1897, a federal court in Indian Territory ruled that my great-great-grandmother, Evaline Goins Padilla, and her family were Choctaw by blood. Her Dawes enrollment card recorded her Choctaw blood but by 1904 that ruling was gone, and so was she, along with more than a hundred members of her extended family.
In this video I go through the actual case file, Robert Goins et al. v. The Choctaw Nation, using the attorneys' letters, the witness affidavits, and Evaline's enrollment card. Those papers show the lawyers for the Nations deciding my family were "Mexicans and negroes" before they had any testimony, and then going out to find witnesses who would say so. This is my family's story, and it's also how reclassification worked on thousands of Native families during the Dawes era.
00:00 – The Paper Trail of Reclassification
01:00 – Danielle’s Family Case & Legal Erasure
02:45 – What is Racial Reclassification?
03:45 – Land Allotment, Dawes Commission & the Curtis Act
05:08 – The Citizenship Court & The Residency Requirement
06:57 – Evaline’s Choctaw Roots & 1896 Testimony
08:47 – The 1897 Ruling Reversed
10:12 – The Financial Incentive to Exclude Claimants
10:45 – Subverting Bloodlines: "Proving" Families Were Black
12:00 – Genuine Evidence vs. Fraudulent Claims (The Caldwell Case)
14:08 – Reclassification Tools Across America (Plecker, Melungeon, Redbone)
15:56 – DNA Proof & Maternal Haplogroup C1c
17:04 – Free Genealogy Tools & Resources
17:36 – Reclaiming Forgotten History
SOURCES
Court records
Robert Goins et al. v. The Choctaw Nation, U.S. Court for the Southern District of Indian Territory, Case No. 127. Judgment entered December 21, 1897.
Choctaw and Chickasaw Citizenship Court, Case No. 31 (Goins). Motion to dismiss, May 1904, and final decree denying citizenship.
Brief for Appellees, U.S. Supreme Court, including No. 588 (Goins case).
Attorneys' case file, Melven Cornish Collection, University of Oklahoma Libraries (oku_31856), including:
Affidavits of Thomas Norris, S.J. Garvin, S.M. Moncrief, Jane Slayton, James Davis, Reuben Goins, J.W. Norton, J.D. Wilburn, José Manchaca, Paddy Thompson, Bill Jones, and J.J. Hayter
Reports of investigator D.A. Richardson, Nacogdoches, Texas
Correspondence of S.L. Williams, Purcell, and Mansfield, McMurray & Cornish, 1899 to 1903
Firm tally of Goins claimants denied
Mansfield, McMurray & Cornish letter book and Choctaw claimants roll, Melven Cornish Collection, University of Oklahoma Libraries.
Enrollment records
Dawes enrollment card, Choctaw by Blood Card No. 5151 (Evaline Paddieo). National Archives, M1186, via Fold3.
Applications for enrollment, Five Civilized Tribes. National Archives, M1301, via Fold3.
Evaline Goins Padier affidavit, August 1, 1896.
Memorandum, district Indian Agent, Pauls Valley, Oklahoma, November 20, 1908.
[1900 U.S. Census, Evaline Padier household: county, ED, sheet]
Books and articles
Angie Debo, The Rise and Fall of the Choctaw Republic (University of Oklahoma Press).
on Samuel Caldwell and the Choctaw and Chickasaw Citizenship Court. Summarized at Legal History Blog: legalhistoryblog.blogspot.com/2026/08/walker-on-choctaw-citizenship.html
Federal Judicial Center, "Choctaw and Chickasaw Citizenship Court, 1902-1904": fjc.gov/history/courts/choctaw-and-chickasaw-citizenship-court-1902-1904
Family research
Gowen Research Foundation, "Choctaw County, Mississippi," Gowen Manuscript 086: freepages.rootsweb.com/~gowenrf/genealogy/Gowenms086.htm
Reposted at Goyen Family Tree: goyengoinggowengoyneandgone.com/086-choctaw-co-mississippi
Access Genealogy, Choctaw citizenship records: accessgenealogy.com/native/page/237
FOLLOW ME 📸
► YouTube: / @NYTN
► Facebook: / facebook.com/findinglolafilm
► Website: nytonashville.com
► X: / twitter.com/ImFindingLola
*Amazon links are affiliate links. If buy something through these links, we may earn affiliate commission. Thank you for supporting this project!










