How Might the Academy Undermine Democratic Legitimacy? @HeterodoxAcademy
How Might the Academy Undermine Democratic Legitimacy?  @HeterodoxAcademy
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Does the university shape public debate over the long run, with no democratic check on it? Philosopher Hrishikesh Joshi argues it does: that the academy shapes the elite, that its power is democratically unaccountable, and that exit is not a real option. This is one philosopher's argument, not a new study, and the views are his own. This video is the talk only.

Chapters:
0:00 Intro
0:11 His paper, and Foucault on hidden power
1:38 A test case, then Rawls and the voting booth
4:51 Wealth, media and legitimacy: Scanlon, Cohen, Chomsky
8:51 How he says the academy shapes the elite
11:25 Why he says professors as a group have unique power
14:11 Why he calls that power unaccountable
15:31 Exit, voice and loyalty: can students just leave?
18:13 Party affiliation and faculty ideology
20:13 What explains the imbalance? The evidence he cites
21:50 His conclusion on democratic legitimacy
22:43 The wealthy patron, and what he says is needed

Hrishikesh Joshi, who goes by Rishi, is an Associate Professor of Philosophy at the University of Arizona. Hosted by Dylan Selterman, HxA Director of Research and Resource Development.

Recorded November 10, 2026 for the HxA Colloquium Series, "Democracy and the Academy." Event page: heterodoxacademy.org/events/democracy-and-the-academy
Upcoming HxA events, in person and online: heterodoxacademy.org/events

Heterodox Academy is a nonpartisan membership organization of faculty, administrators, staff and graduate students at more than 2,100 institutions, working to advance open inquiry in higher education. If you work in higher education or are a graduate student, membership is free: heterodoxacademy.org/become-a-member

Subscribe for more talks from Heterodox Academy.

Follow Heterodox Academy on:
X/Twitter: bit.ly/3Fax5Dy
Facebook: bit.ly/3PMYxfw
LinkedIn: bit.ly/48IYeuJ
Instagram: bit.ly/46HKfUg
Substack: bit.ly/48IhjNF

#Democracy #HigherEducation #PoliticalPhilosophy
How Might the Academy Undermine Democratic Legitimacy?Generative AI in the Classroom - Mountain West Regional ConferenceWhen University Investigations of Faculty Go Off the RailsCass Sunstein on Whats Actually Wrong With the University | Ep 46The Left Wing Case for Open InquiryAvoid Groupthink: Social Psychologys Hidden Danger! #shortsAcademic Freedom Under PressureCultures Role in Explaining Poverty and InequalityWhen Is Human Genetic Engineering Ethically Permissible? Heterodox Conversation™Can We Think Clearly About AI? | Michael InzlichtInclusion Paradox: Welcomed but Silenced? #shortsWhat is Viewpoint Diversity?
Heterodox Academy |

How Might the Academy Undermine Democratic Legitimacy?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER