Haunted Theater - Sunset Playhouse Part 1 @Pjphoto
Haunted Theater - Sunset Playhouse Part 1  @Pjphoto
Uploaded August 2010 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
The ghosts of Elm Grove
Two former Sunset playhouse volunteers still hanging around after their earthly lives
By LORI WEISS
lweiss@cninow.com
Posted: Oct. 29, 2008
Since it was built in 1960, the Sunset Playhouse has played a role in many peoples lives.

Throughout those years, actors, volunteers and directors have graced the theater with their talents and skills.

And although many individuals have come and gone in the last 50 years, there are two former members of Sunset who have decided not to leave the artistic dwelling after their passing.

Actor, technician haunt Sunset
I definitely believe (Sunset) is haunted, said Heather Stankovsky, a paranormal investigator with the Southern Wisconsin Paranormal Research Group. Like the saying goes, Every good theater has a ghost.

Many believe that Sunset Playhouse is haunted by the ghosts of Roger Casey and Lester Schultz.

Schultz, also known as Pinky, was an actor who died of a heart attack during the performance of The Odd Couple in 1968.

Casey was a longtime volunteer who helped the theater with technical needs.

Some things that happen we cant explain, said Jim Stankovsky, who is the treasurer on the theaters Board of Directors. Heather Stankovsky is his daughter.

Jim Stankovsky followed along with his daughter on one of the two paranormal investigations she did at the theater.

Theres a lot of things I have observed that I cannot explain, he said.

During an investigation he participated in, Jim witnessed paranormal activity with a camera being used to film the investigations footage.

As the group filmed the playbook from the play Pinky passed away in, the camera light would continue to turn off.

The person operating it swears he wasnt doing it, he said.

Investigation yields proof
Heather Stankovsky can give no other explanation for, besides the theater being haunted by ghosts, for what she has seen during her investigations.

I know its haunted, she said. Just the stuff I witnessed that night, theres no way of debunking it.

Heather said that as her group was making its way backstage, people asked for the spirits to give them a sign if they were present. At that moment a loud pounding noise was heard near the shop in the rear of the theater.

The prop room in the basement of the playhouse also yielded high electronic voice phenomena numbers.

EVPs are ghosts voices captured through the use of audio recording devices.

But the most astounding evidence she retrieved from the investigation was the figure of Casey.

A member of the group had taken a picture from the stage area facing up to the light and sound booth. After enhancing the picture, an image of Caseys face appeared.

We think they are both here, Jim Stankovsky said. Whoever explains what they experienced are positive there are two separate ghosts.

Many have not seen them
While Jim Stankovsky has had the pleasure of witnessing their presences, many of the longtime employees and volunteers at Sunset have yet to experience a visit from the spirits.

I know all the lore, said Laura Feltes, office manger. I myself have never experienced Roger or Pinky.

Likewise, volunteer Rudy Miskowitch has also never had the pleasure of a visit, but has heard stories from others.

Everyone says Oh, thats Pinky, he said. He gets blamed for everything.

While both mens spirits may still live on in the theater, Jim Stankovsky said there is nothing to be concerned about.

They are friendly; nothing ever happens, he said.
Haunted Theater - Sunset Playhouse Part 1PrideFishing With Bob and Phil part 2Front yard fireworks with Phil and Bob.A Peaceful Morning StormFishing with Bob and Phil 2019SirDriverMan in Flood
Phil Koch |

Haunted Theater - Sunset Playhouse Part 1

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER