Uploaded October 2025 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
The gVasc team shares the mission of the study and encourages participation from members of the SCAD community.
Copyright Broad Institute, 2025. All rights reserved.
The gVasc team shares the mission of the study and encourages participation from members of the SCAD community.
Copyright Broad Institute, 2025. All rights reserved.




![Who Did the Analysis? Editors on Disclosure and Peer Review in the Age of AI Agents
The editors-in-chief of Science, Nature, Cell, and NEJM AI on what journals now require when AI does the analysis, and who gets the credit.
Who Did the Analysis? Editors on Disclosure and Peer Review in the Age of AI Agents
A BroadHacks Event | September 22, 2026 | Broad Institute
AI agents are now part of how researchers analyze data, write code, and survey the literature. How do priority and credit work when an AI system produces the result first? Standards for AI-assisted publishing are still taking shape and vary between journals.
PANELISTS
Holden Thorp, Editor-in-Chief, Science
Magdalena Skipper, Editor-in-Chief, Nature
John Pham, Editor-in-Chief, Cell
Arjun (Raj) Manrai, Senior Deputy Editor, NEJM AI; Harvard Medical School
Moderator: Stan Bratchikov, Broad Institute
Topics: disclosure, reproducibility, code review, peer review at scale, licensing, and credit in the age of AI.
*CHAPTERS*
0:00 Roadmap of the discussion
2:01 Panelist introductions
6:42 *Q1: What should PIs write in methods?*
7:33 Pham (Cell)
8:08 Skipper (Nature)
10:50 Thorp (Science)
12:51 Manrai (NEJM AI) [1]
15:02 Skipper: how the community adapts to new reporting tools
16:10 *Q2: What is disclosure for?* Thorp on scientific gotchas
18:17 Skipper: how we can fail as a community [2]
21:50 Pham: do scientists really need journals?
24:17 Skipper: how publishing has changed with AI
25:41 *Q3: The code blind spot* [3]
26:28 Pham: what stops editors and reviewers from checking code
28:01 Thorp: daily pitches and current rejection rates [4]
30:03 Skipper: whats most valuable to check at submission
34:05 Manrai: a system that makes review 17 times faster [5][6]
41:40 *Q4: The Millennium Prize controversy*
42:15 Skipper: Do not upload peer-reviewed research to chatbots
43:50 Skipper: credit in the controversy and its ramifications
46:19 Thorp: how to not get scooped by the internet [7]
49:16 Pham: AI doom and gloom, and why humans do research
50:58 *Q5: Peer review monoculture in a world of two AI models*
51:21 Skipper: humans secret advantage over AI
55:20 Thorp: the Olive Garden problem and AI research
57:40 *Audience Q1: How will publishers handle the volume of AI analyses?*
59:08 Thorp: the analysis storage problem
1:00:00 Manrai: what journals are still hungry for [8]
1:02:27 Pham: the inevitability of trust in research
1:03:43 *Audience Q2: AI editors, and when to stop reviewing*
1:04:08 Thorp: an exciting and terrifying AI future
1:04:42 Skipper: lessons from 30 years of peer review
1:06:31 *Q6: Integrity and self-correction*
1:07:08 Skipper: correction as a driving force of science
1:08:59 Pham: can submissions still be checked at this volume?
1:09:55 Thorp: Sciences publication rate in the age of AI
1:11:16 Pham: Elseviers 153 new integrity hires
1:12:07 *Audience Q3: A special license for the age of AI?*
1:12:25 Skipper: the future of licensing in publishing
1:15:32 Thorp: the issue with CC BY licenses
1:17:12 Skipper: the nuances of small print
1:19:50 *Q7: Who gets the credit in the age of AI?*
1:20:21 Pham (Cell)
1:21:21 Skipper: credit comes with responsibility
1:22:45 Thorp: when LLMs commit crimes, there are no consequences
1:24:18 Manrai: why responsibility is a good thing
1:25:20 Closing remarks
KEY QUOTES
17:40 We have enough gotchas in our life. – Thorp
33:27 No system and no individual is infallible. – Skipper
47:57 The next day I send kids home with a bag of weed and tell them not to smoke it. – Thorp
50:03 We need to make sure that what we are doing does not train us out of jobs as scientists. – Pham
54:30 So what that we have an answer? We dont really understand the journey that led us to it. – Skipper
55:12 Research, just like art, is a human endeavor. – Skipper
1:21:20 It is absolutely essential to think about credit as one side of the coin, where accountability is the other. – Skipper
REFERENCES
[1] 13:57 Nature News & Views (Manrai): https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02125-z
[2] 21:17 Nature manuscript checklist: https://www.nature.com/documents/nature_3d_ms_checklist.pdf
[3] 26:00 James Zou paper: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11044-y
[4] 29:30 Proofig: https://www.proofig.com/ | iThenticate: https://www.ithenticate.com/
[5] 36:12 NEJM AI Fast Track (human+AI review): https://ai.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/AIe2501175
[6] 40:04 Liang, Zou et al., LLM feedback on research papers: https://ai.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/AIoa2400196
[7] 47:40 Nature on AI text in research papers: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02551-z
[8] 1:02:10 NEJM AI Datasets, Benchmarks & Protocols: https://ai.nejm.org/browse/ai-article-type/datasets-benchmarks-protocols
WATCH NEXT
Our previous talk with James Zou: https://youtu.be/SjJtoZFO7Ng
Holden Thorp with James Evans: https://youtu.be/vjmsrDBQyYc
More: https://www.broadinstitute.org
© Broad Institute, 2026. All rights reserved.
#PeerReview #AI #AIinScience #ScientificPublishing #LLMs #Claude #ChatGPT Who Did the Analysis? Editors on Disclosure and Peer Review in the Age of AI Agents](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/Q04PAohvSYU/mqdefault.jpg)





