Goodbye, Apathy ✦ RDR2 @RedtheMudkip
Goodbye, Apathy ✦ RDR2  @RedtheMudkip
Uploaded September 2021 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
warning for an obnoxious amount of voiceovers. I'm not sorry. I needed a way to capture the frantic emotional energy of this game's ending and the only way I could figure out how to do that was through a ridiculous amount of overlapping voices.

aaanyways. I started working on this vid on March 21st, over half a year ago! and I was just stuck because I didn't know how to keep going with it. I wanted it to be way longer; wanted to include more scenes with Rains Fall and Eagle Flies because honestly they were some of my favorite characters in the game. but it's been too long and I just said screw it & decided to upload this as it is.

it's not the best vid. but it means a lot to me. because RDR2 was the perfect prequel to an already fantastic story. my brother and I beat the second game together this March, and... and long story short it hit way closer to home than I thought it would. I have so many thoughts about it that I can't put into words -- about broken friendships and death and making things right and moving on and everything. this is my love letter to the game that anchored me for months.

I chose this song, specifically, because the lyrics fit Arthur so well. from the references to not being able to breathe & move (lolololol) to giving everything you have for the sake of someone you love... to slowly learning how to feel peace, shedding the chains of apathy as you begin to see that your choices matter and you need to try to fix things even though it's too late. this whole theme, of Arthur trying to do the right thing despite the fact that it doesn't matter anymore, even though he's already made so many mistakes, although he's a dead man walking ("we're more ghosts than people"), is.... inspirational. to put it lamely. I don't have a better word for it, but it touched me so deeply.

and then there's John. trying to fill the shoes of the only positive role model you've had, the man you loved the most, the man who gave his life so you and your wife and child could thrive: it weighs on John. he never says it but it's so apparent. he wants to be the man Arthur knew he could be. but it's so hard to follow the deceased's wishes when that wish is to let go and move on. after beating RDR2 I went straight back to replay RDR1 and the transition is genuinely seamless. Arthur, as a concept, didn't even EXIST at the time the game was made -- and yet he's there, somehow. you feel him with every word John says. it's crazy. kind of magical.

(and then there's my... "alternate" reading of the "you're my brother" line. John Marston is a man living in the 1800s with a wife and a child, and he probably has a ton of internalized homophobia. as someone who ALSO is very deep in the closet IRL because I live in a vehemently homophobic environment, I know with a lot of my crushes I've told them they're "like a sibling to me" because I've wanted so badly to confess my love but have been too afraid to say it like it is. and that's what I see in John's parting words to Arthur, personally. I understand most people like to interpret it as literally them being "found brothers," which is really sweet! but that's my take, and it's very important to me, so I just had to put it out there.)

even if you haven't played the first Red Dead Redemption game (which you SHOULD), I recommend the second one for sure. it's a prequel so you don't need background info at all. there are sad cowboys. sad gay cowboys. what else could you ever want?

special thanks to Lena and Kyle, who taught me how to make my voiceovers actually sound good lol. and of course to my older brother for playing this hell of a game with me. love you guys.
Goodbye, Apathy ✦ RDR2「CANT STOP THE FEELING」→ mep part 1Pokemon AMV // Centuries by Fall Out Boylike the man i know im not. || shuake vent「TAKULISE + SAKUCAMI」→ AMV // i knew you were the one 💖Fire Emblem Fates AMV / GMV - Wait For ItShow By Rock AMV // The Only Difference by Panic! At The Disco「TALK TO ME」→ mep parts「LUCIGO + AZURRIN」→ hey, soul sister ❥I Will Go Down With This ShipMintyPie, RariCatcher &&. SpikeDash // Pardon Me (PMV)famous last words || pegokita amv
Red the Mudkip |

Goodbye, Apathy ✦ RDR2

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER