Uploaded July 2022 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
The Guardian recently wrote an article about evolution. How accurate was it?
Here are links to stuff mentioned in the flick:
EYE EVOLUTION
Video: This presentation by Professor Dawkins is wonderful if you want a general overview of eye evolution. He does not discuss the origin of light sensing cells, though, for that, see readings below.
youtu.be/YT1vXXMsYak
Book: amazon.ca/Evolutions-Witness-How-Eyes-Evolved/dp/0195369742
Paper on light-receptive cell evolution: ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4763119
Paper on light-receptive protein evolution: ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3583139
WING EVOLUTION
Video: What use is half a wing? youtu.be/JMuzlEQz3uo
Video: The Biology of Angels (How did flight actually evolve?) youtu.be/bR5_2MomQEo
Video: My talk at OSU: youtu.be/AwY8z9L6KbU
THE MODERN SYNTHESIS
Short article on the history and scope of the modern synthesis: oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-9780199941728/obo-9780199941728-0115.xml
EVOLUTIONARY MATHEMATICS
Paper on the Price Equation: ehudlamm.com/price_eqn.pdf
Primer Animation on Natural Selection: youtu.be/0ZGbIKd0XrM
Primer Animation on the evolution of aggression: youtu.be/YNMkADpvO4w
PLASTICITY
News article by Nature, highlighting Dr. Emily Standen's work with bichir fish: nature.com/articles/nature.2014.15778
Dr Standen's TEDx talk: youtu.be/4tdKP-_I1uQ
Dr Standen's Lecture: youtu.be/6C6QjaBNvVI
CORRECTIONS
1. Dr. Standen's research did not actually measure lung size changes. The claim that fish raised on land have larger lungs was either invented by the Guardian, or was published by a different research group. That said, I have not been able to find the claim published anywhere aside from the Guardian article.
2. Dr. Standen's research was funded by Canada's Science Foundation (NSERC), not the US Science Foundation (NSF).
The Guardian recently wrote an article about evolution. How accurate was it?
Here are links to stuff mentioned in the flick:
EYE EVOLUTION
Video: This presentation by Professor Dawkins is wonderful if you want a general overview of eye evolution. He does not discuss the origin of light sensing cells, though, for that, see readings below.
youtu.be/YT1vXXMsYak
Book: amazon.ca/Evolutions-Witness-How-Eyes-Evolved/dp/0195369742
Paper on light-receptive cell evolution: ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4763119
Paper on light-receptive protein evolution: ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3583139
WING EVOLUTION
Video: What use is half a wing? youtu.be/JMuzlEQz3uo
Video: The Biology of Angels (How did flight actually evolve?) youtu.be/bR5_2MomQEo
Video: My talk at OSU: youtu.be/AwY8z9L6KbU
THE MODERN SYNTHESIS
Short article on the history and scope of the modern synthesis: oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-9780199941728/obo-9780199941728-0115.xml
EVOLUTIONARY MATHEMATICS
Paper on the Price Equation: ehudlamm.com/price_eqn.pdf
Primer Animation on Natural Selection: youtu.be/0ZGbIKd0XrM
Primer Animation on the evolution of aggression: youtu.be/YNMkADpvO4w
PLASTICITY
News article by Nature, highlighting Dr. Emily Standen's work with bichir fish: nature.com/articles/nature.2014.15778
Dr Standen's TEDx talk: youtu.be/4tdKP-_I1uQ
Dr Standen's Lecture: youtu.be/6C6QjaBNvVI
CORRECTIONS
1. Dr. Standen's research did not actually measure lung size changes. The claim that fish raised on land have larger lungs was either invented by the Guardian, or was published by a different research group. That said, I have not been able to find the claim published anywhere aside from the Guardian article.
2. Dr. Standen's research was funded by Canada's Science Foundation (NSERC), not the US Science Foundation (NSF).










