Uploaded December 2020 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Fuel Qualification is an Element in Achieving Sufficient Understanding of Fuel Behavior. msrworkshop.ornl.gov/msr2020
Fuel qualification is a process which provides high confidence that physical and chemical behavior of fuel is sufficiently understood so that it can be adequately modeled for both normal and accident conditions, reflecting the role of the fuel design in the overall safety of the facility. Uncertainties are defined so that calculated fission product releases include the appropriate margins to ensure conservative calculation of radiological dose consequences.
No Qualification Method Appropriate for Liquid Salt Fuel Currently Exists
• Existing fuel qualification methodology is based upon the characteristics and safety functions of solid fuels
• Role of liquid fuel salt in plant safety is significantly different from solid fuels (physical and chemical behaviors are significantly different)
• Stakeholders have indicated that significant confusion and delay would result from attempting to apply a solid fuel- based methodology to liquid salt fuel
Key Issue is “What Constitutes Fuel Salt?”
• Fuel salt does not come in discrete elements (rods or assemblies) and moves independently of its container during normal operations
– Cladding and fuel assembly structures are qualified as part of solid fuel
• Fuel salt includes all of the material containing fissionable elements or radionuclides that remain in hydraulic communication, but does not include the surrounding systems, structures, or components
– Salt vapors and aerosols remain part of the fuel salt system until they become adequately trapped
– Container corrosion products become part of the fuel salt – Fresh and used fuel salt in on-site storage are within scope
Qualification is Based Upon Understanding the Chemical and Physical Properties of Representative Fuel Samples
• Liquid state significantly changes the physical behavior of fuel
– Liquids do not accumulate internal stresses • No history dependent properties
– Flow homogenizes fluid properties • No position dependent properties
• No size dependent properties
• Chemical and physical properties are set by elemental composition and temperature
– Independent of isotopic content
Liquid Fuel Salt Qualification Establishes Acceptable Salt Composition Range That Maintains Safety Functions
• Liquid fuel salt is a Newtonian fluid
– Heat transfer and fluid flow behave in well known manners
– Continuous variance in physical properties with composition
• Reasonable assurance of adequate protection derives from a combination of measured salt composition and knowledge of resulting chemical and physical properties
• A liquid fuel salt property database would capture the relationship between fuel salt composition and properties
Fuel Qualification is an Element in Achieving Sufficient Understanding of Fuel Behavior. msrworkshop.ornl.gov/msr2020
Fuel qualification is a process which provides high confidence that physical and chemical behavior of fuel is sufficiently understood so that it can be adequately modeled for both normal and accident conditions, reflecting the role of the fuel design in the overall safety of the facility. Uncertainties are defined so that calculated fission product releases include the appropriate margins to ensure conservative calculation of radiological dose consequences.
No Qualification Method Appropriate for Liquid Salt Fuel Currently Exists
• Existing fuel qualification methodology is based upon the characteristics and safety functions of solid fuels
• Role of liquid fuel salt in plant safety is significantly different from solid fuels (physical and chemical behaviors are significantly different)
• Stakeholders have indicated that significant confusion and delay would result from attempting to apply a solid fuel- based methodology to liquid salt fuel
Key Issue is “What Constitutes Fuel Salt?”
• Fuel salt does not come in discrete elements (rods or assemblies) and moves independently of its container during normal operations
– Cladding and fuel assembly structures are qualified as part of solid fuel
• Fuel salt includes all of the material containing fissionable elements or radionuclides that remain in hydraulic communication, but does not include the surrounding systems, structures, or components
– Salt vapors and aerosols remain part of the fuel salt system until they become adequately trapped
– Container corrosion products become part of the fuel salt – Fresh and used fuel salt in on-site storage are within scope
Qualification is Based Upon Understanding the Chemical and Physical Properties of Representative Fuel Samples
• Liquid state significantly changes the physical behavior of fuel
– Liquids do not accumulate internal stresses • No history dependent properties
– Flow homogenizes fluid properties • No position dependent properties
• No size dependent properties
• Chemical and physical properties are set by elemental composition and temperature
– Independent of isotopic content
Liquid Fuel Salt Qualification Establishes Acceptable Salt Composition Range That Maintains Safety Functions
• Liquid fuel salt is a Newtonian fluid
– Heat transfer and fluid flow behave in well known manners
– Continuous variance in physical properties with composition
• Reasonable assurance of adequate protection derives from a combination of measured salt composition and knowledge of resulting chemical and physical properties
• A liquid fuel salt property database would capture the relationship between fuel salt composition and properties







![Dr. Helen Caldicott: George Monbiot, Fukushima, cerebral tumor, psychotic breakdown, my diagnosis.
http://ThoriumRemix.com/ Thorium & MSR & Nuclear assets used in Thorium Remix project.
George Monbiot wrote:
The anti-nuclear movement, to which I once belonged, has mislead the world about the impact of radiation on human health. The claims we made were ungrounded in science, unsupportable when challenged, and wildly wrong. We have done other people, and ourselves, a terrible dis-service. Dr. Helen Caldicott, the worlds foremost anti-nuclear campaigner, has made some striking statements about the dangers of radiation. I asked for the sources. Caldicotts response has profoundly shaken me. None were scientific publications. None contained sources for the claims shed made.
Dr. Helen Caldicott:
George Monbiot published our email exchanges in The Guardian... how dare he? So stupid. That revolting little man said [that] after Fukushima hes become pro-nuclear. Hes either got a cerebral tumor or hes had a psychotic breakdown, thats my clinical diagnosis.
Dr. Helen Caldicott:
Is he being paid? I do wonder. Something... something fishy is going on. Dr. Helen Caldicott: George Monbiot, Fukushima, cerebral tumor, psychotic breakdown, my diagnosis.](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/di8AnUsDmew/mqdefault.jpg)


