Uploaded July 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
In The Chronicle of Higher Education, a question was posed by journalist Beth McMurtrie as to whether or not institutions of higher education truly value teaching, and she offered a list of “red flags” that signal the undervaluing of teaching. In response, Michelle Miller, Professor of Psychological Sciences and President’s Distinguished Teaching Fellow at Northern Arizona University, wrote a post in her “R3 Newsletter,” adding to McMurtrie’s list of red flags and offering her own. In this podcast episode, Dr. Miller discusses her list, which can be reverse engineered to serve as a helpful starting point for those who want to change the institutional culture around teaching at their university.
____________________________
Learn more about the "Dead Ideas in Teaching and Learning" podcast, and find a transcript and resources for this episode, on our website: https://ctl.columbia.edu/resources-and-technology/resources/podcast/
A full transcript with speaker attributions and bios, as well as a link to the video recording and a list of materials cited in the episode, is available on our website.
In The Chronicle of Higher Education, a question was posed by journalist Beth McMurtrie as to whether or not institutions of higher education truly value teaching, and she offered a list of “red flags” that signal the undervaluing of teaching. In response, Michelle Miller, Professor of Psychological Sciences and President’s Distinguished Teaching Fellow at Northern Arizona University, wrote a post in her “R3 Newsletter,” adding to McMurtrie’s list of red flags and offering her own. In this podcast episode, Dr. Miller discusses her list, which can be reverse engineered to serve as a helpful starting point for those who want to change the institutional culture around teaching at their university.
____________________________
Learn more about the "Dead Ideas in Teaching and Learning" podcast, and find a transcript and resources for this episode, on our website: https://ctl.columbia.edu/resources-and-technology/resources/podcast/
A full transcript with speaker attributions and bios, as well as a link to the video recording and a list of materials cited in the episode, is available on our website.
![Critiquing AI Output | AI for Learning
This video offers a demonstration on how to guide students in critiquing output generated by AI. By engaging in this type of activity, students become aware of the strengths and limitations of AI, identify biases and inconsistencies in the AI-generated output, make judgments about the quality, credibility, and relevance of it, and develop metacognitive skills. Instructors can teach students how to think critically about AI-generated output, make space in class for students to practice these important skills and facilitate a conversation after the experience to share what was learned.
The prompt used in this video is provided below and can be adapted for each course context.
For more resources on leveraging AI for teaching and learning, visit the Columbia Center for Teaching and Learning’s website at ctl.columbia.edu.
Prompt: Write a five-sentence summary of the following text. Be sure to highlight the main point of the article.
Text to summarize: [insert text of your choice]
Generative AI Policy: https://provost.columbia.edu/content/office-senior-vice-provost/ai-policy
CUIT ChatGPT Enterprise: https://www.cuit.columbia.edu/content/chatgpt-enterprise Critiquing AI Output | AI for Learning](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/mqQa2hslPpw/mqdefault.jpg)









