Uploaded July 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
A Confessional Critique of Eastern Orthodoxy: 8+1 Areas of Concern
Former Eastern Orthodox priest turned confessional Lutheran (LCMS) pastor Joshua Schooping — who spent 12 years in Eastern Orthodoxy, including seminary training at St. Vladimir's and five years of ordained ministry in ROCOR and the OCA — offers an insider's critique of Eastern Orthodox theology and practice.
Many come to admire Eastern Orthodoxy through the writings of early fathers like Athanasius, the Cappadocians, or Cyril of Alexandria, assuming modern Orthodoxy is a direct continuation of their teaching. Schooping argues this overlooks centuries of doctrinal and liturgical development — much of it solidifying well after the patristic era — that have taken Eastern Orthodoxy in a very different direction from both the earliest church and from historic Protestant confessions.
Structured as "8 + 1," this talk first examines Eastern Orthodoxy's claimed sources of authority (Scripture, the canon, church infallibility, unwritten tradition, the fathers, councils, and liturgical hymnody) before turning to eight specific doctrinal areas of concern:
Forced veneration of icons and the Seventh Ecumenical Council
Rejection of forensic justification
Rejection of penal substitutionary atonement
Rejection of the filioque
Sectarian ecclesiology
Palamite hesychasm
Hyper-Mariology
The doctrine of toll houses
Drawing on primary source material — including the Acts of the Second Council of Nicaea, the Confession of Dositheus (Jerusalem Council of 1672), the Synodikon of Orthodoxy, and patristic writings from Basil, Gregory of Nyssa, Cyril of Alexandria, and others — Schooping makes the case that a clear-eyed, historically grounded examination of Eastern Orthodoxy reveals significant internal inconsistencies and departures from the apostolic and patristic witness.
Please consider supporting Revealed Apologetics here: revealedapologetics.com/donate
Check out Joshua Schooping's channel here: youtube.com/@UCgDY-yM7X1iYvqAvebT5a4A
Check out Eli's work on Apologiastudios here: apologiastudios.com/course-category/apologia-academy
➡️ Join me at Bahnsen U: apologia.link/revealed-bahnsen
A Confessional Critique of Eastern Orthodoxy: 8+1 Areas of Concern
Former Eastern Orthodox priest turned confessional Lutheran (LCMS) pastor Joshua Schooping — who spent 12 years in Eastern Orthodoxy, including seminary training at St. Vladimir's and five years of ordained ministry in ROCOR and the OCA — offers an insider's critique of Eastern Orthodox theology and practice.
Many come to admire Eastern Orthodoxy through the writings of early fathers like Athanasius, the Cappadocians, or Cyril of Alexandria, assuming modern Orthodoxy is a direct continuation of their teaching. Schooping argues this overlooks centuries of doctrinal and liturgical development — much of it solidifying well after the patristic era — that have taken Eastern Orthodoxy in a very different direction from both the earliest church and from historic Protestant confessions.
Structured as "8 + 1," this talk first examines Eastern Orthodoxy's claimed sources of authority (Scripture, the canon, church infallibility, unwritten tradition, the fathers, councils, and liturgical hymnody) before turning to eight specific doctrinal areas of concern:
Forced veneration of icons and the Seventh Ecumenical Council
Rejection of forensic justification
Rejection of penal substitutionary atonement
Rejection of the filioque
Sectarian ecclesiology
Palamite hesychasm
Hyper-Mariology
The doctrine of toll houses
Drawing on primary source material — including the Acts of the Second Council of Nicaea, the Confession of Dositheus (Jerusalem Council of 1672), the Synodikon of Orthodoxy, and patristic writings from Basil, Gregory of Nyssa, Cyril of Alexandria, and others — Schooping makes the case that a clear-eyed, historically grounded examination of Eastern Orthodoxy reveals significant internal inconsistencies and departures from the apostolic and patristic witness.
Please consider supporting Revealed Apologetics here: revealedapologetics.com/donate
Check out Joshua Schooping's channel here: youtube.com/@UCgDY-yM7X1iYvqAvebT5a4A
Check out Eli's work on Apologiastudios here: apologiastudios.com/course-category/apologia-academy
➡️ Join me at Bahnsen U: apologia.link/revealed-bahnsen










