Friendly Fire: Cy Pres, Consent Decrees, and Trump v. IRS @TheFederalistSociety
Friendly Fire: Cy Pres, Consent Decrees, and Trump v. IRS  @TheFederalistSociety
Uploaded July 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Controversy has swirled for years over litigation in which a plaintiff sues a friendly government defendant, and the case concludes with a favorable settlement. Critics argue that this practice creates a non-adversarial process that allows aligned litigants and agencies to shape policy and reward political allies outside the normal rulemaking and appropriations procedures. Defenders respond that these settlements generally resolve legitimate claims while conserving judicial resources and taxpayer dollars. The debate intensified during the Obama administration as the practice proliferated, particularly in environmental consent decrees.

The controversy received renewed attention after the district court’s July 13 ruling in Trump v. IRS, concerning the settlement of President Trump's lawsuit against the IRS over the leak of his tax returns. The court concluded that the parties were never genuinely adverse and that there was therefore no Article III case or controversy. Its order went further, however. Reasoning that the suit was brought for an improper purpose, the court imposed sanctions on the plaintiffs and their counsel and directed that the order be transmitted to the bar authorities of senior DOJ officials.

Join us for a discussion of Trump v. IRS, and the broader legal and policy concerns surrounding sue-and-settle litigation.

Featuring:

Anne Austin, Senior Advisor, Burke Law Group
Zhonette M. Brown, General Counsel, Senior Litigation Counsel, New Civil Liberties Alliance
Abhishek Kambli, Partner, Holtzman Vogel Baran Torchinsky & Josefiak PLLC
(Moderator) John Shu, Attorney and Legal Commentator


* * * * *

As always, the Federalist Society takes no position on particular legal or public policy issues; all expressions of opinion are those of the speaker.
Friendly Fire: Cy Pres, Consent Decrees, and Trump v. IRS[LIVE] Trial by Jury or Administrative Adjudication: What Would the Founders Say?Lit. Update: D.A. ex rel. B.A. v. Tri-County Area Schools and E.D. v. Noblesville School DistrictSCOTUS Short: Trump v. BarbaraMr. Samuel Adkisson, on presidential accountability over the executive branchSCOTUS Short: FCC v. AT&T[LIVE] From Pamphlets to PACs: Campaign Finance and the Founding-Era Tradition of Political SpeechNo Enemies to the Right? Antisemitism and the Big TentPlenary Session 2: Unitary Executive & Administrative Agencies– Who’s in Charge?Panel VII: Sent Hither Swarms of Officers to Harrass Our People, and Eat Out Their Substance[LIVE] What Did the Founders Think of the President’s Pardon Power?Independent Agencies and the OIRA Review Process
The Federalist Society |

Friendly Fire: Cy Pres, Consent Decrees, and Trump v. IRS

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER