Nomen Nominandum | Freeman Dyson: Why General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics can't be unified @NomenNominandum | Uploaded November 2017 | Updated October 2024, 15 hours ago.
UPDATE (25.07.2020):
"New calculations show how hypothetical particles called gravitons would give rise to a special kind of noise. "
quantamagazine.org/gravitons-revealed-in-the-noise-of-gravitational-waves-20200723
This interview is part of the "Closer to Truth" interview series
"Why is the Quantum so Mysterious?", found at
closertotruth.com/series/why-the-quantum-so-mysterious
Dyson's arguments at a more technical level:
youtube.com/watch?v=l-FSFtoeagc
Experimental support for Dyson's claims:
* New Discovery about the Fabric of Space-Time youtube.com/watch?v=nByekIx7XXw&feature=related
* Limits on Cosmological Dispersion from Photon Bunches in GRB 090510 from Fermi LAT Data (2013) - R. J. Nemiroff, A. Kostinski youtube.com/watch?v=o9qGD7hMZFc
Quote:
"The extreme weakness of quantum gravitational effects now poses some philosophical problems; maybe nature is trying to tell us something new here, maybe we should not try to quantize gravity. Is it possible perhaps that we should not insist on a uniformity of nature that would make everything quantized? Is it possible that gravity is not quantized and all the rest of the world is?" - Feynman lectures on gravitation
UPDATE (25.07.2020):
"New calculations show how hypothetical particles called gravitons would give rise to a special kind of noise. "
quantamagazine.org/gravitons-revealed-in-the-noise-of-gravitational-waves-20200723
This interview is part of the "Closer to Truth" interview series
"Why is the Quantum so Mysterious?", found at
closertotruth.com/series/why-the-quantum-so-mysterious
Dyson's arguments at a more technical level:
youtube.com/watch?v=l-FSFtoeagc
Experimental support for Dyson's claims:
* New Discovery about the Fabric of Space-Time youtube.com/watch?v=nByekIx7XXw&feature=related
* Limits on Cosmological Dispersion from Photon Bunches in GRB 090510 from Fermi LAT Data (2013) - R. J. Nemiroff, A. Kostinski youtube.com/watch?v=o9qGD7hMZFc
Quote:
"The extreme weakness of quantum gravitational effects now poses some philosophical problems; maybe nature is trying to tell us something new here, maybe we should not try to quantize gravity. Is it possible perhaps that we should not insist on a uniformity of nature that would make everything quantized? Is it possible that gravity is not quantized and all the rest of the world is?" - Feynman lectures on gravitation