Free Will, Intention, and the Brain | Adina Roskies on the Libert Experiments, and Compatibilism @scfu
Free Will, Intention, and the Brain | Adina Roskies on the Libert Experiments, and Compatibilism  @scfu
Uploaded April 2026 | Updated November 2026, 14 hours ago
In this conversation, philosopher and neuroscientist *Adina Roskies* joins me to discuss free will, conscious intention, and what neuroscience really shows about human decision-making.

We explore the legacy of the Libet experiments, the meaning and limits of W-time, whether the brain begins preparing actions before conscious awareness, and why that does not straightforwardly imply that free will has been disproved. We also discuss compatibilism, the distinction between actions caused externally and those caused by an agent’s own mental states, and how intention may be a *gradual, multi-stage process* rather than a single moment in time.

This discussion centres in part on the paper: What is the intention to move and when does it occur?
sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0149763423001689

Topics include:

* free will and compatibilism
* Benjamin Libet and the readiness potential
* conscious intention and W-time
* whether decisions begin unconsciously
* agency, responsibility, and the neuroscience of action
* how to interpret recent research without overclaiming

0:00 Intro
0:54 Pioneering neuroethics
1:32 Thomas Hobbes - what is freedom?
4:31 Defining 'freedom'
9:27 Folk definitions of free will
12:12 Compatibilism: between hard determinism and philosophical libertarianism?
18:16 Why should everyday folk take compatibilism seriously?
20:52 Is indeterminism agency enhancing?
24:34 Can/will AI have free will?
26:36 Current limitations of 'agentic' AI
29:00 What is the intention to move and when does it occur?
30:27 What is the rediness potential?
31:55 W-time and the Libet experiments
40:18 Proponents of the 'no-free-will' idea: Sam Harris and Robert Sapolsky
44:05 Veto - "free won't" - unconscious causes of conscious processes
49:29 Thought experiment - if an AI had complete introspection across all of it's cognition
50:47 What is Harris' and Sapolsky's positive view of free will?
53:26 Mechanistic interpretability - radical or deep interpretability
1:02:38 Free will - moving parts
1:05:30 Are Folk definitions neurally desociable? - urges, wantings, decisions, intentions
1:09:49 Common mistakes that philosophical libertarians make? Robert Kane
1:13:35 Free will at the fulcrum - randomness vs unpredictability, quantum coin tosses etc
1:18:12 Chaotic systems can't be reverse engineered - therefore we can't know the governing systems that produce chaos
1:19:12 Intentions are processes, not punctuated singular events
1:22:19 Unconscious and conscious parts of intentions
1:23:47 Different kinds of intentions (in neuroscience, psychology, philosophy), motor, proximal, distal
1:27:24 Eliminativist poetry - a new research program bridging STEM and humanities
1:28:09 Why does any of this matter? Philosophical appreciation of our place in the universe, law and governance
1:32:13 A primer on criminal law in neuroscience - how to stay on top of effects of our decisions?
1:33:42 Offloading our cognition too much onto AI - enfeeblement
1:39:12 More moral than us - Should/Could we make AI to be more ethical than humans?
1:47:30 Dealing with bad actors with bad desires - insatiable power seeking behaviour
1:52:49 Daniel Dennit - Free will worth having
1:55:16 Future projects - A book on free will!

#FreeWill #AdinaRoskies #Neuroscience #Compatibilism #Libet #Philosophy #Consciousness #ethics

If you enjoy serious discussions on philosophy, neuroscience, AI, ethics, and the future, subscribe to *Science, Technology & the Future*.

Many thanks for tuning in!
Please support SciFuture by subscribing and sharing!
Buy me a coffee? buymeacoffee.com/tech101z

Have any ideas about people to interview? Want to be notified about future events? Any comments about the STF series?
Please fill out this form: docs.google.com/forms/d/1mr9PIfq2ZYlQsXRIn5BcLH2onbiSI7g79mOH_AFCdIk

Kind regards,
Adam Ford
- Science, Technology & the Future - #SciFuture - scifuture.org
Free Will, Intention, and the Brain | Adina Roskies on the Libert Experiments, and CompatibilismCarbon Copies Pt1 - Randal Koene #neuroscience #wholebrainemulation #minduploadBen Goertzel: AGI Within 5 Years! #AI #AGI #openaiCarbon Copies Pt6 - Randal Koene #Neuroscience #AI #scifuture #mindupload #wholebrainemulationNick Bostrom: Novelty In A Big Universe #novelty #utopia #valuetheoryBen Goertzel on Cryonics in Hong Kong 2011Hugo de Garis on Scary AI Futures - Halloween Special!Ken Mogi   AI, Overcoming the Bottleneck of Human Cognition - Part 2 #AI #AGI #intelligenceCarbon Copies Pt3 - Randal Koene #scifuture #neuroscience #ethics #science  #minduploadNick Bostrom - AI Ethics: Beyond Utility Maximization #ai #ethics #aisafetyMagnus Vinding on Moral Progress  #ethics #suffering #philosophyNick Bostrom: Superintelligence Could Arrive Very Soon #agi #ai #superintelligence
Science, Technology & the Future |

Free Will, Intention, and the Brain | Adina Roskies on the Libert Experiments, and Compatibilism

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER