Uploaded May 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
During this Estimates session with the Clean Energy Regulator (CER), I questioned them on the government’s setup with the Clean Energy Council (CEC). The CEC is a private lobby group, yet they appear to act as the “gatekeeper” as to which solar panels can be sold under the renewable energy schemes.
WHY has a private industry group, which exists to advocate for its members' commercial interests, been given the power to decide which products qualify for government incentives?
I was told the Clean Energy Council (CEC) was originally “named” in the legislation effectively as a co-regulator and have been "tested" against competitors. The Regulator admitted that they worked back-and-forth with the CEC to help their application meet the required standards.
I asked if this process was open and transparent to the public. Their response? Happy to take it on notice and of course, they used the "commercial-in-confidence" excuses.
When questioned on how they manage any bias, the Regulator pointed to "regular cadences of meetings" and "reporting." To me, this sounds like a "soft" approach to overseeing a group that serves its own members.
The Regulator claims they now have "greater control" and that the CEC is merely a "service provider," however the reality is that a private lobby group still appears to hold a lot of sway. They are monitoring themselves through an action plan and reporting back to the government.
I am deeply concerned about the conflict of interest here. How can a lobbying body be impartial?
Australian taxpayers should not be sold out by a system where the foxes are guarding the henhouse.
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/foxes-guarding-the-henhouse/
During this Estimates session with the Clean Energy Regulator (CER), I questioned them on the government’s setup with the Clean Energy Council (CEC). The CEC is a private lobby group, yet they appear to act as the “gatekeeper” as to which solar panels can be sold under the renewable energy schemes.
WHY has a private industry group, which exists to advocate for its members' commercial interests, been given the power to decide which products qualify for government incentives?
I was told the Clean Energy Council (CEC) was originally “named” in the legislation effectively as a co-regulator and have been "tested" against competitors. The Regulator admitted that they worked back-and-forth with the CEC to help their application meet the required standards.
I asked if this process was open and transparent to the public. Their response? Happy to take it on notice and of course, they used the "commercial-in-confidence" excuses.
When questioned on how they manage any bias, the Regulator pointed to "regular cadences of meetings" and "reporting." To me, this sounds like a "soft" approach to overseeing a group that serves its own members.
The Regulator claims they now have "greater control" and that the CEC is merely a "service provider," however the reality is that a private lobby group still appears to hold a lot of sway. They are monitoring themselves through an action plan and reporting back to the government.
I am deeply concerned about the conflict of interest here. How can a lobbying body be impartial?
Australian taxpayers should not be sold out by a system where the foxes are guarding the henhouse.
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/foxes-guarding-the-henhouse/










