Uploaded August 2025 | Updated November 2026, 5 days ago
In this video, Professor Thorsby discusses the anthropocentrism of Thomas Aquinas.
Welcome to this lesson on Thomas Aquinas and the concept of humans as moral ends. Aquinas represents a medieval theological foundation for anthropocentrism. His central claim is that rational creatures—humans—are cared for by divine providence for their own sake, while non-rational beings exist for the sake of humans. This hierarchy sets humans apart as moral ends, while animals, plants, and the rest of creation are treated as instruments.
Aquinas argues that because humans are endowed with intellect and free will, they alone reflect the divine likeness and approach God as the ultimate end. Other beings, lacking rationality, serve humans just as tools serve the craftsman. This framework legitimizes the use—even the killing—of animals for human purposes, so long as it aligns with divine order.
In this view, care must be taken not out of duty to animals themselves but because cruelty toward animals may lead to cruelty toward humans. This distinction anticipates later philosophers like Kant, who also argued for only indirect duties toward animals.
Key Quotes
“Accordingly intellectual creatures are ruled by God, as though He cared for them for their own sake; while other creatures are ruled as being directed to rational creatures.”
- Thomas Aquinas, Summa Contra Gentiles, II.3.c112
“Hereby is refuted the error of those who said it is sinful for a man to kill dumb animals: for by divine providence they are intended for man’s use in the natural order. Hence it is no wrong for man to make use of them, either by killing or in any other way whatever.”
-Thomas Aquinas, Summa Contra Gentiles, II.3.c112
A Religious-Ontological Anthropocentrism
Aquinas gives us one of the clearest formulations of the Great Chain of Being: a hierarchy with God and angels above, humans in the middle, and the rest of nature below. This worldview has been deeply influential in Western thought and continues to echo in how we justify human use of natural resources today.
At a time when biodiversity loss and climate change threaten ecosystems worldwide, Aquinas’s vision raises pressing ethical questions. Should animals and non-human nature continue to be seen primarily as instruments for human flourishing? Or must we move toward a view that grants them intrinsic value?
Key Terms for this Lesson
Anthropocentrism: The view that human beings are the central concern and that other beings exist primarily for human ends.
Providence (Aquinas): Divine governance in which rational creatures are ends in themselves, while non-rational creatures are ordered to human benefit.
Instrumental Value: The value something has as a means to another’s end (e.g., animals used as tools for human sustenance).
Intrinsic Value: Value something has in itself, independent of its usefulness to humans.
Great Chain of Being: A hierarchical view of existence, placing humans between divine beings above and nature below.
Indirect Duties (Aquinas & later Kant): Duties regarding animals not because they are owed to animals, but because of their impact on human morality.
Discussion Questions:
As you read the text, consider the following questions...
If Aquinas is correct that animals exist for human use, does this justify unlimited exploitation? Where, if anywhere, should limits be placed?
How might Aquinas’s framework respond to contemporary evidence of biodiversity loss, species extinction, and ecosystem collapse?
What are the strengths and weaknesses of the Great Chain of Being as a way to think about moral status?
Should environmental ethics continue to be built on an anthropocentric framework, or must it move beyond Aquinas’s vision?
In this video, Professor Thorsby discusses the anthropocentrism of Thomas Aquinas.
Welcome to this lesson on Thomas Aquinas and the concept of humans as moral ends. Aquinas represents a medieval theological foundation for anthropocentrism. His central claim is that rational creatures—humans—are cared for by divine providence for their own sake, while non-rational beings exist for the sake of humans. This hierarchy sets humans apart as moral ends, while animals, plants, and the rest of creation are treated as instruments.
Aquinas argues that because humans are endowed with intellect and free will, they alone reflect the divine likeness and approach God as the ultimate end. Other beings, lacking rationality, serve humans just as tools serve the craftsman. This framework legitimizes the use—even the killing—of animals for human purposes, so long as it aligns with divine order.
In this view, care must be taken not out of duty to animals themselves but because cruelty toward animals may lead to cruelty toward humans. This distinction anticipates later philosophers like Kant, who also argued for only indirect duties toward animals.
Key Quotes
“Accordingly intellectual creatures are ruled by God, as though He cared for them for their own sake; while other creatures are ruled as being directed to rational creatures.”
- Thomas Aquinas, Summa Contra Gentiles, II.3.c112
“Hereby is refuted the error of those who said it is sinful for a man to kill dumb animals: for by divine providence they are intended for man’s use in the natural order. Hence it is no wrong for man to make use of them, either by killing or in any other way whatever.”
-Thomas Aquinas, Summa Contra Gentiles, II.3.c112
A Religious-Ontological Anthropocentrism
Aquinas gives us one of the clearest formulations of the Great Chain of Being: a hierarchy with God and angels above, humans in the middle, and the rest of nature below. This worldview has been deeply influential in Western thought and continues to echo in how we justify human use of natural resources today.
At a time when biodiversity loss and climate change threaten ecosystems worldwide, Aquinas’s vision raises pressing ethical questions. Should animals and non-human nature continue to be seen primarily as instruments for human flourishing? Or must we move toward a view that grants them intrinsic value?
Key Terms for this Lesson
Anthropocentrism: The view that human beings are the central concern and that other beings exist primarily for human ends.
Providence (Aquinas): Divine governance in which rational creatures are ends in themselves, while non-rational creatures are ordered to human benefit.
Instrumental Value: The value something has as a means to another’s end (e.g., animals used as tools for human sustenance).
Intrinsic Value: Value something has in itself, independent of its usefulness to humans.
Great Chain of Being: A hierarchical view of existence, placing humans between divine beings above and nature below.
Indirect Duties (Aquinas & later Kant): Duties regarding animals not because they are owed to animals, but because of their impact on human morality.
Discussion Questions:
As you read the text, consider the following questions...
If Aquinas is correct that animals exist for human use, does this justify unlimited exploitation? Where, if anywhere, should limits be placed?
How might Aquinas’s framework respond to contemporary evidence of biodiversity loss, species extinction, and ecosystem collapse?
What are the strengths and weaknesses of the Great Chain of Being as a way to think about moral status?
Should environmental ethics continue to be built on an anthropocentric framework, or must it move beyond Aquinas’s vision?






![Tom Regan Animals as a Subject of a Life
In this video, Professor Thorsby discusses Tom Regans idea that animal deserve rights bef]cause they are subject-of-a-life.
Tom Regan – Animals as Subjects-of-a-Life
This week we read Tom Regan’s influential defense of animal rights. While Peter Singer bases his case on utilitarian principles, Regan argues from a rights-based framework. His position emphasizes that animals are not simply resources for human use but individuals with inherent value. His essay “Animals as Subjects-of-a-Life” is a cornerstone in the animal rights movement and provides a striking contrast to Singer’s utilitarian approach.
Who Is Tom Regan?
Tom Regan (1938-2017) was an American philosopher and one of the most prominent advocates for animal rights in the 20th century. He taught philosophy at the University of South Carolina and published extensively on moral and social philosophy. His most influential book, The Case for Animal Rights (1983), set out a comprehensive theory of animal rights and is often compared to John Rawls’s A Theory of Justice in its scope and systematic rigor. Unlike many earlier advocates, Regan provided a deeply philosophical foundation for why animals must be regarded as beings with moral rights, making his work central to modern debates about the ethical treatment of animals.
Key Ideas in Animals as Subjects-of-a-Life
Regan begins by identifying himself as an advocate of animal rights and makes clear that the movement requires more than reform—it requires the total abolition of practices that treat animals as resources. He rejects partial measures that allow some animal use to continue under “humane” conditions. What is fundamentally wrong, he argues, is not merely that animals suffer in specific ways, but that they are viewed as objects for human benefit—whether for food, research, sport, or entertainment.
Regan carefully critiques three traditional approaches to animal ethics. First, the Kantian account, which claims mistreating animals is wrong because it might lead humans to mistreat other humans. Regan dismisses this as speciesist, since it fails to take animal suffering seriously in its own right. Second, the cruelty account, which emphasizes avoiding cruelty, is inadequate because cruelty depends on an agent’s mental state (taking pleasure in harm), while what matters is the harm itself. Third, the utilitarian account, defended by Singer, is rejected because utilitarianism allows individuals to be sacrificed if doing so maximizes overall good.
In place of these, Regan defends a rights-based theory. He argues that many animals are “subjects-of-a-life”—they have beliefs, desires, memories, a sense of the future, and an emotional life. These capacities make them bearers of inherent value, not reducible to their usefulness. From this, Regan concludes that animals have moral rights, particularly the right not to be harmed or treated merely as a means. Unlike utilitarianism, rights act as a limit on what may be done to individuals, regardless of potential benefits to others.
Regan’s conclusion is uncompromising: the entire system of animal use is morally bankrupt. Just as we would not justify slavery by pointing to potential benefits, we cannot justify animal exploitation by appealing to human gain. Our duty, therefore, is not to reform existing practices but to abolish them.
Key Quotes
“What’s wrong—fundamentally wrong—with the way animals are treated isn’t the details that vary from case to case. It’s the whole system. The fundamental wrong is the system that allows us to view animals as our resources.”
“Individuals who have inherent value have the right not to be harmed, which precludes treating them merely as a means.” Tom Regan Animals as a Subject of a Life](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/m0lzPcGyEsk/mqdefault.jpg)



