Uploaded November 2022 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
On October 11, 2022, the Centre on Asia and Globalisation hosted Associate Professor Jessica Chen Weiss, Michael J. Zak Professor for China and Asia-Pacific Studies at the Department of Government of Cornell University, who presented on, “A World Safe for Autocracy: The Domestic Politics of China’s Foreign Policy”. The event was part of the Hong Siew Ching Speaker Series and took place during the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy’s Festival of Ideas 2022.
Prof. Weiss discussed the variation in China’s international behavior. At different times, and across different issue areas, China’s behavior has been labelled as “revisionist”, “stakeholder”, or “free-rider”. Addressing this puzzling variation, Weiss argued that Beijing’s foreign policy preferences and behavior across issue areas was both influenced by, and had an impact on, domestic politics.
According to Weiss, two characteristics—centrality and contestation—shapes China’s domestic politics on any given issue.
Sovereignty-linked issues like Hong Kong, Taiwan, and maritime disputes were of ‘high centrality’, while others like UN peacekeeping were of ‘low centrality’. International pressure on China over ‘high centrality’ issues, Weiss suggested, were more likely to backfire, resulting in bargaining failures and leading Beijing to breach international norms.
Contestation referred to the degree of domestic division and contestation over government policy in a given international issue. Even authoritarian regimes are not monolithic, and they can face implementation and enforcement problems over highly contested issues.
This approach of analysing how domestic interests shapes foreign policy was based on Kenneth Waltz’s ‘second image’ approach. Yet, Weiss also observed how the international environment exerted influence on domestic political choices, referring to this as ‘second image reversed’. For example, by framing resistance in Hong Kong and the US–China trade war as part of a national struggle, the Chinese government has sought to build public support for the costs of conflict, raise the domestic cost of international concessions, and signal its intent to stand firm against foreign pressure.
Beijing has been strategic in determining when to allow or repress nationalist mobilization. For instance, it has tolerated the online harassment of Chinese netizens who criticise government policies on social media and online forums. Yet, the Chinese government also faces occasional challenges to control public sentiment. Its response to the restart of US patrols in the South China Sea in 2015 was seen as unsatisfactory by some Chinese nationalists and resulted in a drop in public approval for the Chinese government.
Such dynamics between China’s domestic and foreign policy could have important implications for the trajectory of US-China relations. In the short term, Beijing’s policies thread the needle between projecting resolve and mitigating near-term risks of unwanted escalation. In the long term, repression of dovish voices in China will heightened US perceptions of threat. This reduces credibility of China’s assurances and ambiguity/flexibility in foreign perceptions of Beijing’s intent.
It is important to understand that Chinese rhetoric plays to multiple audiences may be targeted towards reducing domestic contestation on central issues.
Weiss concluded that China has behaved strategically as a “disgruntled stakeholder” and the Chinese Communist Party's ambitions are more nationalist than universalist. The best response to a rising China is an asymmetric approach that focuses on an affirmative, inclusive vision that creates space for cooperation on shared challenges and avoids conflict.
When asked about how can the US not see China as a threat, Weiss said that China has not tried to promote autocracy nor overthrow democracy, but the CCP persist in safeguarding its own interests. As China becomes more interested in setting itself as an alternative to the US, the future of this ideological competition will depend on the actions that both sides will take.
“A world safe for autocracy isn’t my ideal future. I want a world safe for diversity,” Weiss said at the end.
For more information about Festival of Ideas 2022: http://www.lkyspp.sg/foi2022
#GovernancefortheFuture #publicpolicy #policymatters
================================================
Visit us
Website: http://lkyspp.nus.edu.sg
Follow us on
Facebook: facebook.com/nuslkyspp
Twitter: twitter.com/lkysch
Instagram: instagram.com/lkyspp
LinkedIn University Page: linkedin.com/edu/school?id=42060
Subscribe and click on the bell icon to be the first to watch our videos! 🔔
On October 11, 2022, the Centre on Asia and Globalisation hosted Associate Professor Jessica Chen Weiss, Michael J. Zak Professor for China and Asia-Pacific Studies at the Department of Government of Cornell University, who presented on, “A World Safe for Autocracy: The Domestic Politics of China’s Foreign Policy”. The event was part of the Hong Siew Ching Speaker Series and took place during the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy’s Festival of Ideas 2022.
Prof. Weiss discussed the variation in China’s international behavior. At different times, and across different issue areas, China’s behavior has been labelled as “revisionist”, “stakeholder”, or “free-rider”. Addressing this puzzling variation, Weiss argued that Beijing’s foreign policy preferences and behavior across issue areas was both influenced by, and had an impact on, domestic politics.
According to Weiss, two characteristics—centrality and contestation—shapes China’s domestic politics on any given issue.
Sovereignty-linked issues like Hong Kong, Taiwan, and maritime disputes were of ‘high centrality’, while others like UN peacekeeping were of ‘low centrality’. International pressure on China over ‘high centrality’ issues, Weiss suggested, were more likely to backfire, resulting in bargaining failures and leading Beijing to breach international norms.
Contestation referred to the degree of domestic division and contestation over government policy in a given international issue. Even authoritarian regimes are not monolithic, and they can face implementation and enforcement problems over highly contested issues.
This approach of analysing how domestic interests shapes foreign policy was based on Kenneth Waltz’s ‘second image’ approach. Yet, Weiss also observed how the international environment exerted influence on domestic political choices, referring to this as ‘second image reversed’. For example, by framing resistance in Hong Kong and the US–China trade war as part of a national struggle, the Chinese government has sought to build public support for the costs of conflict, raise the domestic cost of international concessions, and signal its intent to stand firm against foreign pressure.
Beijing has been strategic in determining when to allow or repress nationalist mobilization. For instance, it has tolerated the online harassment of Chinese netizens who criticise government policies on social media and online forums. Yet, the Chinese government also faces occasional challenges to control public sentiment. Its response to the restart of US patrols in the South China Sea in 2015 was seen as unsatisfactory by some Chinese nationalists and resulted in a drop in public approval for the Chinese government.
Such dynamics between China’s domestic and foreign policy could have important implications for the trajectory of US-China relations. In the short term, Beijing’s policies thread the needle between projecting resolve and mitigating near-term risks of unwanted escalation. In the long term, repression of dovish voices in China will heightened US perceptions of threat. This reduces credibility of China’s assurances and ambiguity/flexibility in foreign perceptions of Beijing’s intent.
It is important to understand that Chinese rhetoric plays to multiple audiences may be targeted towards reducing domestic contestation on central issues.
Weiss concluded that China has behaved strategically as a “disgruntled stakeholder” and the Chinese Communist Party's ambitions are more nationalist than universalist. The best response to a rising China is an asymmetric approach that focuses on an affirmative, inclusive vision that creates space for cooperation on shared challenges and avoids conflict.
When asked about how can the US not see China as a threat, Weiss said that China has not tried to promote autocracy nor overthrow democracy, but the CCP persist in safeguarding its own interests. As China becomes more interested in setting itself as an alternative to the US, the future of this ideological competition will depend on the actions that both sides will take.
“A world safe for autocracy isn’t my ideal future. I want a world safe for diversity,” Weiss said at the end.
For more information about Festival of Ideas 2022: http://www.lkyspp.sg/foi2022
#GovernancefortheFuture #publicpolicy #policymatters
================================================
Visit us
Website: http://lkyspp.nus.edu.sg
Follow us on
Facebook: facebook.com/nuslkyspp
Twitter: twitter.com/lkysch
Instagram: instagram.com/lkyspp
LinkedIn University Page: linkedin.com/edu/school?id=42060
Subscribe and click on the bell icon to be the first to watch our videos! 🔔


![[CIP series] Can Small States and Middle Powers Shape the Indo-Pacific?
In his landmark address at the World Economic Forum’s Annual Meeting in January 2026, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney called on the world’s middle powers to collaborate to shape a new international order – one that upholds multilateral institutions, preserves rules and limits the coercive leverage of great powers.
The evolving geopolitical dynamics of the Indo-Pacific have lent renewed urgency to this long-standing yet unresolved debate: do small and middle states possess meaningful agency in shaping regional order, or are they ultimately constrained by structural pressures imposed by great power competition?
Counterpoint Indo-Pacific is a webinar and policy brief series published by the Centre on Asia and Globalisation at the National University of Singapores Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy. The main objective of CIP is to bring together experts from across the region to discuss critical issues concerning the Indo-Pacific. Each issue will tackle one question from three to four different perspectives.
Speakers:
Sarah Teo, Assistant Professor, Regional Security Architecture Programme, Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies (IDSS), S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS), Nanyang Technological University
Kanti Bajpai, Visiting Professor of International Relations, Ashoka University; Emeritus Professor, Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore
Tomoo Kikuchi, Professor, the Graduate School of Asia-Pacific Studies and Institute of Japan in the Global Economy, Waseda University
Moderator:
Denis Hew, Senior Research Fellow, Centre on Asia and Globalisation (CAG), Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore
Check out Counterpoint Indo-Pacific (CIP)s page:
cag-lkyspp.com/cip-page
Subscribe to Counterpoint Indo-Pacific (CIP) newsletter to stay up to date with future events and news:
cag-lkyspp.com/CIP-Subscribe
#GovernancefortheFuture #PublicPolicy #PolicyMatters #MiddlePower #SmallStates #IndoPacific #CounterpointIndoPacific #CAG_LKYSPP
Visit us
Website: http://lkyspp.nus.edu.sg
Follow us on
Facebook: http://facebook.com/nuslkyspp
Twitter: http://twitter.com/lkysch
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lkyspp/
LinkedIn University Page: https://www.linkedin.com/edu/school?id=42060
Subscribe and click on the bell icon to be the first to watch our videos! 🔔 [CIP series] Can Small States and Middle Powers Shape the Indo-Pacific?](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/WahHgA4RUjM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Foreseeable Podcast] Forging stewards of biodiversity with local communities
What are the most effective methods of protecting, and hopefully restoring, the planets biodiversity?
This is a key question underlying the work of Tanya OGarra, Senior Research Fellow at the Institute for Environment and Sustainability, Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy. Tanya is an environmental economist with over 15 years’ experience conducting research on the valuation of ecosystem services and the collective management of shared natural resources. She has recently published a study on the effectiveness of community-based approaches to conservation and natural resource management.
Foreseeable is a podcast series by Global-is-Asian (GIA), the flagship digital thought leadership platform of Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy. In each episode, we invite an expert for a conversation relating to their area of expertise and to find out what they foresee happening in the future.
More Foreseeable podcasts are available on these platforms:
GIA website: https://lkyspp.nus.edu.sg/gia
Spotify: https://lkyspp.sg/2RTqzrz
OmnyStudio: https://lkyspp.sg/3cgO7Cb
Apple podcast: https://lkyspp.sg/2QDJzh3
Google podcast: https://lkyspp.sg/3d4zVez
Visit GIA website and subscribe to our newsletter.
#GovernancefortheFuture #publicpolicy #policymatters
Visit us
Website: http://lkyspp.nus.edu.sg
Follow us on
Facebook: http://facebook.com/nuslkyspp
Twitter: http://twitter.com/lkysch
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lkyspp/
LinkedIn University Page: https://www.linkedin.com/edu/school?id=42060
Subscribe and click on the bell icon to be the first to watch our videos! 🔔 [Foreseeable Podcast] Forging stewards of biodiversity with local communities](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/XVX89ZzBFZY/mqdefault.jpg)



![[Foreseeable Podcast] Policy design capacity building for Southeast Asias climate challenges
Benjamin Cashore is Li Ka Shing Professor in Public Management and Director of the Institute for Environment and Sustainability (IES) at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy.
He specialises in global and multi-level environmental governance, comparative public policy and administration, and transnational business regulation and corporate social responsibility.
In his role as the Director of IES, he focuses on helping governments and private sectors close the gap between policy commitments and actual outcomes through fit-for-purpose policy analysis. He joins us to help explain just how that works in the real world.
Foreseeable is a podcast series by Global-is-Asian (GIA), the flagship digital thought leadership platform of Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy. In each episode, we invite an expert for a conversation relating to their area of expertise and to find out what they foresee happening in the future.
More Foreseeable podcasts are available on these platforms:
GIA website: https://lkyspp.nus.edu.sg/gia
Spotify: https://lkyspp.sg/2RTqzrz
OmnyStudio: https://lkyspp.sg/3cgO7Cb
Apple podcast: https://lkyspp.sg/2QDJzh3
Google podcast: https://lkyspp.sg/3d4zVez
Visit GIA website and subscribe to our newsletter.
#GovernancefortheFuture #publicpolicy #policymatters
Visit us
Website: http://lkyspp.nus.edu.sg
Follow us on
Facebook: http://facebook.com/nuslkyspp
Twitter: http://twitter.com/lkysch
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lkyspp/
LinkedIn University Page: https://www.linkedin.com/edu/school?id=42060
Subscribe and click on the bell icon to be the first to watch our videos! 🔔 [Foreseeable Podcast] Policy design capacity building for Southeast Asias climate challenges](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ys-ngk8sMtY/mqdefault.jpg)


