Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
The FAKE Christa Pike stories are getting absolutely OUT OF CONTROL… and now people are claiming SHADOLLA PETERSON was actually responsible for the murder of Colleen Slemmer?!
In today's AfterPrisonShow video, we're diving into the unbelievable rumors, alleged Facebook Messenger conversations, accusations, and social media drama surrounding the Christa Pike case.
Following Pike's botched execution attempt, interest in her case has exploded. But so has the amount of questionable information being shared online.
Now, screenshots are circulating that supposedly show Shadolla Peterson, who was involved in the original 1995 case, making shocking admissions about what happened to Colleen Slemmer.
But are these conversations even REAL? And why are people spreading such outrageous claims?
We break down:
- The allegations involving Shadolla Peterson and her actual connection to the Christa Pike case.
- The supposed Facebook Messenger conversations containing shocking claims about Colleen Slemmer's murder.
- The social media personalities spreading these stories and the drama now unfolding between them.
- Accusations of stolen content, fabricated information, and people profiting from viral crime stories.
- The growing obsession with Christa Pike following her failed execution.
- How Facebook monetization may be encouraging people to sensationalize and potentially fabricate true crime stories.
- Why verifying information matters, especially when real victims and their families are involved.
We also discuss my own process for verifying stories, including times when information I initially questioned turned out to be accurate, and how even major news outlets can report conflicting claims.
**IMPORTANT:** The alleged conversations and accusations featured in this video are NOT presented as verified facts. We're examining the claims being circulated and questioning their credibility.
At what point does true crime coverage stop being about the actual crime and victims and start becoming a competition for views, followers, and MONEY?
Let me know what you think in the comments!
Subscribe to AfterPrisonShow for more prison stories, true crime coverage, death row developments, and criminal justice news.
#ChristaPike #ShadollaPeterson #AfterPrisonShow #ColleenSlemmer #DeathRow #TrueCrime #ChristaPikeUpdate #PrisonNews #TrueCrimeCommunity #ExecutionNews #FacebookDrama #CrimeNews
Interested in any of my diet must haves or camera gear? Check it all out here: amazon.com/shop/joedoesstuff?ref_=cm_sw_r_cp_ud_aipsfshop_N3JNAWB78V6KD7ZVESFK
Facebook.com/afterprison (Most active here. Best way to reach me)
tiktok.com/@afterprisonshow
Become a channel member: youtube.com/channel/UCSonmKTLAPC2bTCF4JHQ1lg/join
For business inquiries: joepguerrero2@gmail.com
Instagram.com/AfterPrisonShow_Joe
Other Videos to check out!
Why I went to prison FULL STORY: youtu.be/7ECgj1NzG_8
How tattooing saved my life in prison: youtu.be/SkKQHbFBmH0
How to TALK like a PRISONER: youtu.be/EAnTkMCEVDk
10 Ways To Cook Ramen Noodles In Prison: youtu.be/CAZuyscGGNU
My FIRST day in PRISON: youtu.be/57cxNR4WFEU
5 Myths about Prison: youtu.be/6Lh3Q2iE8js
The FAKE Christa Pike stories are getting absolutely OUT OF CONTROL… and now people are claiming SHADOLLA PETERSON was actually responsible for the murder of Colleen Slemmer?!
In today's AfterPrisonShow video, we're diving into the unbelievable rumors, alleged Facebook Messenger conversations, accusations, and social media drama surrounding the Christa Pike case.
Following Pike's botched execution attempt, interest in her case has exploded. But so has the amount of questionable information being shared online.
Now, screenshots are circulating that supposedly show Shadolla Peterson, who was involved in the original 1995 case, making shocking admissions about what happened to Colleen Slemmer.
But are these conversations even REAL? And why are people spreading such outrageous claims?
We break down:
- The allegations involving Shadolla Peterson and her actual connection to the Christa Pike case.
- The supposed Facebook Messenger conversations containing shocking claims about Colleen Slemmer's murder.
- The social media personalities spreading these stories and the drama now unfolding between them.
- Accusations of stolen content, fabricated information, and people profiting from viral crime stories.
- The growing obsession with Christa Pike following her failed execution.
- How Facebook monetization may be encouraging people to sensationalize and potentially fabricate true crime stories.
- Why verifying information matters, especially when real victims and their families are involved.
We also discuss my own process for verifying stories, including times when information I initially questioned turned out to be accurate, and how even major news outlets can report conflicting claims.
**IMPORTANT:** The alleged conversations and accusations featured in this video are NOT presented as verified facts. We're examining the claims being circulated and questioning their credibility.
At what point does true crime coverage stop being about the actual crime and victims and start becoming a competition for views, followers, and MONEY?
Let me know what you think in the comments!
Subscribe to AfterPrisonShow for more prison stories, true crime coverage, death row developments, and criminal justice news.
#ChristaPike #ShadollaPeterson #AfterPrisonShow #ColleenSlemmer #DeathRow #TrueCrime #ChristaPikeUpdate #PrisonNews #TrueCrimeCommunity #ExecutionNews #FacebookDrama #CrimeNews
Interested in any of my diet must haves or camera gear? Check it all out here: amazon.com/shop/joedoesstuff?ref_=cm_sw_r_cp_ud_aipsfshop_N3JNAWB78V6KD7ZVESFK
Facebook.com/afterprison (Most active here. Best way to reach me)
tiktok.com/@afterprisonshow
Become a channel member: youtube.com/channel/UCSonmKTLAPC2bTCF4JHQ1lg/join
For business inquiries: joepguerrero2@gmail.com
Instagram.com/AfterPrisonShow_Joe
Other Videos to check out!
Why I went to prison FULL STORY: youtu.be/7ECgj1NzG_8
How tattooing saved my life in prison: youtu.be/SkKQHbFBmH0
How to TALK like a PRISONER: youtu.be/EAnTkMCEVDk
10 Ways To Cook Ramen Noodles In Prison: youtu.be/CAZuyscGGNU
My FIRST day in PRISON: youtu.be/57cxNR4WFEU
5 Myths about Prison: youtu.be/6Lh3Q2iE8js










