Uploaded March 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Dr. Eyal Aharoni (Georgia State University) to the Future Day 2026 stage to discuss one of the most provocative frontiers in technology: the automation of moral judgement.
Breaking the Moral Turing Test: Studies of human attribution and deference to AI moral judgment and decision-making
Synopsis: As AI systems become integrated into high-stakes environments, we face a critical question: How much do we trust an algorithm’s “conscience”? Dr. Aharoni will present findings from the first Modified Moral Turing Test (mMTT), revealing how laypeople perceive AI-generated moral commentary.
The talk moves from the laboratory to the hospital, discussing new research on AI-assisted medical triage. While high-performance AI can save lives, it also risks eroding human performance through over-trust. Dr. Aharoni will outline a novel framework for predicting and mitigating these errors, ensuring that when humans and AI collaborate in emergencies, the results are better – not worse – than either could achieve alone.
0:00 Intro
0:40 Talk - Breaking the Moral Turing Test
1:36 The LLM moral reasoning challenge - LLMs outperform humans in moral reasoning - Moral reasoning is regarded as one of the most sophisticated and unique of human faculties. Given the results of comparative moral turing tests and other studies, LLMs seem to outperform and enhance human reasoning in various ways. Do LLMs challenge the tenet?
2:10 LLM Problems: transparency, wide bugs, lack emotional checks & balances
3:28 Metaphysical challenge: Do LLMs have moral intelligence?
3:50 Psychological challenge: Do humans perceive AIs as having moral intelligence?
4:03 How do ordinary people perceive LLM moral commentary? - The (Explicit) Moral Turing Test MTT & its problems
5:14 Problem of demand characteristics
5:52 The Comparative Moral Turing Test (cMTT)
6:47 Stimulus Development
7:57 Funeral example as a conventional wrong
9:07 cMTT result analysis
10:03 Predictions (pre-registered)
11:41 cMTT Results - participants rated the LLM generated responses as significantly better in quality than he human-generated ones
12:46 cMTT Descriptives - quality preference by criterion
13:21 cMTT results - participants guessed which responses were generated by an LLM 80% of the time
15:15 'Breaking' the MTT - AI exceeded expectations
16:03 False Conclusions: not claiming that LLMs are morally intelligent, or humans think LLM evals are generally superior etc
17:21 Study Conclusions: AI moral responses superior & perceived moral expertise may have given identity away
17:46 Trust of AI may lead to uncritical acceptance of questionable advice
18:37 Pope Leo's warning against LLM generation of sermons
19:20 AI in high stakes decision contexts - Medical Triage
21:03 Can AI's outperform medical professionals - initial data (HealthBench - Evaluating LLMs Towards Improved Human Health)
21:51 AI decision support - the human factor - The Performance Paradox
24:01 When AI seems reliable, humans tend to increase risk exposure
25:10 Ensuring human-AI collaborations are constructive
27:50 Real time AI assistance in learning, then withdrawal of AI assistance (study 1)
31:30 Test immediate vs delayed assistance (before vs after human judgement) (study 2)
33:34 Human-Centered Design - Designs: fault injection, prompting users for justifications for their judgements (before receiving AI judgement) etc
37:30 Ethical Questions in AI-Assisted Triage
41:20 End of presentation. Q&A starts
41:48 Enfeeblement vs empowerment - when and when not to outsource to AI
45:24 Why do we have moral reasoning? (evolutionary reasoning etc) Rivalrist or pluralist theories? - Better angels of our nature evolved because they were useful (reciprocity, cooperation). LLMs give us moral cues that evolution has taught us to associate with the presence of a moral actor or patient. (so how can we separate the detection of actual moral behaviour from these psychological cues?)
50:50 Blade Runner synth detection tech - our Turing tests will have to become more sophisticated
56:04 Consciousness in non-human animals
57:39 Main vulnerabilities of over-trust in AI - realtime/high stakes decisions
1:06:06 AI as a tutor, instead of an oracle
1:09:28 Can AI be more moral than us? Can AI help us be more moral?
1:16:51 How is change in AI effecting how we think about AI and the advice they give etc?
1:18:53 AI capability is jagged and brittle - in high stakes AI hallucinations could cause fatalities
1:19:56 Hard to know how much time we have before transformative AI to work on guardrails
#AI #Ethics #Philosophy
Many thanks for tuning in!
Please support SciFuture by subscribing and sharing!
Buy me a coffee? buymeacoffee.com/tech101z
Kind regards,
Adam Ford
- Science, Technology & the Future - #SciFuture - scifuture.org
Dr. Eyal Aharoni (Georgia State University) to the Future Day 2026 stage to discuss one of the most provocative frontiers in technology: the automation of moral judgement.
Breaking the Moral Turing Test: Studies of human attribution and deference to AI moral judgment and decision-making
Synopsis: As AI systems become integrated into high-stakes environments, we face a critical question: How much do we trust an algorithm’s “conscience”? Dr. Aharoni will present findings from the first Modified Moral Turing Test (mMTT), revealing how laypeople perceive AI-generated moral commentary.
The talk moves from the laboratory to the hospital, discussing new research on AI-assisted medical triage. While high-performance AI can save lives, it also risks eroding human performance through over-trust. Dr. Aharoni will outline a novel framework for predicting and mitigating these errors, ensuring that when humans and AI collaborate in emergencies, the results are better – not worse – than either could achieve alone.
0:00 Intro
0:40 Talk - Breaking the Moral Turing Test
1:36 The LLM moral reasoning challenge - LLMs outperform humans in moral reasoning - Moral reasoning is regarded as one of the most sophisticated and unique of human faculties. Given the results of comparative moral turing tests and other studies, LLMs seem to outperform and enhance human reasoning in various ways. Do LLMs challenge the tenet?
2:10 LLM Problems: transparency, wide bugs, lack emotional checks & balances
3:28 Metaphysical challenge: Do LLMs have moral intelligence?
3:50 Psychological challenge: Do humans perceive AIs as having moral intelligence?
4:03 How do ordinary people perceive LLM moral commentary? - The (Explicit) Moral Turing Test MTT & its problems
5:14 Problem of demand characteristics
5:52 The Comparative Moral Turing Test (cMTT)
6:47 Stimulus Development
7:57 Funeral example as a conventional wrong
9:07 cMTT result analysis
10:03 Predictions (pre-registered)
11:41 cMTT Results - participants rated the LLM generated responses as significantly better in quality than he human-generated ones
12:46 cMTT Descriptives - quality preference by criterion
13:21 cMTT results - participants guessed which responses were generated by an LLM 80% of the time
15:15 'Breaking' the MTT - AI exceeded expectations
16:03 False Conclusions: not claiming that LLMs are morally intelligent, or humans think LLM evals are generally superior etc
17:21 Study Conclusions: AI moral responses superior & perceived moral expertise may have given identity away
17:46 Trust of AI may lead to uncritical acceptance of questionable advice
18:37 Pope Leo's warning against LLM generation of sermons
19:20 AI in high stakes decision contexts - Medical Triage
21:03 Can AI's outperform medical professionals - initial data (HealthBench - Evaluating LLMs Towards Improved Human Health)
21:51 AI decision support - the human factor - The Performance Paradox
24:01 When AI seems reliable, humans tend to increase risk exposure
25:10 Ensuring human-AI collaborations are constructive
27:50 Real time AI assistance in learning, then withdrawal of AI assistance (study 1)
31:30 Test immediate vs delayed assistance (before vs after human judgement) (study 2)
33:34 Human-Centered Design - Designs: fault injection, prompting users for justifications for their judgements (before receiving AI judgement) etc
37:30 Ethical Questions in AI-Assisted Triage
41:20 End of presentation. Q&A starts
41:48 Enfeeblement vs empowerment - when and when not to outsource to AI
45:24 Why do we have moral reasoning? (evolutionary reasoning etc) Rivalrist or pluralist theories? - Better angels of our nature evolved because they were useful (reciprocity, cooperation). LLMs give us moral cues that evolution has taught us to associate with the presence of a moral actor or patient. (so how can we separate the detection of actual moral behaviour from these psychological cues?)
50:50 Blade Runner synth detection tech - our Turing tests will have to become more sophisticated
56:04 Consciousness in non-human animals
57:39 Main vulnerabilities of over-trust in AI - realtime/high stakes decisions
1:06:06 AI as a tutor, instead of an oracle
1:09:28 Can AI be more moral than us? Can AI help us be more moral?
1:16:51 How is change in AI effecting how we think about AI and the advice they give etc?
1:18:53 AI capability is jagged and brittle - in high stakes AI hallucinations could cause fatalities
1:19:56 Hard to know how much time we have before transformative AI to work on guardrails
#AI #Ethics #Philosophy
Many thanks for tuning in!
Please support SciFuture by subscribing and sharing!
Buy me a coffee? buymeacoffee.com/tech101z
Kind regards,
Adam Ford
- Science, Technology & the Future - #SciFuture - scifuture.org










![Wendell Wallach - AI Regulation Lessons from China #Ethics #AIEthics #China
This video features Wendell Wallach discussing the potential lessons Western institutions can learn from Chinas approach to AI regulation and the ethical responsibilities of corporations.
Learning from Chinese Regulation: Wallach suggests that the West should look more closely at Chinese AI governance strategies [00:07]. While not suggesting a wholesale copy, he notes that Chinas regulations place constraints on the social deployment of AI to ensure it benefits the citizenry [00:30].
Criticism of Western AI Oversight: He describes the current regulatory environment in the West as a mess, citing a lack of corporate accountability that has led to widespread misinformation and the exploitation of citizens [00:45].
The Problem with Bad Capitalism: Wallach critiques the current form of capitalism in America, arguing that it funnels all benefits to capitalists while ignoring the societal costs [01:28]. He emphasizes that corporations are reaping massive rewards without being held responsible for the negative impacts of their technologies through taxation or other guidelines [01:47].
A Call for Responsible Capitalism: He concludes that a more benign form of capitalism is one that demands corporations take responsibility for the societal costs created by their products [02:06].
Wendell Wallach (born 21 April 1946) is a world-renowned bioethicist and expert on the ethics and governance of emerging technologies, particularly artificial intelligence (AI) and neuroscience. Often referred to as a godfather of AI ethics, his work focuses on the challenges of aligning rapidly advancing systems with human values.
# Current Roles & Affiliations:
Wallach remains active in several prestigious academic and policy institutions:
- Yale University: Emeritus Scholar at the Interdisciplinary Center for Bioethics, where he chaired the Technology and Ethics study group for 11 years.
- Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs: Carnegie-Uehiro Senior Fellow and co-director of the AI & Equality Initiative (AIEI), which addresses structural inequalities driven by AI.
- The Hastings Center: Senior Advisor for this nonpartisan research institute focused on the social and ethical issues of science and health.
- Other Fellows: Fellow at the Sandra Day O’Connor School of Law (Arizona State University) and the Institute for Ethics & Emerging Technology.Key Publications
# He has authored several foundational works that helped define the field of machine ethics:
- Moral Machines: Teaching Robots Right from Wrong (2008): Co-authored with Colin Allen, this is widely considered the first book to examine the challenge of building artificial moral agents.
- A Dangerous Master: How to Keep Technology from Slipping Beyond Our Control (2015): Explores the risks of unchecked technological development and proposes governance solutions. A revised edition with a new preface was released in 2024.
- Library of Essays on Ethics and Emerging Technologies: Series editor for this comprehensive eight-volume collection published by Routledge.
# Global Policy & Influence
Wallach has a significant presence in international policy forums:United Nations: Has provided testimony to the UN on lethal autonomous weapons systems and advised on digital cooperation.
World Economic Forum (WEF): Formerly co-chaired the Global Future Council on Technology, Values, and Policy and served on the AI Council.
# Awards: Recipient of the World Technology Network awards for Ethics (2014) and Journalism & Media (2015).
#moralmachines #MachineEthics #AI
Many thanks for tuning in!
Please support SciFuture by subscribing and sharing!
Buy me a coffee? https://buymeacoffee.com/tech101z
Have any ideas about people to interview? Want to be notified about future events? Any comments about the STF series?
Please fill out this form: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1mr9PIfq2ZYlQsXRIn5BcLH2onbiSI7g79mOH_AFCdIk/
Kind regards,
Adam Ford
- Science, Technology & the Future - #SciFuture - http://scifuture.org Wendell Wallach - AI Regulation Lessons from China #Ethics #AIEthics #China](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/VYJKq9W1Uu0/mqdefault.jpg)