Uploaded February 2025 | Updated November 2026, 18 hours ago
Let's examine a tiny piece of one of the most confusing young Earth creationist talks I've heard in quite some time. Dr. Carl Werner claims 2024 is "the year evolution was overturned," but his fundamental misunderstandings of evolutionary theory are astonishing. I focus on his demonstration that inheritance of acquired characteristics is wrong as if he has destroyed Darwinian evolution and his complete failure mention natural selection - the actual primary mechanism of evolution.
Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction
00:47 - Werner's "Two Mechanisms" Claim
02:31 - The Inheritance of Acquired Characteristics
06:05 - What Darwin Actually Believed
10:13 - Werner's Mutation Misunderstandings
14:45 - Why Natural Selection Matters
19:26 - Cherry-Picking to Mislead an Audience
25:03 - Why Werner is on the Fringe of Creationism
As a biology professor, I'm stunned by Werner's confidence despite spending "45 years studying evolutionary biology" while missing its most basic concepts. He repeatedly conflates Lamarckian evolution with Darwinian evolution and demonstrates profound misconceptions about how mutations work in populations.
Dr. Carl Werner presenting at Twin Cities Creation Science Association Feb 2025. youtu.be/FHoKQZNSwyU?si=ULr_ZTj_LAcES3NB&t=1670
Post-recording note: I realized after recording this episode that he says "Darwin says this is a reason for how evolution occurred" rather than "THE reason for how". Below is the the transcript of Werner's video for the portion that I showed. It is very difficult to tell if he thinks there are only two basic mechanisms for evolution (the words he uses) or if he mean that there are two basic mechanisms that are debunked - but never goes on to mention natural selection at all!). Points is that he is very hard to understand so I may have misunderstood his intent here.
"Now I want to show you that the mechanisms of evolution don't work there's basically two and both of them don't work one is this idea that an animal can adapt and pass those adaptations onto the next generation Darwin believed this and he said it was a reason for how Evolution occurred he called it the law of use and disuse and this is why it doesn't work. Darwin thought if you exercised a horse and got it really strong strong muscles, that The offspring of the horse would be born with large muscles he wrote that in the Origin of Species that's foolish you can exercise a horse all you want the baby will not be affected by the exercise that would be like a weightlifter in the gym gets big muscles and his child is born with big biceps, that's stupid. It doesn't happen why does that not work because you know the horse and the weightlifter adapted but see they can't pass it on because the body is divided in to two kinds of cells…
Keywords: #evolution #creationism #Darwin #naturalselection #Lamarckianism #inheritanceofacquiredcharacteristics #biology misconceptions #evolutionary biology #science education #creationistmyths
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Joel Duff (aka Dr. Duff or The Natural Historian) resources:
About: joelduff.org
Blog: thenaturalhistorian.com
Twitter: twitter.com/NaturalHistoria
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thenaturalhi...
Photography "Portraits of Creation:" beechnutphotography.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Let's examine a tiny piece of one of the most confusing young Earth creationist talks I've heard in quite some time. Dr. Carl Werner claims 2024 is "the year evolution was overturned," but his fundamental misunderstandings of evolutionary theory are astonishing. I focus on his demonstration that inheritance of acquired characteristics is wrong as if he has destroyed Darwinian evolution and his complete failure mention natural selection - the actual primary mechanism of evolution.
Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction
00:47 - Werner's "Two Mechanisms" Claim
02:31 - The Inheritance of Acquired Characteristics
06:05 - What Darwin Actually Believed
10:13 - Werner's Mutation Misunderstandings
14:45 - Why Natural Selection Matters
19:26 - Cherry-Picking to Mislead an Audience
25:03 - Why Werner is on the Fringe of Creationism
As a biology professor, I'm stunned by Werner's confidence despite spending "45 years studying evolutionary biology" while missing its most basic concepts. He repeatedly conflates Lamarckian evolution with Darwinian evolution and demonstrates profound misconceptions about how mutations work in populations.
Dr. Carl Werner presenting at Twin Cities Creation Science Association Feb 2025. youtu.be/FHoKQZNSwyU?si=ULr_ZTj_LAcES3NB&t=1670
Post-recording note: I realized after recording this episode that he says "Darwin says this is a reason for how evolution occurred" rather than "THE reason for how". Below is the the transcript of Werner's video for the portion that I showed. It is very difficult to tell if he thinks there are only two basic mechanisms for evolution (the words he uses) or if he mean that there are two basic mechanisms that are debunked - but never goes on to mention natural selection at all!). Points is that he is very hard to understand so I may have misunderstood his intent here.
"Now I want to show you that the mechanisms of evolution don't work there's basically two and both of them don't work one is this idea that an animal can adapt and pass those adaptations onto the next generation Darwin believed this and he said it was a reason for how Evolution occurred he called it the law of use and disuse and this is why it doesn't work. Darwin thought if you exercised a horse and got it really strong strong muscles, that The offspring of the horse would be born with large muscles he wrote that in the Origin of Species that's foolish you can exercise a horse all you want the baby will not be affected by the exercise that would be like a weightlifter in the gym gets big muscles and his child is born with big biceps, that's stupid. It doesn't happen why does that not work because you know the horse and the weightlifter adapted but see they can't pass it on because the body is divided in to two kinds of cells…
Keywords: #evolution #creationism #Darwin #naturalselection #Lamarckianism #inheritanceofacquiredcharacteristics #biology misconceptions #evolutionary biology #science education #creationistmyths
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Joel Duff (aka Dr. Duff or The Natural Historian) resources:
About: joelduff.org
Blog: thenaturalhistorian.com
Twitter: twitter.com/NaturalHistoria
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thenaturalhi...
Photography "Portraits of Creation:" beechnutphotography.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------










