Episode 4 - Photons as Waves and Detection Events (with Chantal Roth) @FractalWoman
Episode 4 - Photons as Waves and Detection Events (with Chantal Roth)  @FractalWoman
Uploaded July 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
In this fourth discussion with Chantal, we ask a basic question: if light is a real wave in an elastic medium, what do we actually mean by a "photon"?

We begin with phonons - quantized vibrational modes in ordinary solids. Phonons are called quasiparticles, but we know they are collective waves. They can interfere, pass through double-slit arrangements, undergo quantum-erasure experiments, and produce discrete detector clicks. This gives us a useful mechanical comparison for light.

We then look at quantization as a natural property of trapped waves. A string, drumhead, or spherical wave supports only certain stable modes. Matter waves and electron orbitals can be viewed through the same language of standing waves and spherical harmonics, with transitions between modes taking place continuously.

The main focus is the photoelectric effect. Using resonance, detector thresholds, and Fermi's Golden Rule, we explore how a continuous electromagnetic wave can drive an electron between discrete energy levels. Frequency selects which transitions are possible, while intensity affects the transition rate. The resulting electron emission is a discrete detection event even if the incoming light is a wave.

We also discuss single-emission pulses, double-slit detection patterns, the Wiener experiment, Compton scattering, Planck's constant, uncertainty as a Fourier property of localized waves, and matter-antimatter annihilation as one wave pattern cancelling into another. The proposal explored here is that a photon need not be an infinitesimal point particle: it can be understood as an emission or detection event associated with a real electromagnetic wave.

Simulations:

* Phonon modes: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/vd9ym6gx
* Phonon vs photon: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/29t8dmhu
* Double slit with people: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/9ezhntL3
* Quantized trapped wave: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/bLw0s81y
* 2D harmonics: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/95bLo6uc
* Spherical harmonics 1: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/apx1hu2q
* Spherical harmonics 2: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/kng286d7
* Harmonic transitions 1: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/z0repod7
* Harmonic transitions 2: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/wu10pLkn
* Drumhead transitions: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/yg4fcdxm
* Free electron: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/qxncdgwu
* Waves as detection events: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/8z5ub9aq
* Photon as detection: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/fxcpmj3b
* Swing resonance 1: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/o9Lund76
* Swing resonance 2: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/ujsmLf1t
* Fermi's Golden Rule: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/37zqmd0s
* Photoelectric effect: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/z8bd51of
* Electromagnetic wave: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/g1w86jsy
* Single emission pulse: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/2cphue8w
* Double slit intensity: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/kx0dtp7h
* Double slit detections: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/4she27ax
* Wiener experiment: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/bhnLe08s
* Meaning of h 1: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/7zhkop0j
* Meaning of h 2: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/86db3njr
* Heisenberg/Fourier: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/cLfrs7tm
* Uncertainty: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/dbefpwzt
* Double slit/which path: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/sr57vd02
* Matter and antimatter: jsfiddle.net/Chenopdodium/1c7a58nf

References:

* Double-slit phonon states: arxiv.org/pdf/1902.06344.pdf
* Quantum erasure with acoustic phonons: arxiv.org/abs/2005.09311
* Matter-wave diffraction with C60: https://www.quantumnano.at/research/universal-matter-waves/far-field-diffraction/the-origin-c60-diffraction/
* Atom laser: https://news.mit.edu/1997/atom-0129
* Rashkovskiy - Classical Field Theory of the Photoelectric Effect: researchgate.net/publication/325749189_Classical_Field_Theory_of_the_Photoelectric_Effect
* Rashkovskiy - Are There Photons in Fact?: doi.org/10.1117/12.2185010
* Rashkovskiy - Quantum Mechanics Without Quanta: arxiv.org/abs/1507.02113
* Classical-field theory of thermal radiation: arxiv.org/pdf/1604.05165
Episode 4 - Photons as Waves and Detection Events (with Chantal Roth)On Our Fractal Universe: A Conversation with Chris LehtoEric Dollards Transmission Line Element and the Principle of IncommensurabilitySquidsMandel(brot) Meditations : Just for fun. No music. Just visuals.Current FlowMichelson Morley Experiment : A Shocking RevelationQuaternions and Quantum Mechanics with Chantal RothRethinking the Photon: Motivation (A Silent Movie)Wave Action 2The Robitaille Files: On the Temperature of the PhotosphereThrough the Looking Glass : Simulating a magnet passing through the center of a ferrolens.
FractalWoman |

Episode 4 - Photons as Waves and Detection Events (with Chantal Roth)

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER