Uploaded April 2022 | Updated September 2026, 7 hours ago

---

Mary Gillespie a bus drive from Circleville, Ohio started receiving letters telling her to come out and admit that she was having an affair with superintendent Gordon Maddie. What would follow was an arrest, a death and multiple finger pointings.
Who wrote the Circleville letters?

Welcome To "Everything That's Weird" where we explore mysterious disappearances, bizarre worldly occurrences, strange phenomenon and basically everything that's weird.

Go to: everythingthatsweird.com

for hidden episodes, merchandise, and more!