EP#214 | CAN YOU TRUST MEMORY? @NotOnRecord
EP#214 | CAN YOU TRUST MEMORY?  @NotOnRecord
Uploaded June 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
**Sponsored by EasyDNS**
Move your domain or web hosting to EasyDNS and support Not On Record:
easydns.com/NotOnRecord
Use promo code: **notonrecord**

In Episode 214 of *Not On Record*, criminal defence lawyer Joseph Neuberger and Diana Davison examine the important Ontario Court of Appeal decision R. v. C.P., 2026 ONCA 333 and discuss how mental illness can properly factor into assessing witness reliability and credibility in criminal trials.

The case involved allegations of sexual assault against a biological father and raised complex questions about a complainant who had a documented history of hallucinations, delusions, medication non-compliance, and street drug use during the period of the alleged offences. The Court of Appeal was asked to determine whether the trial judge improperly relied on myths and stereotypes about mental illness when acquitting the accused.

Joseph and Diana explain the critical legal distinction between credibility and reliability, why mental illness alone cannot be used to discount a witness’s evidence, and when case-specific evidence of hallucinations, delusions, panic attacks, psychiatric symptoms, or medication issues may legitimately become relevant at trial. They also discuss third-party psychiatric records applications, the evidentiary foundation required to raise mental health issues in court, and why judges must carefully avoid discriminatory reasoning while still assessing reliability based on evidence.

This episode provides valuable guidance for criminal lawyers, law students, and anyone interested in how Canadian courts balance fairness, mental health considerations, and the search for truth in the justice system.

### **Chapters**
**00:00** Introduction to R. v. C.P. (2026 ONCA 333)
**02:19** Mental illness, credibility, and reliability explained
**04:21** Hallucinations, delusions, medication, and street drug use
**07:10** Crown appeal and myths about mental illness
**10:13** Evidence supporting reliability concerns
**14:29** Accessing psychiatric and therapy records in criminal cases
**16:11** Why the Court of Appeal upheld the acquittal
**21:34** Lessons for lawyers handling mental health evidence

Website: NotOnRecordpodcast.com
Sign up to our email list - eepurl.com/hw3g99 Social Media Links
Twitter: twitter.com/NotonRecord
Instagram: instagram.com/notonrecordpodcast
TikTok: tiktok.com/@notonrecordpodcast
Facebook: facebook.com/notonrecord
Telegram: https://t.me/NotOnRecord
Minds: minds.com/notonrecord

Audio Platforms Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/4F2ssnX7ktfGH8OzH4QsuX Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/not-on-record-podcast/id1565405753
SoundCloud: soundcloud.com/notonrecord
Rumble: rumble.com/c/c-842207
For more information on criminal law issues go to Neuberger & Partners LLP http://www.nrlawyers.com.
Produced by Possibly Correct Media PossiblyCorrect.com
#Podcast #law #MeToo
EP#214 | CAN YOU TRUST MEMORY?Not On Record REWIND | When Children Are Told What to RememberA Conviction Is No Timeout #substack #shortsOur ‘bloodthirsty’ view on sentences Not On Record EP#195 | Your Rights at Risk? A Lawyer’s WarningThats such bullshit, too. #substack #shortsJudge Cross Examined the Accusedneuberger august reel 6EP#212 | Can Dreams Convict?House Arrest Is Being Eliminated #substack #shortsWhy Family Photos Arent Proof #substack #shortsEP#234 | Massage Therapists and Sexual Assault Allegations: What Happens Next?EP#207 | 11th Hour Disclosure Blew Up the Case
Not On Record |

EP#214 | CAN YOU TRUST MEMORY?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER