Tim Gracyk | Enrico Caruso "Love Me Or Not" Victor 6015 (1920) lyrics by Thomas Campion, music by Antonio Secchi @timgracyk | Uploaded October 2024 | Updated October 2024, 8 hours ago.
When Caruso sings in English, he might as well be singing in another language. To put it another way, words sung in English by Caruso are not easily distinguishable.
Most songs sung by Caruso in English are forgettable songs--an exception is "Over There." He should have spent that recording session on one of the many Verdi arias that Caruso never got around to.
Love me or not, love her I must or die;
Leave me or not, follow her needs must I.
O that her grace would my wished comforts give.
How rich in her, how happy should I live.
All my desire, all my delight should be
Her to enjoy, her to unite to me:
Envy should cease, her would I love alone:
Who loves by looks, is seldom true to one.
Could I enchant, and that it lawful were,
Her would I charm softly that none should hear.
But love enforced rarely yields firm content;
So would I love that neither should repent.
Lyrics by Thomas Campion (1567-1620)
Music by Antonio Secchi
Recorded on January 29, 1920
Victor 88616 and Victor 6015
Caruso lived from February 25, 1873, to August 2, 1921.
He was born in Naples, and at the end of his life he returned to Naples, hoping to recover from illness but instead dying there. He did not live in Naples during his adult life. Caruso purchased the Villa Bellosguardo, a palatial country house near Florence, in 1904. Caruso's real home during his years of greatest fame was a suite at Manhattan's Knickerbocker Hotel.
The tenor made more than 260 recordings for the Victor Talking Machine Company. A sensation in opera houses and on concert stages, he is still famous because his records were incredibly popular during his own life and remained popular long after the tenor's death. Many singers of the twentieth century said they learned much while listening to Caruso's voice.
He was loved as the lead tenor in "warhorse" works--that is, in operas that stand the test of time, being produced often. But he also took risks, gambling on newly created roles (with no guarantee that the new opera would succeed) and also helping revive forgotten operas. He excelled in Italian and French role. His voice was not suited for Mozart or Wagner.
The tenor's first recording session was in a hotel room in Milan on April 11, 1902.
One month earlier, Caruso enjoyed a triumph in the premiere of Franchetti’s opera Germania. This led to the tenor making records.
On April 11, 1902, Caruso was paid by the Gramophone & Typewriter Company’s Fred Gaisberg to sing ten numbers into a recording horn in a Milan hotel room. The fee was 100 pounds sterling.
The story about the company saying the fee was too high is apocryphal.
The tenor sang to piano accompaniment provided by Salvatore Cottone.
Gaisberg (either Fred or his brother Will) wrote “Carusso” on early wax blanks.
You could say this session as giving birth to a new era. Before 1902, opera recordings aroused little enthusiasm since voices on discs and cylinders were distant, often drowned out by surface noise. Early opera recordings gave little satisfaction.
Caruso helped make gramophones respected because his voice recorded well (in addition to the tenor being a master of interpretation and having a voice that thrilled audiences when he sang in opera houses). Before 1902, recording officials had difficulty convincing celebrities to make records since the final product was crude. Some celebrities did make recordings in 1902 (Plançon, Van Rooy, Calvé, Scotti, Bispham, Renaud)--partly to earn large fees for little work, partly to satisfy curiosity about how they sound. But Caruso’s success inspired many others.
With the first Caruso discs available in the summer of 1902, the gramophone was suddenly more than a toy. That was Caruso’s contribution to the infant industry. Lovers of great singing realized that recording devices could capture and preserve great singing. Caruso’s voice on his early discs came across clearly enough to be satisfying, Caruso’s interpretations compelling.
Caruso had other Milan sessions. The next one (again for the Gramophone & Typewriter Company) was on November 30, 1902, with some titles recorded a day or two later (in December 1902).
Will Gaisberg (Fred’s brother--Fred himself was touring, making records in exotic locations) produced most of the Milan recordings of the November-December sessions. B. G. Royal recorded four of the recordings, and these have "-R" embossed next to the matrix numbers, indicating Royal as producer.
On April 19, 1903, Caruso made seven recordings in Milan for the Anglo-Italian Commerce Company. These were released as blue-label Zonophone discs. These are the first Caruso recordings to open with spoken announcements.
In late October 1903, three more titles were recorded in Milan for the Anglo-Italian Commerce Company. These were issued by Pathé in two formats: cylinder and disc. Opening spoken announcements on these three items are longer than on Zonophone since the company is cited.
When Caruso sings in English, he might as well be singing in another language. To put it another way, words sung in English by Caruso are not easily distinguishable.
Most songs sung by Caruso in English are forgettable songs--an exception is "Over There." He should have spent that recording session on one of the many Verdi arias that Caruso never got around to.
Love me or not, love her I must or die;
Leave me or not, follow her needs must I.
O that her grace would my wished comforts give.
How rich in her, how happy should I live.
All my desire, all my delight should be
Her to enjoy, her to unite to me:
Envy should cease, her would I love alone:
Who loves by looks, is seldom true to one.
Could I enchant, and that it lawful were,
Her would I charm softly that none should hear.
But love enforced rarely yields firm content;
So would I love that neither should repent.
Lyrics by Thomas Campion (1567-1620)
Music by Antonio Secchi
Recorded on January 29, 1920
Victor 88616 and Victor 6015
Caruso lived from February 25, 1873, to August 2, 1921.
He was born in Naples, and at the end of his life he returned to Naples, hoping to recover from illness but instead dying there. He did not live in Naples during his adult life. Caruso purchased the Villa Bellosguardo, a palatial country house near Florence, in 1904. Caruso's real home during his years of greatest fame was a suite at Manhattan's Knickerbocker Hotel.
The tenor made more than 260 recordings for the Victor Talking Machine Company. A sensation in opera houses and on concert stages, he is still famous because his records were incredibly popular during his own life and remained popular long after the tenor's death. Many singers of the twentieth century said they learned much while listening to Caruso's voice.
He was loved as the lead tenor in "warhorse" works--that is, in operas that stand the test of time, being produced often. But he also took risks, gambling on newly created roles (with no guarantee that the new opera would succeed) and also helping revive forgotten operas. He excelled in Italian and French role. His voice was not suited for Mozart or Wagner.
The tenor's first recording session was in a hotel room in Milan on April 11, 1902.
One month earlier, Caruso enjoyed a triumph in the premiere of Franchetti’s opera Germania. This led to the tenor making records.
On April 11, 1902, Caruso was paid by the Gramophone & Typewriter Company’s Fred Gaisberg to sing ten numbers into a recording horn in a Milan hotel room. The fee was 100 pounds sterling.
The story about the company saying the fee was too high is apocryphal.
The tenor sang to piano accompaniment provided by Salvatore Cottone.
Gaisberg (either Fred or his brother Will) wrote “Carusso” on early wax blanks.
You could say this session as giving birth to a new era. Before 1902, opera recordings aroused little enthusiasm since voices on discs and cylinders were distant, often drowned out by surface noise. Early opera recordings gave little satisfaction.
Caruso helped make gramophones respected because his voice recorded well (in addition to the tenor being a master of interpretation and having a voice that thrilled audiences when he sang in opera houses). Before 1902, recording officials had difficulty convincing celebrities to make records since the final product was crude. Some celebrities did make recordings in 1902 (Plançon, Van Rooy, Calvé, Scotti, Bispham, Renaud)--partly to earn large fees for little work, partly to satisfy curiosity about how they sound. But Caruso’s success inspired many others.
With the first Caruso discs available in the summer of 1902, the gramophone was suddenly more than a toy. That was Caruso’s contribution to the infant industry. Lovers of great singing realized that recording devices could capture and preserve great singing. Caruso’s voice on his early discs came across clearly enough to be satisfying, Caruso’s interpretations compelling.
Caruso had other Milan sessions. The next one (again for the Gramophone & Typewriter Company) was on November 30, 1902, with some titles recorded a day or two later (in December 1902).
Will Gaisberg (Fred’s brother--Fred himself was touring, making records in exotic locations) produced most of the Milan recordings of the November-December sessions. B. G. Royal recorded four of the recordings, and these have "-R" embossed next to the matrix numbers, indicating Royal as producer.
On April 19, 1903, Caruso made seven recordings in Milan for the Anglo-Italian Commerce Company. These were released as blue-label Zonophone discs. These are the first Caruso recordings to open with spoken announcements.
In late October 1903, three more titles were recorded in Milan for the Anglo-Italian Commerce Company. These were issued by Pathé in two formats: cylinder and disc. Opening spoken announcements on these three items are longer than on Zonophone since the company is cited.
