Uploaded June 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Does “calories in, calories out” explain why people gain weight?
For A Whole New Level, Gary Taubes breaks down why energy balance describes weight change — but doesn’t explain its cause.
- Energy conservation is a law of physics, not a biological explanation.
- Saying people gained weight because they ate more explains nothing about *why*.
- The same logic would say Bill Gates got rich by spending less than he earned.
- Mechanism matters more than accounting.
Does “calories in, calories out” explain why people gain weight?
For A Whole New Level, Gary Taubes breaks down why energy balance describes weight change — but doesn’t explain its cause.
- Energy conservation is a law of physics, not a biological explanation.
- Saying people gained weight because they ate more explains nothing about *why*.
- The same logic would say Bill Gates got rich by spending less than he earned.
- Mechanism matters more than accounting.










