Uploaded April 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Another round of questioning regarding the Labor government's pursuit of environmental water. And frankly, the answers I'm getting from the Department and Minister Watt leave me deeply concerned for our rural communities.
Here is where we stand:
I asked the officials exactly how much water they’re still looking to strip from the system. It turns out they are only about halfway to their 450-gigalitre target. By their own admission, there are still 229 gigalitres left to be recovered. That is a massive amount of water that will no longer be growing food or fibre.
I asked Minister Watt why he’s ignoring his own Labor counterparts in the New South Wales Legislative Council, who voted unanimously for a Royal Commission into water. The Minister dismissed the idea as an "expensive repeat," preferring to stick to their own reviews. It’s clear they don't want a truly independent set of eyes looking at the damage being done.
This is the part that should really worry every Australian.
The government is paying an average of $5,040 per megalitre for buybacks. Meanwhile, temporary water trading prices have jumped 250% over the last decade. They are forcing water prices to "ludicrous levels."
They claim they want "value for the taxpayer." The Reality? They’re outbidding farmers, forcing them off the land.
When I asked how much more taxpayer money is needed to finish these buybacks, they refused to give me a number, claiming it’s "commercial-in-confidence." Simply, they don't want sellers to know!
All Pain, No Clear Gain!
I asked them directly what exactly this 229 gigalitres will achieve that justifies gutting our farming sector. The answers were the usual bureaucratic fluff about "supporting variations in flows" and "waterbird breeding."
They are prioritising bird breeding over the survival of the towns that feed this country.
The government admits their "Sustainable Communities Program" is in such early stages that they can't even tell if it's working, yet they are charging ahead with buybacks that will be finished by December 2026.
We cannot allow "environmental outcomes" to become a suicide pact for regional Australia.
— Senate Estimates | February 2026
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/empty-towns-full-bird-nests-labors-priority/
Another round of questioning regarding the Labor government's pursuit of environmental water. And frankly, the answers I'm getting from the Department and Minister Watt leave me deeply concerned for our rural communities.
Here is where we stand:
I asked the officials exactly how much water they’re still looking to strip from the system. It turns out they are only about halfway to their 450-gigalitre target. By their own admission, there are still 229 gigalitres left to be recovered. That is a massive amount of water that will no longer be growing food or fibre.
I asked Minister Watt why he’s ignoring his own Labor counterparts in the New South Wales Legislative Council, who voted unanimously for a Royal Commission into water. The Minister dismissed the idea as an "expensive repeat," preferring to stick to their own reviews. It’s clear they don't want a truly independent set of eyes looking at the damage being done.
This is the part that should really worry every Australian.
The government is paying an average of $5,040 per megalitre for buybacks. Meanwhile, temporary water trading prices have jumped 250% over the last decade. They are forcing water prices to "ludicrous levels."
They claim they want "value for the taxpayer." The Reality? They’re outbidding farmers, forcing them off the land.
When I asked how much more taxpayer money is needed to finish these buybacks, they refused to give me a number, claiming it’s "commercial-in-confidence." Simply, they don't want sellers to know!
All Pain, No Clear Gain!
I asked them directly what exactly this 229 gigalitres will achieve that justifies gutting our farming sector. The answers were the usual bureaucratic fluff about "supporting variations in flows" and "waterbird breeding."
They are prioritising bird breeding over the survival of the towns that feed this country.
The government admits their "Sustainable Communities Program" is in such early stages that they can't even tell if it's working, yet they are charging ahead with buybacks that will be finished by December 2026.
We cannot allow "environmental outcomes" to become a suicide pact for regional Australia.
— Senate Estimates | February 2026
Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/empty-towns-full-bird-nests-labors-priority/










