Uploaded December 2025 | Updated September 2026, 2 weeks ago

---

Order our cocktail book: Home Bartending Mastery: Iconic Cocktails to build Skills and Drink Better geni.us/HomeBartendingMastery or direct tinyurl.com/barflybook

Recipe at the bottom. And for even more recipes and articles visit our website theeducatedbarfly.com

Shop our awesome dehydrated cocktail garnishes shop.theeducatedbarfly.com

Our Glassware in Collaboration Amehla
🍸 Nick and Nora Cocktail Coupes amzn.to/3oJKtHw
🍸 Coupe Glass amzn.to/3KEdv8B
🥃 Old Fashioned Glass Heavy Base amzn.to/2Yuv42Q

🍸 Top tools we recommend 🥄
Our Cocktail Book: amzn.to/3F76KJQ
Antique Style Weighted Tin Set: amzn.to/2YnjvHH
Barfly Measuring Cup Jigger: amzn.to/3j4jFfe
Barfly Mixing Glass (17oz): amzn.to/3iP1DNv
GE Pebble Ice Machine: amzn.to/3oRw2yl
Large Hand Juicer: amzn.to/3CLC50J
Y Peelers: amzn.to/3jDOASh
Home Bartending Mastery: amzn.to/3F76KJQ

Full Store amazon.com/shop/theeducatedbarfly

00:00 Our biennial Tradition
01:43 Why didn't we do this sooner?
02:14 Jeffrey Morgenthaler
03:25 Recipe starts here
07:24 Tasting Notes
08:28 Recipe
08:36 5 Year Old Eggnog
09:41 Holiday Shopping?

🍸 The Awesome and professional Bar Ware is supplied by Barfly Mixology Gear barflybymercer.com

📷 Instagram: instagram.com/theeducatedbarfly
💬 Facebook: facebook.com/theeducatedbarfly
💬 Join us on our Patreon for exclusive access: patreon.com/theeducatedbarfly

Recipe
Morgenthaler Eggnog
180ml Milk
120ml Heavy Cream
2 Whole Eggs
75g Sugar
2-1/2oz (75ml) Amontillado Sherry
2oz Tequila
Grated Nutmeg Garnish