Uploaded March 2025 | Updated November 2026, 11 hours ago
With egg prices on the rise, I tested two egg substitutes in my Bakery Style Chocolate Chip Cookies. Here's what happened:
CONTROL (Original Recipe):
💰 Price: $0.50 per egg, two used in recipe
🥚 Soft & chewy, bursting with butterscotch & vanilla flavor
BOB'S RED MILL EGG REPLACER:
💰 Price: $0.14 per egg replaced
✅ PROS: Cheap, vegan, shelf-stable, cookies were thick & attractive
❌ CONS: Dry & crumbly dough that yielded one less cookie (!), cookie texture was gritty & starchy, flavor was less sweet, and this product is only available at health food stores near me
PLAIN YOGURT:
💰 Price: $0.18 per egg replaced
🥚 Inspired by @theloopywhisk's book The Elements of Baking
✅ PROS: Cheaper than eggs, easy to find, staple ingredient in many households, slightly tangy tasty (pleasant fresh/grassy note) & appealing texture!
❌ CONS: Crumblier dough than control, baked texture was denser and doughier, not shelf stable, and contains dairy (not suitable for certain allergies/diets)
With countless substitutions available, which is YOUR favorite? Let me know in the comments!
Recipe: handletheheat.com/bakery-style-chocolate-chip-cookies
With egg prices on the rise, I tested two egg substitutes in my Bakery Style Chocolate Chip Cookies. Here's what happened:
CONTROL (Original Recipe):
💰 Price: $0.50 per egg, two used in recipe
🥚 Soft & chewy, bursting with butterscotch & vanilla flavor
BOB'S RED MILL EGG REPLACER:
💰 Price: $0.14 per egg replaced
✅ PROS: Cheap, vegan, shelf-stable, cookies were thick & attractive
❌ CONS: Dry & crumbly dough that yielded one less cookie (!), cookie texture was gritty & starchy, flavor was less sweet, and this product is only available at health food stores near me
PLAIN YOGURT:
💰 Price: $0.18 per egg replaced
🥚 Inspired by @theloopywhisk's book The Elements of Baking
✅ PROS: Cheaper than eggs, easy to find, staple ingredient in many households, slightly tangy tasty (pleasant fresh/grassy note) & appealing texture!
❌ CONS: Crumblier dough than control, baked texture was denser and doughier, not shelf stable, and contains dairy (not suitable for certain allergies/diets)
With countless substitutions available, which is YOUR favorite? Let me know in the comments!
Recipe: handletheheat.com/bakery-style-chocolate-chip-cookies










