Earth Block Testing @naturalhouses
Earth Block Testing  @naturalhouses
Uploaded May 2011 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Go to our Natural Building Blog where we answer questions.
naturalbuildingblog.com

Today we're testing the various earth blocks and earthbags that we've made over the last 2-3 months. We're going to weigh each sample, do a visual inspection -- for example, we'll test the hardness and look at it carefully. Also we're going to do a shear test. You see over here we have two blocks set 10" apart, and I'll stand on top of the block or on top of the bag. Also, I'm going to cut the bags open and then cut the samples in half so we can inspect the inside. We'll post the results on our Earthbag Building Blog. [Note: there's also a 4' drop test at the end, where samples are dropped on one corner.] I have to preface this by saying this is not a careful, scientific experiment. It started out as a fun thing to try. It was haphazardly done. Many of the samples were moved before they had dried. Many were left out in the rain. Two samples were totally destroyed -- the ones with the (rice hull) ash. So it's unfortunate, but this was never intended to be a careful experiment. So the test results are going to be questionable at best. But still, I think we can ... I think it's a worthwhile experiment and we can learn a little bit, so we'll see how it goes.

[They sound very solid.] This bag I had high hopes for, but it was not made very carefully. You can see the cracks that developed because the bag was not contained (constrained). It was tamped and kept expanding without anything restraining it, and it formed cracks. This was a bag with road base and extra clay. So this is unfortunate because I had high hopes for this. Obviously if you have big cracks it's not going to pass the shear test, I don't think. This one is the clay and rice hulls. You can hear it has a dull sound. It has good insulation. Again, it has some bad cracks. If we did this again, next time I would constrain the ends so they can't expand and cause these cracks. In an earthbag wall the bags are butted against each other, where these samples were not. So this was a valuable lesson learned.

[Shear test.] This is good news. The road base with extra clay is very strong even with those big cracks in it. This is surprising. Even the clay and rice hulls are holding my weight. This one is not nearly as strong. You can see the corner broke away as I picked it up, but still it has pretty good shear value. This is good news because the clay and rice hull block is passing the shear test. This is one of my favorite samples. It has a real good look and feel (it's lighter weight and has insulation). This is the vetiver clay with rice hulls. It's one of the best blocks. It passed the shear test. This is the adobe block. It's passed the shear test even though there were some cracks formed in it when I was making it.

[Drop test.] Note: the first three samples pass the drop test. The earthbag made with clay and extra vetiver did not pass the test. Both halves split apart, probably because there wasn't enough clay to hold them together.

[Cutting the bags open to inspect the core.] This is the bag with road base and extra clay. It looks almost like concrete even though the ends were not constrained. It's a very solid mix. It looks very good. This looks better than what we were using (entirely road base). The extra clay seems to make it stronger. [Note: extra clay soil was added, not clay.] This is the clay with extra rice hulls. This is good insulation, but yet it has a good solid feel to it. [Note: this turns out to be the strongest sample in this test.] This sample has clay and rice hulls, and you can see it's still solid. So it has some insulation and still looks good. This one here has more rice hulls.

[Drop test continued with earthbag samples.] Very good! No damage at all. It feels like a rock. [This is the earthbag with clay and some rice hulls that appears to be the strongest sample in this test.] No damage. This crack was there when it was made. No damage to this one either. Whoa! This was the road base with extra clay. It just busted apart. This is the road base with extra clay [second sample to confirm results]. Obviously it's crumbly.
Earth Block TestingLiving Wall 2Living WallBamboo Wattle and DaubVetiver Clay ResultsSecond Course of FoundationFourth Foundation BagSecond Earth Filled BagThatch PanelsUse Same Number of BucketsSoil PreparationSecond Bag Second Course
naturalhouses |

Earth Block Testing

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER