Uploaded June 2026 | Updated September 2026, 2 weeks ago
🥪✨ Earl of Sandwich has officially opened its brand-new location in Downtown Disney...and we were there to check it out!
Even with a long line, the ordering process moved surprisingly fast. You’ll still order at one kiosk and pay at another, and yes—Magic Key discounts are accepted!
Of course, the Holiday Turkey is still as delicious as ever, but the real surprise for us was the new Pastrami Sandwich.🤩
The pastrami is carved to order, piled onto soft marbled rye with Swiss, sauerkraut, and a dijonaise spread that lets the meat shine. At $18.99 it isn’t cheap, but it’s a HUGE sandwich with table-service quality.
🍪 And don’t skip dessert! We watched the team make the Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cookie fresh in front of us, and the cereal was still crunchy when we took our first bite. It’s massive, super soft, and definitely big enough to share for $5.99.
Our only real drawback? Seating. The new location has a much smaller patio and less indoor seating than the old Earl, so finding a place to sit during busy times could be a challenge.
Overall, though, this feels like a fantastic addition to Downtown Disney, and we already have a feeling that pastrami sandwich is going to become a fan favorite. 🥪✨
🥪✨ Earl of Sandwich has officially opened its brand-new location in Downtown Disney...and we were there to check it out!
Even with a long line, the ordering process moved surprisingly fast. You’ll still order at one kiosk and pay at another, and yes—Magic Key discounts are accepted!
Of course, the Holiday Turkey is still as delicious as ever, but the real surprise for us was the new Pastrami Sandwich.🤩
The pastrami is carved to order, piled onto soft marbled rye with Swiss, sauerkraut, and a dijonaise spread that lets the meat shine. At $18.99 it isn’t cheap, but it’s a HUGE sandwich with table-service quality.
🍪 And don’t skip dessert! We watched the team make the Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cookie fresh in front of us, and the cereal was still crunchy when we took our first bite. It’s massive, super soft, and definitely big enough to share for $5.99.
Our only real drawback? Seating. The new location has a much smaller patio and less indoor seating than the old Earl, so finding a place to sit during busy times could be a challenge.
Overall, though, this feels like a fantastic addition to Downtown Disney, and we already have a feeling that pastrami sandwich is going to become a fan favorite. 🥪✨
