Uploaded March 2023 | Updated November 2026, 1 hour ago
While livestreaming Batman: Arkham Asylum an alert came up screaming Caspers timing while Doug was sneaking up on a guard and it scared him. Yes, the Nostalgia Critic got scared by Casper.
While livestreaming Batman: Arkham Asylum an alert came up screaming Caspers timing while Doug was sneaking up on a guard and it scared him. Yes, the Nostalgia Critic got scared by Casper.










