Uploaded July 2017 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Whorf ignited a controversy when he claimed the Hopi don't speak or think about time the way Europeans do. Malotki wrote 600 pages to prove him wrong. Come explore Sapir-Whorf and Hopi Time! Do speakers of different languages have different concepts of time?
Subscribe for language: youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=NativLang
Be my patron: patreon.com/user?u=584038
~ BRIEFLY ~
After years of studying Hopi, one linguist wrote a whole book focusing on just one thing about the language: it's full of ways of talking about time. Of all things, why time?
Decades earlier, Whorf studied Hopi. Building on his mentor Sapir's ideas about language, thought and culture, he drew a provocative conclusion. Comparing Hopi to European languages, he told us that the Hopi have a vastly different notion of "time". To simplify, the Hopi think about time differently because they speak Hopi.
Hopi became the poster child for linguistic relativity or "Sapir-Whorf", the idea that language shapes your thoughts or even determines how you think about time. Watch as the big fish claims about Hopi time grow. See why Malotki and other detractors dismiss them. Then explore the resurgence Whorfian ideas about language from curious cases of fieldwork on the ground and results from the lab. Finally, meet the curious case of Yucatec, a tenseless language.
In the end, we'll see that languages do talk about time differently, but getting people to act as if they have fundamentally different concepts of time.
~ CREDITS ~
Art, narration, animation and some of the music by Josh from NativLang
Sources for claims and credits for imgs, music and sfx:
docs.google.com/document/d/1Jo0LZ6rcLpXfmd7yekZDCce_cGLA9T6PZa6rsXIDFmI
Whorf ignited a controversy when he claimed the Hopi don't speak or think about time the way Europeans do. Malotki wrote 600 pages to prove him wrong. Come explore Sapir-Whorf and Hopi Time! Do speakers of different languages have different concepts of time?
Subscribe for language: youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=NativLang
Be my patron: patreon.com/user?u=584038
~ BRIEFLY ~
After years of studying Hopi, one linguist wrote a whole book focusing on just one thing about the language: it's full of ways of talking about time. Of all things, why time?
Decades earlier, Whorf studied Hopi. Building on his mentor Sapir's ideas about language, thought and culture, he drew a provocative conclusion. Comparing Hopi to European languages, he told us that the Hopi have a vastly different notion of "time". To simplify, the Hopi think about time differently because they speak Hopi.
Hopi became the poster child for linguistic relativity or "Sapir-Whorf", the idea that language shapes your thoughts or even determines how you think about time. Watch as the big fish claims about Hopi time grow. See why Malotki and other detractors dismiss them. Then explore the resurgence Whorfian ideas about language from curious cases of fieldwork on the ground and results from the lab. Finally, meet the curious case of Yucatec, a tenseless language.
In the end, we'll see that languages do talk about time differently, but getting people to act as if they have fundamentally different concepts of time.
~ CREDITS ~
Art, narration, animation and some of the music by Josh from NativLang
Sources for claims and credits for imgs, music and sfx:
docs.google.com/document/d/1Jo0LZ6rcLpXfmd7yekZDCce_cGLA9T6PZa6rsXIDFmI






![Optimality Theory - is grammar about rules or constraints? Linguistics 101
A very short introduction to Optimality Theory, a linguistic framework that attempts to account for the grammar of human languages.
Traditional models of grammar rely on complementary, unbreakable rules. The outcomes (sounds, words and sentences) follow those rules.
Optimality Theory models grammar with ranked, violable, competing constraints. The outcomes represent the best candidates - the ones incurring the least serious violations.
This video uses the analogy of two friends making plans for the night. One employs rule-based reasoning, the other constraint-based reasoning. The video then goes on to analyze the simplified grammar of plural -s (pronounced [s] in hats but [z] in bags) using an Optimality Theory tableau.
For an academic consideration of constraints, rules, optimal candidates, markedness/faithfulness and tableau conventions, refer to Prince & Smolensky, Optimality Theory: Constraint Interaction in Generative Grammar, sections 1.1, 1.2 and 2.2 (15).
Music by Kevin MacLeod Optimality Theory - is grammar about rules or constraints? Linguistics 101](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/xsMea6QhLoA/mqdefault.jpg)



