Uploaded July 2010 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
mannythemovieguy.com
I was expecting "Dinner for Schmucks" to be a malicious movie. Its premise involving businessmen bringing "idiots" to a special dinner to be made fun of signified cruelty. So to my surprise, not only is the film funny, it also has a great, big heart.
Injecting the film with its much-needed humanity is the perfect pairing of Steve Carell and Paul Rudd. The comedic duo grounded the film in reality while making audiences laugh out loud.
Rudd stars as Tim Conrad, an ambitious and good-looking guy who is on the verge of asking his beautiful, long-time girlfriend, Julie (Stephanie Szostak) to marry him. Tim works at Fender Financial where his boss, Larry Fender (Bruce Greenwood), has noticed his business acumen.
In order to join the company's elite club, Tim must first attend the upcoming monthly dinner at Fender's mansion. But there's a catch. Each guest must bring a special individual with a special talent. In short, they must bring dimwitted folks.
Inspired by the great French farce "Les diner de cons" from the comic genius Francis Veber ("La cage ux folles"), "Dinner for Schmucks" is worthy of its inspiration. There's an underlying tone of sadness throughout the film that director Jay Roach ("Meet the Parents," "Austin Powers" movies) transformed into an all-out comedy.
This comedy through tragedy benefitted from the casting of Carell. The actor disappeared into his role as Barry Speck, an IRS employee and an amateur taxidermist. Barry gives dead mice a second life by dressing them in tiny outfits and placing them in miniature scenarios. He calls his works of art "mousterpieces."
Barry becomes Tim's guest where his mousterpiece is the centerpiece of the so-called dinner in "Dinner for Schmucks." The original French film did not show the mythical dinner but Roach and company created this scene for laughs and to bring closure to the relationship between Tim and Barry.
The script by David Guion and Michael Handelman has many funny setups and dialogue but I suspect the actors provided most of the hilarious lines through improvisations. One of my favorite scenes is another dinner (yes, there are many scenes involving food in this movie) where non-verbal action becomes the source of laughter. Tres French!
I like how "Dinner for Schmucks" succeeds in following French farce conventions such as mistaken identity, comedy of errors, and usage of deliberate absurdity. And both Carell and Rudd are game to instill these conventions to their characters.
Hollywood has never been consistent in adapting French films. For every successful "Birdcage" (based on "La cage aux folles"), there's a dreadful "Father's Day" (based on Veber's "Les Compères"). But have no fear French cinema fans, "Dinner for Schmucks" serves up a full-course of laughter.
Yet like many of Roach's movies, the female characters are mostly underwritten. I wanted to see the relationship of Tim and Julie from her point of view in order to understand his character better. Supposedly, Tim is doing everything, including begrudgingly bringing Barry to dinner, because of his love for Julie.
But the cast is the true stars of the movie. Zach Galifianakis ("The Hangover") even shows up for a memorable cameo as Barry's boss and nemesis. I also enjoyed the supporting cast such as Kristen Schaal ("The Flight of the Conchords") as Tim's assistant and Jemaine Clement, also from "The Flight of the Conchords," as the sex-starved artist, Kieran.
In the end, "Dinner for Schmucks" is a true testament to Carell's and Rudd's talents. They're enough for me to recommend making a dinner date with this film.
RATING: "DINNER FOR SCHMUCKS" 3 KISSES
mannythemovieguy.com
I was expecting "Dinner for Schmucks" to be a malicious movie. Its premise involving businessmen bringing "idiots" to a special dinner to be made fun of signified cruelty. So to my surprise, not only is the film funny, it also has a great, big heart.
Injecting the film with its much-needed humanity is the perfect pairing of Steve Carell and Paul Rudd. The comedic duo grounded the film in reality while making audiences laugh out loud.
Rudd stars as Tim Conrad, an ambitious and good-looking guy who is on the verge of asking his beautiful, long-time girlfriend, Julie (Stephanie Szostak) to marry him. Tim works at Fender Financial where his boss, Larry Fender (Bruce Greenwood), has noticed his business acumen.
In order to join the company's elite club, Tim must first attend the upcoming monthly dinner at Fender's mansion. But there's a catch. Each guest must bring a special individual with a special talent. In short, they must bring dimwitted folks.
Inspired by the great French farce "Les diner de cons" from the comic genius Francis Veber ("La cage ux folles"), "Dinner for Schmucks" is worthy of its inspiration. There's an underlying tone of sadness throughout the film that director Jay Roach ("Meet the Parents," "Austin Powers" movies) transformed into an all-out comedy.
This comedy through tragedy benefitted from the casting of Carell. The actor disappeared into his role as Barry Speck, an IRS employee and an amateur taxidermist. Barry gives dead mice a second life by dressing them in tiny outfits and placing them in miniature scenarios. He calls his works of art "mousterpieces."
Barry becomes Tim's guest where his mousterpiece is the centerpiece of the so-called dinner in "Dinner for Schmucks." The original French film did not show the mythical dinner but Roach and company created this scene for laughs and to bring closure to the relationship between Tim and Barry.
The script by David Guion and Michael Handelman has many funny setups and dialogue but I suspect the actors provided most of the hilarious lines through improvisations. One of my favorite scenes is another dinner (yes, there are many scenes involving food in this movie) where non-verbal action becomes the source of laughter. Tres French!
I like how "Dinner for Schmucks" succeeds in following French farce conventions such as mistaken identity, comedy of errors, and usage of deliberate absurdity. And both Carell and Rudd are game to instill these conventions to their characters.
Hollywood has never been consistent in adapting French films. For every successful "Birdcage" (based on "La cage aux folles"), there's a dreadful "Father's Day" (based on Veber's "Les Compères"). But have no fear French cinema fans, "Dinner for Schmucks" serves up a full-course of laughter.
Yet like many of Roach's movies, the female characters are mostly underwritten. I wanted to see the relationship of Tim and Julie from her point of view in order to understand his character better. Supposedly, Tim is doing everything, including begrudgingly bringing Barry to dinner, because of his love for Julie.
But the cast is the true stars of the movie. Zach Galifianakis ("The Hangover") even shows up for a memorable cameo as Barry's boss and nemesis. I also enjoyed the supporting cast such as Kristen Schaal ("The Flight of the Conchords") as Tim's assistant and Jemaine Clement, also from "The Flight of the Conchords," as the sex-starved artist, Kieran.
In the end, "Dinner for Schmucks" is a true testament to Carell's and Rudd's talents. They're enough for me to recommend making a dinner date with this film.
RATING: "DINNER FOR SCHMUCKS" 3 KISSES










