Uploaded October 2020 | Updated September 2026, 3 days ago
This is old news: but there seems to be recent surge of this case.
In summary, Zen Garcia, on his book "Flat Earth As Key To Decrypt The Book Of Enoch” had issued an open challenge to prove earth had curvature or is moving excess of 50 mph: and anyone succeeding would win the contest reward.
William Thompson felt that he had matched the requirements, and Zen Garcia failed to pay him the reward money. And thus the legal case began.
In legal sense, it was really to establish if William's proof has met the requirement to be eligible for the reward.
We will go throught part of the legal document; the proof presented by William; and why in my humble opinion, this challenge can never be won in a legal battle.
Enjoy.
Court Document:
rodscontracts.com/docs/legal/ThompsonVersusGarcia.pdf
My video on 8 inches:
youtube.com/watch?v=Dh1XxLgYGmE
Proof video 1 and 2:
youtube.com/watch?v=DdjB15AFaTg
youtube.com/watch?v=CSiYfsrfbcE
David’s Take:
flatearthdeception.com/flat-earther-nathan-roberts-scimandan-why-did-your-globe-lose-in-court
=============================
Table of contents
=============================
0:00 - Introduction
1:41 - Challenge with stipulations
3:05 - Back story Zen Garcia and William Thompson
3:43 - Case Document
4:15 - Zen's Legal Response
5:35 - Why William lost the case (my opinion)
5:55 - Other's view
8:24 - What was the issue with the proof
9:41 - How Flat Earthers are taking it
10:08 - Why is this an impossible challenge?
11:30 - Why Zen's stipulations are impossible.
13:48 - Other issues
This is old news: but there seems to be recent surge of this case.
In summary, Zen Garcia, on his book "Flat Earth As Key To Decrypt The Book Of Enoch” had issued an open challenge to prove earth had curvature or is moving excess of 50 mph: and anyone succeeding would win the contest reward.
William Thompson felt that he had matched the requirements, and Zen Garcia failed to pay him the reward money. And thus the legal case began.
In legal sense, it was really to establish if William's proof has met the requirement to be eligible for the reward.
We will go throught part of the legal document; the proof presented by William; and why in my humble opinion, this challenge can never be won in a legal battle.
Enjoy.
Court Document:
rodscontracts.com/docs/legal/ThompsonVersusGarcia.pdf
My video on 8 inches:
youtube.com/watch?v=Dh1XxLgYGmE
Proof video 1 and 2:
youtube.com/watch?v=DdjB15AFaTg
youtube.com/watch?v=CSiYfsrfbcE
David’s Take:
flatearthdeception.com/flat-earther-nathan-roberts-scimandan-why-did-your-globe-lose-in-court
=============================
Table of contents
=============================
0:00 - Introduction
1:41 - Challenge with stipulations
3:05 - Back story Zen Garcia and William Thompson
3:43 - Case Document
4:15 - Zen's Legal Response
5:35 - Why William lost the case (my opinion)
5:55 - Other's view
8:24 - What was the issue with the proof
9:41 - How Flat Earthers are taking it
10:08 - Why is this an impossible challenge?
11:30 - Why Zen's stipulations are impossible.
13:48 - Other issues
