Uploaded August 2023 | Updated November 2026, 5 days ago
Recent environmental guidance in the cultural heritage field reflects the increasingly important objectives of sustainability and reduced carbon footprint. New and revised guidance from organizations such as the Bizot Group, IIC/ICOM-CC, AICCM, and ASHRAE share common principles, including consideration of passive low-energy environmental control methods, adoption of realistic target conditions given the building envelope and exterior climate, and support for broader environmental parameters for many classes of objects.
Motivated by an interest in energy savings and security, as well as broad organisational involvement and buy-in for implementing environmental change, the National Gallery of Victoria (NGV) in Melbourne, Victoria, is adopting the Bizot Green Protocol (BGP) for its collection and for outgoing loans. Initial NGV trials of a transitionary ‘soft Bizot’ setting – temperature between 20°C and 23°C with 24-hour fluctuations of no more than ±1.5°C and relative humidity between 46% and 56% with 24-hour fluctuations of no more than ±4% – demonstrated reduced energy use.
The NGV and the Getty Conservation Institute are collaborating to examine object response during this environmental transition. In addition to visual monitoring of several works in the collection using macrophotography, acoustic emission (AE) monitoring will be carried out on a Flemish retable consisting of carved and polychromed wood and oil paint. AE monitoring is a highly sensitive technique that measures energy, in the form of transient elastic waves, released by and propagated through a material such as wood that has undergone brittle cracking. This has the potential benefit of detecting environmentally induced micro-changes in an object before damage is visible to the viewer.
Recent environmental guidance in the cultural heritage field reflects the increasingly important objectives of sustainability and reduced carbon footprint. New and revised guidance from organizations such as the Bizot Group, IIC/ICOM-CC, AICCM, and ASHRAE share common principles, including consideration of passive low-energy environmental control methods, adoption of realistic target conditions given the building envelope and exterior climate, and support for broader environmental parameters for many classes of objects.
Motivated by an interest in energy savings and security, as well as broad organisational involvement and buy-in for implementing environmental change, the National Gallery of Victoria (NGV) in Melbourne, Victoria, is adopting the Bizot Green Protocol (BGP) for its collection and for outgoing loans. Initial NGV trials of a transitionary ‘soft Bizot’ setting – temperature between 20°C and 23°C with 24-hour fluctuations of no more than ±1.5°C and relative humidity between 46% and 56% with 24-hour fluctuations of no more than ±4% – demonstrated reduced energy use.
The NGV and the Getty Conservation Institute are collaborating to examine object response during this environmental transition. In addition to visual monitoring of several works in the collection using macrophotography, acoustic emission (AE) monitoring will be carried out on a Flemish retable consisting of carved and polychromed wood and oil paint. AE monitoring is a highly sensitive technique that measures energy, in the form of transient elastic waves, released by and propagated through a material such as wood that has undergone brittle cracking. This has the potential benefit of detecting environmentally induced micro-changes in an object before damage is visible to the viewer.







![Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA) and its Role in Paint Tempera Dosimetry
Full Lecture Title — Invasive to Non-Invasive: Coupling DMA with DIC to interrogate the mechanical response of plastic composite objects during dynamic environmental management
Presenter:
Marianne Odlyha, Birkbeck University of London
Abstract:
In the ERA project (Environmental Research for Art Conservation) test tempera paint samples were prepared and some were exposed to accelerated ageing (light, heat, pollutants) and others were exposed in frames in major art galleries, a chapel housing a collection of artworks, and a historic castle where environmental conditions were recorded. The sites were selected on the basis of the wide range of environmental conditions. Analysis post exposure involved an interdisciplinary approach using mass spectrometry, thermal and spectroscopic analysis. The data obtained from DMA will be presented here. Tempera paint based on whole egg was prepared according to traditional recipes and then spread onto Melinex substrate. A selection of pigments was used including smalt, Sienna, azurite, lead white, and Naples yellow. Strips of the differently pigmented materials were cut to about 15mms and mounted in a frame for site exposure. For DMA analysis samples were then cut from these strips. Measurements were made in bending mode at 1Hz from -100°C to 150°C. The best response came from smalt tempera samples and this can be explained in terms of good mechanical integrity of the coating which is determined by factors such as pigment reinforcement and adherence to the substrate [1]. In chemical terms, a stronger response indicates the formation of a polymer network. Cobalt ions interact with egg yolk lecithins to form network structures composed of cross-linked aggregates which will increase the mechanical integrity of the film. The high pigment volume concentration in the smalt tempera sample is another factor that affected its mechanical properties. All the pigmented tempera samples used in this study contained, on an average, approximately 90 wt.% pigment as determined by thermogravimetry (TGA). Specific indicators for change by DMA of the paint tempera films were identified as changes in the glass transition temperature (observed as tan d peaks) of the paint tempera samples. Analysis of ageing effects was conducted by measuring either a shift in peak position to higher temperatures or calculation of peak ratios, based on 2 peaks, or the ratio of intensities at selected temperature regions (e.g. -20°C) and peak maximum. Data will be presented for smalt, azurite and Naples yellow samples and will show that differences were observed between sites with varying environmental conditions.
[1] Odlyha et al., Dosimetry of paintings: determination of the degree of chemical change in museum exposed test paintings (smalt tempera) by thermal analysis Thermochimica Acta
365 (2000) 35-44
This presentation was part of the Mechanical Insights: Shaping the Future of Museum Collection Symposium. View details and the full symposium program here: https://www.getty.edu/projects/mechanical-characterization-historic-artistic-materials/mechanical-insights-symposium/
Part of Getty Conservation Institute’s Managing Collection Environment Initiative: https://www.getty.edu/projects/managing-collection-environments-initiative/ Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA) and its Role in Paint Tempera Dosimetry](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/jyz3Ue6n32Y/mqdefault.jpg)


