Defending Substance Dualism with Dustin Crummett @EmersonGreen
Defending Substance Dualism with Dustin Crummett  @EmersonGreen
Uploaded June 2021 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Dr. Crummett and I talk about his version of substance dualism, the advantages it has over materialism as well as other forms of dualism, and some common objections to dualism. We also touch on panpsychism, idealism, dual-aspect theories, and the problem of psychophysical luck.

Dustin Crummett received a PhD from the University of Notre Dame in 2018, and he is currently working on animal ethics as a postdoctoral researcher at the Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich. He specializes in social and political philosophy, ethics, and philosophy of religion.

Dustin’s website dustincrummett.com

Micah Edvenson & Dustin Crummett on Socialism youtu.be/JFgGE5iLcKg

Dustin Crummett with John Buck & Inspiring Christianity on Dualism youtu.be/7ilENYcWqXo

A Deeper Analysis of the Problem of Evil with Dr. Dustin Crummett youtube.com/watch?v=507pU2JSJ7E

Is The Problem Of Evil Worse Than We Thought? Non-Alchemist & Dr. Dustin Crummett youtube.com/watch?v=sntpmX18bKw

Science, Mind, and the Limits of Understanding - Noam Chomsky chomsky.info/201401__

Can physicalism explain phenomenal consciousness? youtu.be/Q7jxTvJtqm4

Luke Roelofs - Combining Minds amazon.com/Combining-Minds-Composite-Subjectivity-Philosophy/dp/0190859059

Hedda Hassel Morch - The Evolutionary Argument for Phenomenal Powers philpapers.org/archive/MRCTEA.pdf

/ timestamps /

00:00 - 01:11 introduction

01:12 - 12:28 problems for materialism: conscious beings & consciousness

12:29 - 27:52 vagueness arguments against materialism

27:53 - 30:06 phenomenal conservatism

30:07 - 35:46 doubt and conceivability arguments

35:47 - 44:48 Phineas Gage & neural dependence

44:49 - 51:06 the interaction problem

51:07 - 1:02:05 ShannonQ’s objection

1:02:06 - 1:07:34 physical causal closure

1:07:35 the core theory

1:10:36 - 1:17:21 vitalism

1:17:22 - 1:23:46 where are all the ghosts?

1:23:47 - 1:27:46 split-brain cases

1:27:47 - 1:32:29 occam’s razor & the intrinsic nature of matter

1:32:30 - 1:43:19 panpsychism’s problems

1:43:20 - 1:49:40 idealism

1:49:41 - 1:52:21 non-reductive physicalism

1:52:22 - 1:57:40 dual-aspect theories

1:57:41 Dustin’s forthcoming paper on the psychophysical luck problem, James & Mørch on phenomenal fine-tuning

/ / /

linktr.ee/emersongreen

emersongreenblog.wordpress.com

Rate the show on iTunes here podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/walden-pod/id1474408172

Support on Patreon at patreon.com/waldenpod or /counter

Subscribe to CA and Walden Pod on YouTube youtube.com/channel/UCqBy2TfJbYXjqBL3cQOFUig

Follow on Twitter @waldenpod and @OnPanpsychism
Defending Substance Dualism with Dustin CrummettLivestream: Finite Theism, Evil, and MormonismSaved for having the right beliefs?Animal Suffering is Overwhelming Evidence Against GodDebate: Limited vs. Unlimited GodThe Moral Argument for God - Have I Been Debunked?What the ‘agnostic atheist’ graph gets wrongLearning About Mormonism w/ Tarik D. LaCourIs Mormonism the Least Plausible Form of Christianity? w/@thoughtfulfaith2020 @ldsphilosophy6015What would make atheists accept a miracle claim?  |  C.M. Lorkowski & Real AtheologyPanpsychism is OVER??? Responding to Skydivephil & co.Could you have been an alligator?  |  Philosophy of Personal Identity
Emerson Green |

Defending Substance Dualism with Dustin Crummett

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER