Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
A retrospective look at Dark Souls 3, the last souls game, and the beginning of the next step for FromSoftware
Go to buyraycon.com/aquaOPEN to get up to 50% off! Thanks to Raycon for sponsoring!
Edited by VFXShaun
Shauns Twitter: https://x.com/VFXShaun
Shauns Portfolio ytjobs.co/talent/profile/3229?r=333
Shauns YouTube Channel: youtube.com/c/PlaystayShaun
You can get videos early and support the channel by becoming a patron or a YouTube member!: patreon.com/thatboyaqua
Follow my Twitter: twitter.com/ThatBoyAqua
Join the Discord: discord.gg/VBJwTUa
Other Essays: youtube.com/playlistlist=PL0hudNq_z8tDAoBj0iR1bO2f0U8TRQDu8
Chapters
Intro: 0:00
The Chosen Ash: 1:00
Difficulty as A Feature: 3:34
Yet Another Swamp Level: 16:30
Bosses in Brief: 31:32
The End of Fire: 35:39
I have a complicated relationship with Dark Souls 3. When I first played it just a year after it was released, I thought it was simply ok. Then over time, I came to loathe it. To me, The third and assumedly final entry in the souls series epitomised everything that I felt was wrong with modern Fromsoft design, and when Elden Ring felt like it leaned so much harder into those design quirks, I retroactively disliked it even more. But recently things have changed; I’ve found myself coming to like, even love, the game, and while I certainly don't think it’s a flawless game, as fromsoft fans are prone to do, lets be honest, I think it’s a game worthy of its reputation, and this video will aim to discuss why the game has its reputation, where I think it needs to be looked at a bit more critically, and what the legacy of the game is now that it’s no longer the end of a trilogy, but the beginning of the next generation for fromsoft. This is how I came to love Dark Souls 3, and why, in some ways, I think I still hate it a bit.
The most prevailing theory of our player character in Dark Souls 3 is that they are a nobody, and the last hail mary from the powers that be. I think this is because there is an assumption that the ashen one had failed to link the fire, and thus, wasn’t good enough. However, I think certain dialogue lines support the idea that even if our ashen one wasn’t powerful enough to link the fire, they were still strong enough to get there, and that means they possess a base level strength that is greater than the average undead from Dark Souls 1. This is an important distinction to make because our character's place in the world affects how we view it, and in order to make a good game great, one of the things a designer must accomplish is putting the player and their avatar in the same mindset. When we were the chosen undead in Dark Souls 1, the implication is that we were a nobody, and had no grasp on the nature of the world and its inhabitants. For the player, the same was true, we hadn’t played the game before.
In Dark Souls 3, this is assumedly our third time in a Dark Souls game, and at least our second time in lordran, Thus, it’s fitting that our avatar is too familiar with the land. This familiarity is a big reason why Dark Souls 3 can convey so much through its world. To boil down the settings from previous games; Lordran was a dying world. The age of fire was coming to an end and its inhabitants were rotting away. Monolithic castles still stood tall, but they were empty, hollow, and their new purpose was to be a monument to a world long gone. Dark Souls 2 introduced Drangleic, a world that was forgetting itself. Like a land that contracted dementia, it knew of places, settings, and people, but couldn’t remember where or when. Its world made no sense, what was the sky in one place, was a pool of lava in another, and this was because the world itself was going hollow. Finally, at Lothric, we see a world desperately trying to pull itself together. Like someone who’s been lethally injured, guts spilling out, Lothric is frantically putting the parts of itself back together, and failing. Places are shoved in the wrong location, they can’t remember which order some place goes. Was it sunny or Anor Londo or snowing? And none of the lords are interested in helping.
A retrospective look at Dark Souls 3, the last souls game, and the beginning of the next step for FromSoftware
Go to buyraycon.com/aquaOPEN to get up to 50% off! Thanks to Raycon for sponsoring!
Edited by VFXShaun
Shauns Twitter: https://x.com/VFXShaun
Shauns Portfolio ytjobs.co/talent/profile/3229?r=333
Shauns YouTube Channel: youtube.com/c/PlaystayShaun
You can get videos early and support the channel by becoming a patron or a YouTube member!: patreon.com/thatboyaqua
Follow my Twitter: twitter.com/ThatBoyAqua
Join the Discord: discord.gg/VBJwTUa
Other Essays: youtube.com/playlistlist=PL0hudNq_z8tDAoBj0iR1bO2f0U8TRQDu8
Chapters
Intro: 0:00
The Chosen Ash: 1:00
Difficulty as A Feature: 3:34
Yet Another Swamp Level: 16:30
Bosses in Brief: 31:32
The End of Fire: 35:39
I have a complicated relationship with Dark Souls 3. When I first played it just a year after it was released, I thought it was simply ok. Then over time, I came to loathe it. To me, The third and assumedly final entry in the souls series epitomised everything that I felt was wrong with modern Fromsoft design, and when Elden Ring felt like it leaned so much harder into those design quirks, I retroactively disliked it even more. But recently things have changed; I’ve found myself coming to like, even love, the game, and while I certainly don't think it’s a flawless game, as fromsoft fans are prone to do, lets be honest, I think it’s a game worthy of its reputation, and this video will aim to discuss why the game has its reputation, where I think it needs to be looked at a bit more critically, and what the legacy of the game is now that it’s no longer the end of a trilogy, but the beginning of the next generation for fromsoft. This is how I came to love Dark Souls 3, and why, in some ways, I think I still hate it a bit.
The most prevailing theory of our player character in Dark Souls 3 is that they are a nobody, and the last hail mary from the powers that be. I think this is because there is an assumption that the ashen one had failed to link the fire, and thus, wasn’t good enough. However, I think certain dialogue lines support the idea that even if our ashen one wasn’t powerful enough to link the fire, they were still strong enough to get there, and that means they possess a base level strength that is greater than the average undead from Dark Souls 1. This is an important distinction to make because our character's place in the world affects how we view it, and in order to make a good game great, one of the things a designer must accomplish is putting the player and their avatar in the same mindset. When we were the chosen undead in Dark Souls 1, the implication is that we were a nobody, and had no grasp on the nature of the world and its inhabitants. For the player, the same was true, we hadn’t played the game before.
In Dark Souls 3, this is assumedly our third time in a Dark Souls game, and at least our second time in lordran, Thus, it’s fitting that our avatar is too familiar with the land. This familiarity is a big reason why Dark Souls 3 can convey so much through its world. To boil down the settings from previous games; Lordran was a dying world. The age of fire was coming to an end and its inhabitants were rotting away. Monolithic castles still stood tall, but they were empty, hollow, and their new purpose was to be a monument to a world long gone. Dark Souls 2 introduced Drangleic, a world that was forgetting itself. Like a land that contracted dementia, it knew of places, settings, and people, but couldn’t remember where or when. Its world made no sense, what was the sky in one place, was a pool of lava in another, and this was because the world itself was going hollow. Finally, at Lothric, we see a world desperately trying to pull itself together. Like someone who’s been lethally injured, guts spilling out, Lothric is frantically putting the parts of itself back together, and failing. Places are shoved in the wrong location, they can’t remember which order some place goes. Was it sunny or Anor Londo or snowing? And none of the lords are interested in helping.










