current community recipes have a high failure rate, so we need better @paulwheaton
current community recipes have a high failure rate, so we need better  @paulwheaton
Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
permies.com/thorns youtube.com/watch?v=kHQ27zwGo-4 We explore one of the biggest challenges facing intentional communities: drama. People often arrive excited and convinced they have found the place they will live forever, only to leave a year or two later exhausted by interpersonal conflict and slow decision-making.

The discussion looks at rules, guidelines, and especially how decisions are made. While many intentional communities rely heavily on consensus, that process can become extremely slow. One alternative discussed here is an "independent thought consensus dictator hybrid," where people are encouraged to act independently, talk with anyone directly affected, bring larger issues to the group, and escalate stalled decisions when necessary.

The larger goal is not to claim there is a perfect answer, but to document years of experience and experiment with a better recipe for community. If permaculture is ultimately about creating resilient human systems as well as ecological ones, solving the community challenge may be one of the hardest and most important parts.

KEY POINTS

• Drama is described as the number one reason people leave other intentional communities.
• New members often arrive extremely enthusiastic about community living.
• Within a couple of years, interpersonal conflict can become exhausting enough that people leave.
• One major question is how to deliberately reduce the amount of drama inside a community.
• Some rules can be explicit, such as restrictions on tobacco or drugs.
• Many other expectations are handled more as guidelines developed through experience.
• Decision-making structure is presented as one of the most important parts of community design.
• Many intentional communities use consensus-based decision-making.
• Consensus can become extremely slow when agreement is difficult.
• The model discussed here is called the "independent thought consensus dictator hybrid."
• People are encouraged to act independently when their decisions do not negatively affect others.
• If someone may object, the issue can be discussed directly with that person or brought to the group.
• If consensus takes too long, the decision can be escalated.
• The approach is based on lived experience rather than claiming to have every answer.
• The goal is to document successes, failures, observations, and possible improvements.
• Existing intentional community models are described as needing better ways to reduce drama.
• Other forms of shared living may offer useful lessons about how people coexist with less conflict.
• Community-building is presented as one of the biggest challenges in permaculture.
• Solving human relationships may be harder than many ecological or land-based problems.

0:00 Why people leave intentional communities
0:23 Rules, bylaws, and community guidelines
1:03 The independent thought consensus dictator hybrid
1:36 Searching for a better community recipe
2:19 Why community may be the hardest part of permaculture

▶ Stuff like this at permies.com:

Hugelkultur
permies.com/hug

plants, organic gardening, permaculture gardening, fungi and soil
permies.com/c/growies

giant hugelkultur (12 feet tall) at basecamp
permies.com/t/giant-hugelkultur

▶ Some of my videos that are kinda like this video:

▶️ planting seeds on our 12 foot tall hugelkultur - raised bed garden
• planting seeds on our 12 foot tall hugelku...

▶️ double or triple what you can grow in the same garden space with hugelkultur
• double or triple what you can grow in the ...

▶️ berms and big hugelkultur plus a quick dry stack retaining wall
• berms and big hugelkultur plus a quick dry...

▶ If you are into podcasts, here's a smattering of the podcasts I've put out on wofati and eco building:

Podcast 696 – Permaculture Smackdown 29: Hugelkultur
https://permies.com/wiki/273327/Podca...

Podcast 399 – Hugelkultur at basecamp
https://permies.com/t/89308/podcast-H...

Podcast 339 – Hugelkultur Listener Questions With Cassie
https://permies.com/wiki/55186/Podcas...


I now have over 700 podcasts about homesteading and permaculture
permies.com/f/88/podcast

▶ I have more freaky cheap things I will give to you for monies:

Roundwood timber framing
timberframing.net

Building a Better World in Your Backyard book
greenlivingbook.com

Low Tech Laboratory
lowtechmovie.com

▶ Sign up for our daily-ish email and get the 10 Podcast Review of the book Just Enough by Azby Brown for FREE

permies.com/goodies/147/y-0czf

Or other freebies
permies.com/goodies

▶ Thanks to my patreon peeps for pushing me into making videos again patreon.com/pwvids

Dr. Hugh Gill Kultur
Kyle Neath
Mehron Kugler
Bill Crim
G. Cooper
William Kearns
Bryan Beck
Bill Erickson
Tina Wolf
Eric Tolbert
Cheryl
Joyce Hunter

▶ All my stuff: permies.com/stuff
current community recipes have a high failure rate, so we need betterWhat to plant so that eating from your garden is 40x easierearly retirement extreme: the path to being mortgage freePodcast 744 – Organic Bananas – Part 2iterative earthworks projects:  plan, dig, change plan, dig, change plan, digOur attempt to get 25 years out of a pine fence post, the gravel sockrocket mass heater batch box doors: hinges vs plungewhat is a rocket mass heater?  (updated)The BEER Plan for Extreme Early RetirementOur best rock jack after twelve years: fence post on exposed bedrockPodcast 738 – Grow Our Own Food (GOOF) – Part 2Our attempt to get 25 years out of a pine fence post, the gravel sock
paul wheaton |

current community recipes have a high failure rate, so we need better

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER