Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 12 hours ago
A while back, I said that criticism is art. Just like how there are good and bad artists, there are good and bad critics. If you want to be a good critic, this thread is an example of what not to do.
// Holy F this is terrible
That is not a good criticism at all. That's just good old rage.
// Didn't insult the creators personally.
Sorry to say this but going "Holy hell this is terrible" to someone else's work that they put their time, money, or soul into is a pretty personal insult.
// I just didn't like the song and provided criticisms in replies.
Oh, do you now? What are those criticisms again? The song is flawed. Okay, how is it flawed? Are there any areas where the creator can improve? Do you want to elaborate why is it flawed? Or do you just want to have something to be mad at today, as you say here?
// Not all criticisms needs to be constructive.
Ah. So, you do just want to have something to be mad at today. What do you mean "not all criticism needs to be constructive?" They absolutely do if you want something to improve and be better. You are clearly not trying to convey any forms of "criticism," let alone a constructive one. You're just reacting. As you said, you just "have something to be mad about."
// People are allowed to dislike something.
Disliking something is not criticism.
// As a creator, you should be prepared for people to dislike your crap.
And as a critic, you should be prepared to get called out when your "criticism" is beyond flawed. Considering that you disabled the replies to this thread, you are not prepared to be a critic. You just, as you say, want something to be mad at today.
// If you can't handle that you shouldn't be making stuff.
And if you can't handle people replying to you, you shouldn't be on Twitter X. That or disabling the replies work too, I guess.
A while back, I said that criticism is art. Just like how there are good and bad artists, there are good and bad critics. If you want to be a good critic, this thread is an example of what not to do.
// Holy F this is terrible
That is not a good criticism at all. That's just good old rage.
// Didn't insult the creators personally.
Sorry to say this but going "Holy hell this is terrible" to someone else's work that they put their time, money, or soul into is a pretty personal insult.
// I just didn't like the song and provided criticisms in replies.
Oh, do you now? What are those criticisms again? The song is flawed. Okay, how is it flawed? Are there any areas where the creator can improve? Do you want to elaborate why is it flawed? Or do you just want to have something to be mad at today, as you say here?
// Not all criticisms needs to be constructive.
Ah. So, you do just want to have something to be mad at today. What do you mean "not all criticism needs to be constructive?" They absolutely do if you want something to improve and be better. You are clearly not trying to convey any forms of "criticism," let alone a constructive one. You're just reacting. As you said, you just "have something to be mad about."
// People are allowed to dislike something.
Disliking something is not criticism.
// As a creator, you should be prepared for people to dislike your crap.
And as a critic, you should be prepared to get called out when your "criticism" is beyond flawed. Considering that you disabled the replies to this thread, you are not prepared to be a critic. You just, as you say, want something to be mad at today.
// If you can't handle that you shouldn't be making stuff.
And if you can't handle people replying to you, you shouldn't be on Twitter X. That or disabling the replies work too, I guess.










