Uploaded November 2024 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Today I went to see a speech by Kim Murray, who released her final report about residential schools. Part of her focus was on what she calls “residential school denialism”.
She defines denialism pretty broadly – it includes minimizing the harm of residential schools, saying the death rates were typical for the period, saying that we don’t know the truth, that there is a conspiracy to exaggerate deaths, and that it wasn’t a genocide. And Murray wants to criminalize this speech.
This is a terrible idea. A lot is unknown, and creating a broad criminal sanction around this topic will not allow for an investigation to take place. Residential schools were a terrible policy, and to the extent that people want to minimize how bad it was, the stories Murray collected in her report are a better answer to that misunderstanding. Stories like experimentation on children, abuse, and disease. Those stories are the answer. Not criminalizing speech.
Today I went to see a speech by Kim Murray, who released her final report about residential schools. Part of her focus was on what she calls “residential school denialism”.
She defines denialism pretty broadly – it includes minimizing the harm of residential schools, saying the death rates were typical for the period, saying that we don’t know the truth, that there is a conspiracy to exaggerate deaths, and that it wasn’t a genocide. And Murray wants to criminalize this speech.
This is a terrible idea. A lot is unknown, and creating a broad criminal sanction around this topic will not allow for an investigation to take place. Residential schools were a terrible policy, and to the extent that people want to minimize how bad it was, the stories Murray collected in her report are a better answer to that misunderstanding. Stories like experimentation on children, abuse, and disease. Those stories are the answer. Not criminalizing speech.










