Uploaded March 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
https;//permies.com/hug In this excerpt from the hugelkultur webinar, I talk about a mistake I see all the time: people bringing in commercial compost or topsoil when they start building their beds. It sounds helpful, but in many cases it introduces persistent herbicides and other contaminants that can damage your garden for years or even decades. Because of that risk, I often recommend working with the dirt you already have rather than importing unknown materials.
Instead, the real power comes from mulch and biological processes. Thick organic mulch feeds soil life, protects moisture, and slowly builds real soil over time. Even simple approaches like Ruth Stout’s deep mulch gardening prove how powerful this can be. When building hugelkultur systems, combining wood with local materials and plenty of mulch creates a far more resilient system than relying on purchased soil inputs.
Key points
• Commercial compost and topsoil can introduce persistent herbicides
• Persistent herbicides can remain active in soil for many years
• Imported soil products may also contain unwanted industrial contaminants
• Lifeless local dirt is often safer than unknown purchased materials
• Homemade compost is excellent, but not required to start hugelkultur
• You can begin building beds without waiting for finished compost
• Mulch is one of the most powerful tools for building soil
• Hugelkultur without mulch often gives weaker results
• Ruth Stout demonstrated the power of deep mulch gardening
• Imported hay can also contain herbicide residues
• Local organic materials are usually the safest mulch sources
0:00 Why commercial compost and topsoil can be risky
0:18 Persistent herbicides and long-term soil contamination
0:46 Safer alternative: use the dirt you already have
1:08 Compost is helpful but not required to start
1:16 The importance of mulch in soil building
1:55 Ruth Stout and deep mulch gardening
2:26 Risks of imported hay and herbicide contamination
gardenmastercourse.com
▶ Stuff like this at permies.com:
Hugelkultur
permies.com/hug
plants, organic gardening, permaculture gardening, fungi and soil
permies.com/c/growies
giant hugelkultur (12 feet tall) at basecamp
permies.com/t/giant-hugelkultur
▶ Some of my videos that are kinda like this video:
▶️ planting seeds on our 12 foot tall hugelkultur - raised bed garden
• planting seeds on our 12 foot tall hugelku...
▶️ double or triple what you can grow in the same garden space with hugelkultur
• double or triple what you can grow in the ...
▶️ berms and big hugelkultur plus a quick dry stack retaining wall
• berms and big hugelkultur plus a quick dry...
▶ If you are into podcasts, here's a smattering of the podcasts I've put out on wofati and eco building:
Podcast 696 – Permaculture Smackdown 29: Hugelkultur
https://permies.com/wiki/273327/Podca...
Podcast 399 – Hugelkultur at basecamp
https://permies.com/t/89308/podcast-H...
Podcast 339 – Hugelkultur Listener Questions With Cassie
https://permies.com/wiki/55186/Podcas...
I now have over 700 podcasts about homesteading and permaculture
permies.com/f/88/podcast
▶ I have more freaky cheap things I will give to you for monies:
Roundwood timber framing
timberframing.net
Building a Better World in Your Backyard book
greenlivingbook.com
Low Tech Laboratory
lowtechmovie.com
▶ Sign up for our daily-ish email and get the 10 Podcast Review of the book Just Enough by Azby Brown for FREE
permies.com/goodies/147/y-0czf
Or other freebies
permies.com/goodies
▶ Thanks to my patreon peeps for pushing me into making videos again patreon.com/pwvids
Dr. Hugh Gill Kultur
Kyle Neath
Mehron Kugler
Bill Crim
G. Cooper
William Kearns
Bryan Beck
Bill Erickson
Tina Wolf
Eric Tolbert
Cheryl
Joyce Hunter
▶ All my stuff: permies.com/stuff
https;//permies.com/hug In this excerpt from the hugelkultur webinar, I talk about a mistake I see all the time: people bringing in commercial compost or topsoil when they start building their beds. It sounds helpful, but in many cases it introduces persistent herbicides and other contaminants that can damage your garden for years or even decades. Because of that risk, I often recommend working with the dirt you already have rather than importing unknown materials.
Instead, the real power comes from mulch and biological processes. Thick organic mulch feeds soil life, protects moisture, and slowly builds real soil over time. Even simple approaches like Ruth Stout’s deep mulch gardening prove how powerful this can be. When building hugelkultur systems, combining wood with local materials and plenty of mulch creates a far more resilient system than relying on purchased soil inputs.
Key points
• Commercial compost and topsoil can introduce persistent herbicides
• Persistent herbicides can remain active in soil for many years
• Imported soil products may also contain unwanted industrial contaminants
• Lifeless local dirt is often safer than unknown purchased materials
• Homemade compost is excellent, but not required to start hugelkultur
• You can begin building beds without waiting for finished compost
• Mulch is one of the most powerful tools for building soil
• Hugelkultur without mulch often gives weaker results
• Ruth Stout demonstrated the power of deep mulch gardening
• Imported hay can also contain herbicide residues
• Local organic materials are usually the safest mulch sources
0:00 Why commercial compost and topsoil can be risky
0:18 Persistent herbicides and long-term soil contamination
0:46 Safer alternative: use the dirt you already have
1:08 Compost is helpful but not required to start
1:16 The importance of mulch in soil building
1:55 Ruth Stout and deep mulch gardening
2:26 Risks of imported hay and herbicide contamination
gardenmastercourse.com
▶ Stuff like this at permies.com:
Hugelkultur
permies.com/hug
plants, organic gardening, permaculture gardening, fungi and soil
permies.com/c/growies
giant hugelkultur (12 feet tall) at basecamp
permies.com/t/giant-hugelkultur
▶ Some of my videos that are kinda like this video:
▶️ planting seeds on our 12 foot tall hugelkultur - raised bed garden
• planting seeds on our 12 foot tall hugelku...
▶️ double or triple what you can grow in the same garden space with hugelkultur
• double or triple what you can grow in the ...
▶️ berms and big hugelkultur plus a quick dry stack retaining wall
• berms and big hugelkultur plus a quick dry...
▶ If you are into podcasts, here's a smattering of the podcasts I've put out on wofati and eco building:
Podcast 696 – Permaculture Smackdown 29: Hugelkultur
https://permies.com/wiki/273327/Podca...
Podcast 399 – Hugelkultur at basecamp
https://permies.com/t/89308/podcast-H...
Podcast 339 – Hugelkultur Listener Questions With Cassie
https://permies.com/wiki/55186/Podcas...
I now have over 700 podcasts about homesteading and permaculture
permies.com/f/88/podcast
▶ I have more freaky cheap things I will give to you for monies:
Roundwood timber framing
timberframing.net
Building a Better World in Your Backyard book
greenlivingbook.com
Low Tech Laboratory
lowtechmovie.com
▶ Sign up for our daily-ish email and get the 10 Podcast Review of the book Just Enough by Azby Brown for FREE
permies.com/goodies/147/y-0czf
Or other freebies
permies.com/goodies
▶ Thanks to my patreon peeps for pushing me into making videos again patreon.com/pwvids
Dr. Hugh Gill Kultur
Kyle Neath
Mehron Kugler
Bill Crim
G. Cooper
William Kearns
Bryan Beck
Bill Erickson
Tina Wolf
Eric Tolbert
Cheryl
Joyce Hunter
▶ All my stuff: permies.com/stuff
 the twisted feels of being angry at good guys](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/zB8NYOK7zoQ/mqdefault.jpg)