Uploaded August 2025 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
The slime mold controversy is around the claim that slime mold is intelligent because it can solve mazes and draw maps. I (and many others) have argued that this is nothing like intelligence, as generally understood and as normally defined in animal behavior studies. Instead, what the maze shows is that slime mold is competent at foraging for food. We know how it does this. It uses chemotaxis and it uses mass flow for branch pruning. This is what Daniel Dennett called "Competence without comprehension".
"Competence without comprehension" refers to the ability to perform a task successfully without necessarily understanding why or how the task is accomplished. It's the idea that an organism or system can exhibit skillful behavior without needing to grasp the underlying principles or mechanisms. This concept is often associated with evolutionary processes and the development of complex systems, where functionality emerges through trial and error rather than through conscious design.
The slime mold controversy is around the claim that slime mold is intelligent because it can solve mazes and draw maps. I (and many others) have argued that this is nothing like intelligence, as generally understood and as normally defined in animal behavior studies. Instead, what the maze shows is that slime mold is competent at foraging for food. We know how it does this. It uses chemotaxis and it uses mass flow for branch pruning. This is what Daniel Dennett called "Competence without comprehension".
"Competence without comprehension" refers to the ability to perform a task successfully without necessarily understanding why or how the task is accomplished. It's the idea that an organism or system can exhibit skillful behavior without needing to grasp the underlying principles or mechanisms. This concept is often associated with evolutionary processes and the development of complex systems, where functionality emerges through trial and error rather than through conscious design.










