Uploaded February 2021 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Classical Foundationalism, by historically choosing only starting points that are incorrigible, ends up excluding the actual "starting points" in favor of beliefs we are very certain are true. They correctly identify some beliefs that we can know are true, but they aren't actually "starting points" that can be successfully built on. In failing to conclude that our actual starting points are "proper", you end up unable to have a pathway to rational belief in inferential justification at all.
More modern types of foundationalism don't define their starting points (aka properly basic beliefs) in such a narrow way and do not run into the same problem.
Classical Foundationalism, by historically choosing only starting points that are incorrigible, ends up excluding the actual "starting points" in favor of beliefs we are very certain are true. They correctly identify some beliefs that we can know are true, but they aren't actually "starting points" that can be successfully built on. In failing to conclude that our actual starting points are "proper", you end up unable to have a pathway to rational belief in inferential justification at all.
More modern types of foundationalism don't define their starting points (aka properly basic beliefs) in such a narrow way and do not run into the same problem.










