Uploaded August 2024 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
There are twelve lenses here and that means 479,001,600 potential ranking orders. The one we got, would have been guess 318,674,002 for me. These final results had so many surprises. The Minolta kinda just delivered C-grade results for most everything but key did not really tank anything, and it gave surprise a TKO to the Zeiss thanks exclusively to how much differently the two performed in image contrast. That the Zeiss, Yashica, Olympus, Canon, and Pentax round out the top half isn’t too shocking. Nor, frankly, is the fact that the Konica and Mamiya tripped over their own shoelaces, but Rollei, what happened?
But this is something that we saw in the previous showdown video, too. A middle-ground, or upper-middle-ground performer with a few top-notch attributes will likely be perceived, at least in a contrived test environment, as being a stronger overall performer than lenses that have some significant weaknesses, even if those weaknesses can be lived with by most people. But that said, in this case, the Minolta won this contest on the strength of the real-world test shots.
But I want to leave you with one other takeaway here. Two very important factors of lens image performance are purely subjective so I don’t test them in these videos – image aesthetic and blurry area character. The former is how does the lens create an image’s space, the look, mood, emotion, or handle subjects? The second is quite simply, ‘do I like the blurry areas?’ Were I grading these lenses on those factors, the results would differ a lot from the rankings above. For blurry areas, I like the Mamiya the best. Other entrants with great blurry areas include the Konica, Canon, and Zeiss. The Zeiss, also, has the best transitions from sharp to blurry and the best transitions across distances through the scene. For the manner in which a lens handles a subject, the Zeiss, Mamiya, Miranda, and Minolta are, in some order that would vary by how long it’s been since my last cup of coffee, the best.
Testing a lens on any kind of chart or in any kind of competitive comparison is only useful to diagnose lens problems and to understand fine technical nuances of lens performance. No chart will tell you if your lens will create good images because this is the truth of the twelve lenses in this video as well as all other lenses: they are all equally good and absolutely capable of delivering amazing results if you have the ability to find the subjects with which they work their best and create images that speak the story your subject wants to tell.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
youtube.com/channel/UCrZlzcRfCKLngZnqNTmTQjw/join
David Hancock's Amazon Author Page with Links to Select Camera Manual eBooks:
amazon.com/David-Hancock/e/B0B6DZCD9K
Full-resolution test and sample photos:
davidhancock.smugmug.com/50mm-1-4-Showdown
Video Index:
0:00 - Intro
0:12 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Showdown and Review
2:21 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Specifications
3:53 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Lens Diagrams
6:30 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Performance Comparison
19:55 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Video Use
23:06 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Ranking
Full Reviews:
Asahi Pentax SMC-M 50mm f/1.4 (Character in a Compact Body) | Round Glass Review
youtu.be/ggeBMJM5lzI
My Instagram:
instagram.com/davidhancock
There are twelve lenses here and that means 479,001,600 potential ranking orders. The one we got, would have been guess 318,674,002 for me. These final results had so many surprises. The Minolta kinda just delivered C-grade results for most everything but key did not really tank anything, and it gave surprise a TKO to the Zeiss thanks exclusively to how much differently the two performed in image contrast. That the Zeiss, Yashica, Olympus, Canon, and Pentax round out the top half isn’t too shocking. Nor, frankly, is the fact that the Konica and Mamiya tripped over their own shoelaces, but Rollei, what happened?
But this is something that we saw in the previous showdown video, too. A middle-ground, or upper-middle-ground performer with a few top-notch attributes will likely be perceived, at least in a contrived test environment, as being a stronger overall performer than lenses that have some significant weaknesses, even if those weaknesses can be lived with by most people. But that said, in this case, the Minolta won this contest on the strength of the real-world test shots.
But I want to leave you with one other takeaway here. Two very important factors of lens image performance are purely subjective so I don’t test them in these videos – image aesthetic and blurry area character. The former is how does the lens create an image’s space, the look, mood, emotion, or handle subjects? The second is quite simply, ‘do I like the blurry areas?’ Were I grading these lenses on those factors, the results would differ a lot from the rankings above. For blurry areas, I like the Mamiya the best. Other entrants with great blurry areas include the Konica, Canon, and Zeiss. The Zeiss, also, has the best transitions from sharp to blurry and the best transitions across distances through the scene. For the manner in which a lens handles a subject, the Zeiss, Mamiya, Miranda, and Minolta are, in some order that would vary by how long it’s been since my last cup of coffee, the best.
Testing a lens on any kind of chart or in any kind of competitive comparison is only useful to diagnose lens problems and to understand fine technical nuances of lens performance. No chart will tell you if your lens will create good images because this is the truth of the twelve lenses in this video as well as all other lenses: they are all equally good and absolutely capable of delivering amazing results if you have the ability to find the subjects with which they work their best and create images that speak the story your subject wants to tell.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
youtube.com/channel/UCrZlzcRfCKLngZnqNTmTQjw/join
David Hancock's Amazon Author Page with Links to Select Camera Manual eBooks:
amazon.com/David-Hancock/e/B0B6DZCD9K
Full-resolution test and sample photos:
davidhancock.smugmug.com/50mm-1-4-Showdown
Video Index:
0:00 - Intro
0:12 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Showdown and Review
2:21 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Specifications
3:53 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Lens Diagrams
6:30 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Performance Comparison
19:55 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Video Use
23:06 - Vintage Manual Focus 50mm f/1.4 Lens Ranking
Full Reviews:
Asahi Pentax SMC-M 50mm f/1.4 (Character in a Compact Body) | Round Glass Review
youtu.be/ggeBMJM5lzI
My Instagram:
instagram.com/davidhancock










