Christoph Benzmueller: Many Logics, One Methodology @ToposInstitute
Christoph Benzmueller: Many Logics, One Methodology  @ToposInstitute
Uploaded May 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Topos Institute Colloquium, 7th of May 2026.
———
This talk advances the case for logical pluralism at the object logic level within a unifying meta-logical framework. While modern proof assistant systems often enforce a single foundational logic — a tendency we may call logical imperialism — such rigidity impedes the kind of interdisciplinary reuse that robust knowledge representation demands. Our proposed alternative is LogiKEy: a logic-pluralistic methodology for knowledge representation and reasoning in which object logics are treated as first-class, analyzable entities, with applicability across many fields, including but not limited to computational metaphysics and ontology.

The virtues of LogiKEy are illustrated through a concrete case study: Gödel's modal ontological argument and Dana Scott's variant of it. Supported by experimental studies in a proof assistant system for classical higher-order logic, we demonstrate how the framework promotes interdisciplinary research and education on logical foundations and philosophical arguments, while also yielding new formal insights into these landmark arguments, and we address some questions accumulated over the past decade.

This is partly joint work with Dana Scott.

Reference: Notes on Gödel's and Scott's Variants of the Ontological Argument, Christoph Benzmüller, Dana S. Scott · Monatshefte für Mathematik 208, 569–611. Doi: doi.org/10.1007/s00605-025-02078-x
Christoph Benzmueller: Many Logics, One Methodology[Berkeley Seminar] Benjamin Brast McKie | The Construction of Possible Worlds[Oxford Seminar] David Jaz Myers | A modal proof of the nerve theoremDavid Ayala: Valent higher groupoids are flagged spaces, and consequencesThomas Powell: Quantitative results for stochastic processesMartin Kleppmann and Owen Lynch | Coln: proofs at machine scaleThierry Coquand: Constructive Models of UnivalenceBrendan Fong: Abstractions for Real People[DOTS Lectures] 10. LTL and specifications of behavioursAmar Hadzihasanovic: Combinatorial foundation for planar string diagramsRichard Blute: Quantum Finiteness Spaces[Berkeley Seminar] Nelson Niu (Topos Institute) | A loose Yoneda theory for equipments
Topos Institute |

Christoph Benzmueller: Many Logics, One Methodology

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER