Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Kaitlyn Schiess talks with Kate Bowler, American religious historian and author of the new book Joyful Anyway, about why so many of us feel pressure to be happy. They start with hope amid a frustrating political moment, then dig into toxic positivity, its religious versions, and why resilience is emotional flexibility, not constant cheer.
Next, they explore why we look for a lesson in every hard thing, how Christianity answers the problem of desire differently than stoicism, and how progress and decline stories shape the way we read our lives. They close with defining success on your own terms, why joy can't be scheduled during the holidays, and the questions about suffering and unmet desire they're still asking.
π¬ Kate says joy can't be scheduled, but it's more likely to find us when we let go of the scripts for how we're supposed to feel. What's an unexpected moment of joy you've had this year? Share it in the comments!
Articles and Books Mentioned in this Episode:
"Joyful Anyway" by Kate Bowler: https://link.amazon/B09pLSw8m
00:00 β Welcome to The Better Question
01:38 β What We're Watching and Reading
04:10 β The Search for a Happiness Plan
05:01 β Hope Amid Political Frustration
10:35 β Sponsor: Baker Book House - Check out How (Not) to Be a Tyrant from Brazos Press wherever books are sold! https://link.amazon/B0gwsDDDW
11:28 β Sponsor: With and For Podcast - With & For: Psychology and Spirituality for Thriving Podcast. Check it out now! pod.link/1712333330
12:31 β Toxic Positivity and "Good Vibes Only"
16:09 β Resilience and Honesty in Church
19:17 β The Pressure to Find a Lesson
21:25 β Desire and the Problem of Wanting
23:13 β Stoicism vs. Christian Longing
26:17 β A Priest's Advice on the Ache
29:05 β Sponsor: Tyndale House - If you've been longing for a vision of the church that feels more like family than performance, Interwoven Discipleship offers a thoughtful, hope-filled invitation: tyndale.com/p/interwoven-discipleship/9798898021405?utm_source=Podcast&utm_medium=Midroll+Ad&utm_campaign=Curiously_Kaitlyn_Midroll&utm_id=Curiously+Kaitlyn+Podcast+Ad
29:55 β Progress and Decline Stories
33:39 β The Shape of a Life
34:56 β Defining Success on Your Own Terms
40:12 β Seeking Joy During the Holidays
44:32 β Surprising Moments of Joy
46:10 β Unanswered Prayer and Unmet Desire
48:13 β Kate's Lingering Questions
Resources and Links:
β Join Holy Post Plus for bonus content, extended interviews, and much more! Sign up today at holypost.com/plus
π§‘ Support us on Patreon: patreon.com/holypost
π° Join the Holy Post Substack: holypost.substack.com
π Holy Post Website: holypost.com
π Holy Post Merch Store: holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
π Like & subscribe for more conversations on faith, culture, politics, and more!
Follow & Connect with Holy Post:
Instagram: instagram.com/holypostpod
TikTok: tiktok.com/@holypostmedia
X / Twitter: https://x.com/holypostpod
Facebook: facebook.com/holypostpod
#Joy #ToxicPositivity #KateBowler #FaithAndCulture #TheBetterQuestion #HolyPostMedia #HPM
Kaitlyn Schiess talks with Kate Bowler, American religious historian and author of the new book Joyful Anyway, about why so many of us feel pressure to be happy. They start with hope amid a frustrating political moment, then dig into toxic positivity, its religious versions, and why resilience is emotional flexibility, not constant cheer.
Next, they explore why we look for a lesson in every hard thing, how Christianity answers the problem of desire differently than stoicism, and how progress and decline stories shape the way we read our lives. They close with defining success on your own terms, why joy can't be scheduled during the holidays, and the questions about suffering and unmet desire they're still asking.
π¬ Kate says joy can't be scheduled, but it's more likely to find us when we let go of the scripts for how we're supposed to feel. What's an unexpected moment of joy you've had this year? Share it in the comments!
Articles and Books Mentioned in this Episode:
"Joyful Anyway" by Kate Bowler: https://link.amazon/B09pLSw8m
00:00 β Welcome to The Better Question
01:38 β What We're Watching and Reading
04:10 β The Search for a Happiness Plan
05:01 β Hope Amid Political Frustration
10:35 β Sponsor: Baker Book House - Check out How (Not) to Be a Tyrant from Brazos Press wherever books are sold! https://link.amazon/B0gwsDDDW
11:28 β Sponsor: With and For Podcast - With & For: Psychology and Spirituality for Thriving Podcast. Check it out now! pod.link/1712333330
12:31 β Toxic Positivity and "Good Vibes Only"
16:09 β Resilience and Honesty in Church
19:17 β The Pressure to Find a Lesson
21:25 β Desire and the Problem of Wanting
23:13 β Stoicism vs. Christian Longing
26:17 β A Priest's Advice on the Ache
29:05 β Sponsor: Tyndale House - If you've been longing for a vision of the church that feels more like family than performance, Interwoven Discipleship offers a thoughtful, hope-filled invitation: tyndale.com/p/interwoven-discipleship/9798898021405?utm_source=Podcast&utm_medium=Midroll+Ad&utm_campaign=Curiously_Kaitlyn_Midroll&utm_id=Curiously+Kaitlyn+Podcast+Ad
29:55 β Progress and Decline Stories
33:39 β The Shape of a Life
34:56 β Defining Success on Your Own Terms
40:12 β Seeking Joy During the Holidays
44:32 β Surprising Moments of Joy
46:10 β Unanswered Prayer and Unmet Desire
48:13 β Kate's Lingering Questions
Resources and Links:
β Join Holy Post Plus for bonus content, extended interviews, and much more! Sign up today at holypost.com/plus
π§‘ Support us on Patreon: patreon.com/holypost
π° Join the Holy Post Substack: holypost.substack.com
π Holy Post Website: holypost.com
π Holy Post Merch Store: holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
π Like & subscribe for more conversations on faith, culture, politics, and more!
Follow & Connect with Holy Post:
Instagram: instagram.com/holypostpod
TikTok: tiktok.com/@holypostmedia
X / Twitter: https://x.com/holypostpod
Facebook: facebook.com/holypostpod
#Joy #ToxicPositivity #KateBowler #FaithAndCulture #TheBetterQuestion #HolyPostMedia #HPM










