Choice vs Story in RPGs @judgemathasgames
Choice vs Story in RPGs  @judgemathasgames
Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Persona 5 Royal made me fall in love with JRPGs again. After years of chasing player choice in games like Knights of the Old Republic and Mass Effect, I thought I'd outgrown turn-based RPGs. I was very, very wrong.

In this video essay, I look back at how Final Fantasy VII got me hooked, why I drifted toward Western RPGs, and how Joker and the Phantom Thieves reminded me what I loved about these stories in the first place. Sometimes the moments that stick with you are the ones you couldn't choose your way around.

That sent me straight into Yakuza: Like a Dragon, Metaphor: ReFantazio, Dragon Quest XI S, and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33.

What game brought you back to a genre you'd given up on? Let me know in the comments.

Subscribe for more gaming videos and RPG discussions.

SPOILERS: Includes story spoilers for Final Fantasy VII and Persona 5 Royal, including Royal's third semester.

#Persona5Royal #JRPG #VideoEssay

0:00 The unexpected JRPG revival
0:46 Discovering Final Fantasy 7
2:59 The era of choice-driven RPGs
5:01 The cost of player agency
6:16 Rediscovering magic in Persona 5
8:29 The emotional depth of Royal
10:40 The power of linear stories
Choice vs Story in RPGsSanitarium - Worth Playing Today? - Judge Mathas Halloween Special (feat. Yung Mithis)What Is The Rarest Game In My Collection? | Judge Mathas QnAStar Wars Month Episode III: Revenge of the SequelsLegacy of Kain: Defiance - Judge MathasCall of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth - Judge MathasDeadly Premonition - Judge MathasStar Wars Dark Forces II: Jedi Knight - Judge MathasFreddi Fish and the Case of the Missing Kelp Seeds - Judge MathasPsychonauts - Judge MathasCold Fear: This Boat Is Not Up to Code - Judge MathasOddworld: Strangers Wrath - Judge Mathas
MathasGames |

Choice vs Story in RPGs

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER