Catholicism, Popes, and Homosexuality: A Defense @mileskdonahue
Catholicism, Popes, and Homosexuality: A Defense  @mileskdonahue
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Noah McKay, a philosophy Ph.D. student at Princeton, joins me to discuss his recent conversation to Catholicism, Catholic miracle evidence, whether the Bible predicts a succession of popes, and Catholic sexual ethics.

This interview is also available as a podcast:
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/103-catholicism-popes-and-homosexuality-a-defense/id1776277450?i=1000797734990
Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/6hfRMJHf1fwDifwfR7b7qB?si=80542df0948b40c3
Substack: mileskdonahue.substack.com/p/103-catholicism-popes-and-homosexuality?r=1pf1v9

Check out my Substack where you can get a paid membership because you're awesome: mileskdonahue.substack.com

To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating via Buy Me a Coffee: buymeacoffee.com/mileskdonahue.

Follow me on X: twitter.com/PhilosopherMKD

EPISODE CHAPTERS
00:00:00 Introduction
00:01:53 From Protestantism to Catholicism: the initial case
00:02:24 Craig Keener and the evidence for Christian miracles
00:04:35 Fine-tuning, the resurrection, and other arguments for Christianity
00:05:33 How Joe Schmid helped change his theological views
00:07:13 Marian apparitions, Eucharistic miracles, and Catholicism
00:11:18 Overcoming objections to Catholic theology and history
00:14:26 Why Noah initially rejected the papacy
00:16:24 The biblical case for papal authority
00:22:19 Scripture, tradition, and divine revelation
00:24:21 Does the papacy preserve Christian unity and truth?
00:30:11 Peter, Paul, and the case for apostolic succession
00:48:10 Can the Catholic Church really claim to preserve unity?
01:06:08 How strong is the evidence for Catholic miracles?
01:14:00 Can miracles override moral and philosophical objections?
01:19:07 Catholic sexual ethics, moral intuitions, and disagreement
01:32:37 What philosophical position is Noah most uncertain of?
Catholicism, Popes, and Homosexuality: A DefenseCosmology Doesnt Prove a Beginning | #15 Dr. Daniel LinfordCommonsense Views of Time Make No Sense - Tim MaudlinEven a Resurrection Wouldnt Prove Gods Existence - Stephen LawEvolution Does Not Undermine Morality - Michael HuemerDoes God Own a Watch? | Ryan T. MullinsIn Defense of William Lane CraigMichael Huemers New Argument for AtheismAn Unheated Discussion on Science, Probability, and InductionGod, Science, and the Multiverse | AAP Conference 2024Morality Does Not Point to God - David EnochWhat Is a Woman? | Tomas Bogardus
Miles K. Donahue |

Catholicism, Popes, and Homosexuality: A Defense

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER